On Sep 27, 2009, at 2:56 PM, Chris Hostetter wrote:
: > On S-1294, the SolrJS patch, I yet again have concerns about
even including
: > this, given the lack of activity (from Matthias, the original
author and
...
: > true for others too. At a minimum, I think S-1294 should be
pushed to 1.5.
: > Next up, I think we consider pulling SolrJS from the release,
but keeping it
: > in trunk and officially releasing it with either 1.5 or 1.4.1,
assuming its
: > gotten some love in the meantime. If by then it has no love, I
vote we
: > remove it and let the fork maintain it and point people there.
If we leave SolrJS in the release, then i can't imagine any reason
why the
patch in SOLR-1294 shouldn't be committed ... no one is going to
step up
and help maintain it if we aren't committing the patches that people
offer
to improve it.
Yes, but no committers have stepped up and said whether the patch is
any good. Ryan mentioned taking it, but that was two weeks ago.
That said: as a client that isn't tightly coupled to the Solr
Interals, if
there's already a better SolrJS fork out there that has a community
actively maintaining it, then I don't see a strong reason for us to
start
including SolrJS in 1.4.
Summary...
+0 on SolrJS being in 1.4
+1 on SOLR-1294 being in 1.4 if SolrJS is in 1.4
-Hoss
