Seems like you should just time them in similar conditions. If you fly a
course with pylons 150m apart, down and back, down and back, you'll find
that the small plane might be quicker on the first pass, but the speed will
diminish after that. The big plane will ultimately have a faster time.
They carry their speed better.
JE
--
Erickson Architects
John R. Erickson, AIA
> From: Brett Jaffee <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> Reply-To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Date: Wed, 07 Feb 2001 11:13:52 -0800
> To: Raymond Wong <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
> Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
> Subject: Re: [RCSE] bigger is better??
>
> 1.True, I'd say. I believe someone has posted previously on this. Something
> about a bigger plane taking long a longer time to cover ground as a fraction
> of its wingspan. In other words, a small plane may cover a distance that's
> equal to it's own wingspan in less time then a bigger plane that is moving
> faster. Since you tend to judge the approach andsize of the plane by looking
> at the wing, this causes the illusion. It also means small planes are faster
> proportional to their size, but not actually faster in absolute speed
> (assuming we are talking about similar large and small airplanes).
>
> 2. Maybe
>
> 3. Well, actually, the F-16 is slower then the Concord . The F-16 can't do
> over Mach 2 due to it's fixed engine inlet. The Concord cruises at over Mach
> 2.
>
> 4. Certainly, in some cases, but if we are talking about similar style
> planes with similar wing loadings , I think a a bigger plane will be faster.
> Note that 60" planes sometimes compete in Unlimited class MOM racing.
> Sometimes they win, but mostly it seems like the bigger planes are used.
>
> 5. Unless the lift band is really narrow and close to hill, I'm not sure this
> is true.
>
> Raymond Wong wrote:
>
>> I just got my first BIG model, a Miraj and a Hade. Is it my imagination or
>> is it really true, the 60inch Nemesis looked faster. most other pilots were
>> watching and they thought the Nemesis was faster too. My disappointment
>> didn't just stop there, the Nemesis seem to be able to climb higher too! true
>> or false:1. bigger models look slower than its actual speed, just like a 747
>> appears to be crawlling in the sky.2. bigger models look lower than its
>> actual altitude, because you can still see it at far.3. smaller models are
>> faster just like the F-16 is faster than the Concord.4. smaller models are
>> really faster, they never won a F3F only because they are not allowed.5.
>> bigger models will do better in bigger lift, smaller models will do better in
>> smaller lift.
>
RCSE-List facilities provided by Model Airplane News. Send "subscribe" and
"unsubscribe" requests to [EMAIL PROTECTED]