On Nov 10, 2008, at 3:52 PM, Tricia Williams wrote:

Hi,

I am just wondering what the status of these issues (SOLR-139 and SOLR-828) is for supporting updateable/modifiable documents. Specifically

  * Is anyone is clinging to an update of the SOLR-139 patch?
    
(https://issues.apache.org/jira/secure/attachment/12379550/Eriks-ModifiableDocument.patch
    from 2008-04-07 doesn't apply cleanly anymore)
* Where do people think this is at in terms of the completed solution?
  * Is SOLR-828 seeking to replace SOLR-139?


If you want something to work now, take the SOLR-828 approach. (I have a working version of 139, but it is really ugly and not something I would recommend using)

As for the future of this, I think the basic design needs some thought. I *think* we need to introduce a pluggable 'storedDocumentLoader'; the default implementation could load the document from stored fields other implementations could load from SQL, disk or whatever. Given the concurrency issues, I think this needs to be done within the DirectUpdateHandler rather then an UpdateProcessor.

My current work does not require modifiable documents, so I have not focused on it much...

ryan

Reply via email to