Le 07/03/2011 23:03, Tom Cato Amundsen a écrit : >>>>> 2011/2/9 Phil Hézaine <[email protected]>: >>>>>> There are dictations of 1 to 4 voices but sometimes i encounter a >>>>>> problem of overlap with the same pitched note in 2 different staves. >>>>>> I haven't checked the archives, perhaps you already know about this >>>>>> issue. If not I could join an example in my next mail. >>>>>> Would it be a solution in the future? > > I think the MIDI code in 3.19.4 fixes this. Let me know if there are > more problems.
Until now all is right, Tom. Many thanks for your GNU work. ;-) > Btw, how do you expect the user to use the chorals? If you have > specific ideas not possible with the current exercise modules, then I > can adapt them, or add new modules. > > Is a common use similar to this? > * User select a choral > * User select which voices to play > * User transcribes the music played > * User displays and compares the music on the screen with his/hers paper Yes, it is. If you play the rules. > Another useful use would be sight-singing. The program displays one or > more voices and the user should sing one of the voices. But you can already do this if you change the rules of the game. > Maybe we need a gui with a check button for each voice, so the user > don't have to click the back/forward buttons to get the desired set of > voices? Alt least the main window changing size when pressing the > forward button right now is pretty annoying. I agree about this. It seems more modular and flexible. > If you think this make sense, I can create a modified dictation module > that does this, and also handles staffs and voices, so that the lesson > file only need to contain one copy of each voice. I'm sure I can > script changes to the lesson files, so we don't have to manually edit > all of them, unless you already have them in an even more python > friendly format. If we do this, the program should display the music > on two staffs with a violin and bass clef as expected. I'm not at all a dev and I wasn't working with python but only with my little knowledge of gvim. As a matter of fact I began each file with the 4 voices implemented. Then I was copying 8 times the same question and deleting the useless voices for each question. Your idea is very good but IMHO don't be bored with a script change to avoid to manually edit the files. If I understand your purpose very well the 4 voices already are written at the end of the file. It won't be a huge problem to update my files to fit your idea, I think. But I don't agree at all with the display of music on two staves. It's not a right way for a dictation or a chorus display. For instance think of a chorus of Claude Le Jeune, Gesualdo or whatever, if the voices intersect each other, and even worse, between two staves of a system, what a nightmare. On the other hand may be a feature about the display of a clef in accordance with the user wishes wouldn't be out of interest. My 2 cents. All the best. Phil. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------ What You Don't Know About Data Connectivity CAN Hurt You This paper provides an overview of data connectivity, details its effect on application quality, and explores various alternative solutions. http://p.sf.net/sfu/progress-d2d _______________________________________________ Solfege-devel mailing list To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to [email protected] with a subject of "unsubscribe", or visit https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/solfege-devel
