Also, it will help if you can mention the exact version of solrcloud you are
talking about in each issue - I know you have one from the old branch, and I
assume a version off trunk you are playing with - so a heads up on which and if
trunk, what rev or day will help in the case that I'm trying to dupe issues
that have been addressed.
- Mark
On Feb 10, 2012, at 6:09 PM, Mark Miller wrote:
> I'm trying, but so far I don't see anything. I'll have to try and mimic your
> setup closer it seems.
>
> I tried starting up 6 solr instances on different ports as 2 shards, each
> with a replication factor of 3.
>
> Then I indexed 20k documents to the cluster and verified doc counts.
>
> Then I shutdown all the replicas so that only one instance served each shard.
>
> Then I indexed 20k documents to the cluster.
>
> Then I started the downed nodes and verified that they where in a recovery
> state.
>
> After enough time went by I checked and verified document counts on each
> instance - they where as expected.
>
> I guess next I can try a similar experiment using multiple cores, but if you
> notice anything that stands out that is largely different in what you are
> doing, let me know.
>
> The cores that are behind, does it say they are down, recovering, or active
> in zookeeper?
>
> On Feb 10, 2012, at 4:48 PM, Jamie Johnson wrote:
>
>> Sorry for pinging this again, is more information needed on this? I
>> can provide more details but am not sure what to provide.
>>
>> On Fri, Feb 10, 2012 at 10:26 AM, Jamie Johnson <jej2...@gmail.com> wrote:
>>> Sorry, I shut down the full solr instance.
>>>
>>> On Fri, Feb 10, 2012 at 9:42 AM, Mark Miller <markrmil...@gmail.com> wrote:
>>>> Can you explain a little more how you doing this? How are you bringing the
>>>> cores down and then back up? Shutting down a full solr instance, unloading
>>>> the core?
>>>>
>>>> On Feb 10, 2012, at 9:33 AM, Jamie Johnson wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> I know that the latest Solr Cloud doesn't use standard replication but
>>>>> I have a question about how it appears to be working. I currently
>>>>> have the following cluster state
>>>>>
>>>>> {"collection1":{
>>>>> "slice1":{
>>>>> "JamiesMac.local:8501_solr_slice1_shard1":{
>>>>> "shard_id":"slice1",
>>>>> "state":"active",
>>>>> "core":"slice1_shard1",
>>>>> "collection":"collection1",
>>>>> "node_name":"JamiesMac.local:8501_solr",
>>>>> "base_url":"http://JamiesMac.local:8501/solr"},
>>>>> "JamiesMac.local:8502_solr_slice1_shard2":{
>>>>> "shard_id":"slice1",
>>>>> "state":"active",
>>>>> "core":"slice1_shard2",
>>>>> "collection":"collection1",
>>>>> "node_name":"JamiesMac.local:8502_solr",
>>>>> "base_url":"http://JamiesMac.local:8502/solr"},
>>>>> "jamiesmac:8501_solr_slice1_shard1":{
>>>>> "shard_id":"slice1",
>>>>> "state":"down",
>>>>> "core":"slice1_shard1",
>>>>> "collection":"collection1",
>>>>> "node_name":"jamiesmac:8501_solr",
>>>>> "base_url":"http://jamiesmac:8501/solr"},
>>>>> "jamiesmac:8502_solr_slice1_shard2":{
>>>>> "shard_id":"slice1",
>>>>> "leader":"true",
>>>>> "state":"active",
>>>>> "core":"slice1_shard2",
>>>>> "collection":"collection1",
>>>>> "node_name":"jamiesmac:8502_solr",
>>>>> "base_url":"http://jamiesmac:8502/solr"}},
>>>>> "slice2":{
>>>>> "JamiesMac.local:8501_solr_slice2_shard2":{
>>>>> "shard_id":"slice2",
>>>>> "state":"active",
>>>>> "core":"slice2_shard2",
>>>>> "collection":"collection1",
>>>>> "node_name":"JamiesMac.local:8501_solr",
>>>>> "base_url":"http://JamiesMac.local:8501/solr"},
>>>>> "JamiesMac.local:8502_solr_slice2_shard1":{
>>>>> "shard_id":"slice2",
>>>>> "state":"active",
>>>>> "core":"slice2_shard1",
>>>>> "collection":"collection1",
>>>>> "node_name":"JamiesMac.local:8502_solr",
>>>>> "base_url":"http://JamiesMac.local:8502/solr"},
>>>>> "jamiesmac:8501_solr_slice2_shard2":{
>>>>> "shard_id":"slice2",
>>>>> "state":"down",
>>>>> "core":"slice2_shard2",
>>>>> "collection":"collection1",
>>>>> "node_name":"jamiesmac:8501_solr",
>>>>> "base_url":"http://jamiesmac:8501/solr"},
>>>>> "jamiesmac:8502_solr_slice2_shard1":{
>>>>> "shard_id":"slice2",
>>>>> "leader":"true",
>>>>> "state":"active",
>>>>> "core":"slice2_shard1",
>>>>> "collection":"collection1",
>>>>> "node_name":"jamiesmac:8502_solr",
>>>>> "base_url":"http://jamiesmac:8502/solr"}}}}
>>>>>
>>>>> I then added some docs to the following shards using SolrJ
>>>>> http://localhost:8502/solr/slice2_shard1
>>>>> http://localhost:8502/solr/slice1_shard2
>>>>>
>>>>> I then bring back up the other cores and I don't see replication
>>>>> happening. Looking at the stats for each core I see that on the 8501
>>>>> instance (the instance that was off) the number of docs is 0, so I've
>>>>> clearly set something up incorrectly. Any help on this would be
>>>>> greatly appreciated.
>>>>
>>>> - Mark Miller
>>>> lucidimagination.com
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>
> - Mark Miller
> lucidimagination.com
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
- Mark Miller
lucidimagination.com
