Failed state symptomatic of reactionary leadership .

Photo: The New York Times

 .By Jacob K. Lupai

Introduction

February 22, 2012 (SSNA) -- A statement that a failed state is
symptomatic of reactionary leadership is likely to be received with
mixed emotions. Eye brows may be raised in anticipation of further
elaboration. However, a critical analysis of realities on the ground
may increase an understanding of the extent to which a failed state is
symptomatic of reactionary leadership.

People in the world are of multi-racial, multi-ethnic, multi-cultural
and multi-religious societies. It is therefore not difficult to
comprehend what the root causes of internal conflicts in a society may
be. The root cause of internal conflicts is the lack of sensitivity to
the differences within the society. There is always the unfair power
and wealth sharing among the different groups. For example, one ethnic
group may always try at any cost to maintain a dominant grip on power
and wealth to the exclusion of others.

A challenge to such ethnic domination is considered by those in power
as a threat to national unity. However, such tricks for ethnic
domination disguised as endeavours for national unity are a deceptive
cover for ethnic hegemony. This brings in the concept of reactionary
leadership in relation to the extent to which a state becomes a failed
state in the context of Sub Saharan Africa.

Characteristics of a failed state

It may be interesting to know what the characteristics of a failed
state are. Foremost the glaring characteristic of a failed state is
the absolute breakdown of rule of law and order. Many factors
contribute to breakdown of rule of law and order. Human rights
violation is one factor when it occurs in a scale that the system is
unable to cope with and the subsequent massive reaction of those whose
human rights are being violated that each takes the law into their
hands. Another important factor is when heinous crimes are being
perpetually committed and the system is unable to bring the
perpetrators to justice leaving the victims with the perception that
the state has failed them. One factor is the absolute lack of
discipline in the system where juniors blatantly defy orders from
seniors or from above. The management of the system is in shambles as
indiscipline is rampant. Absolute irregularities in finances make the
system to be heavily infested with greedy and corrupt money grabbers.

One important characteristic of a failed state are tribal or clan wars
and also religious wars. Somalia in the Horn of Africa is a typical
example of a failed state because of clan and religious wars. Recently
radical Islamists have entered the scene in consolidating Somalia as
indeed a failed state. In the final analysis a failed state is
characterized by the absolute lack of a robust central system that can
cope with all sorts of scenarios. The system itself may become part of
the problem. This could be because the system was nothing but a
composition of reactionaries involved in all sorts of things ranging
from land and money grabbing to turning a blind eye to criminal
activities because of vested interest. Naturally this wouldn’t be the
way to build a nation.

Reactionary leadership

The word reactionary may be defined as tending to oppose especially
political change to return to the former system. Reactionary
leadership may therefore be seen as opposing reforms. In a country
considered to be multi-ethnic, multi-cultural and multi-religious
reforms are inevitable for flexibility in accommodating diversities in
nation-building. People fight a liberation war for a political change
but not to return to the old system of oppression. Reactionary
leadership tends to live in the dream world of the past. It is
therefore not strange to associate a failed state with reactionary
leadership that does not look beyond their noses. Mohamed Siyaad Barre
of Somalia was probably a reactionary leader who contributed greatly
to Somalia now being a failed state. He was instead paranoid of the
unity of Somalia. Siyaad Barre increasingly personal and repressive
rule did not bring in the necessary reforms to address the challenges
facing his government. Ultimately Siyaad Barre’s repressive rule
brought Somalia into a non-state situation people see today. Siyaad
Barre’s reactionary leadership of turning clans against each other has
made Somalia a failed state by all standards. The Somalia’s situation
may offer a lesson to others in nation-building.

Revolutionary leadership

The word revolutionary involves great and often violent change or
innovation and to innovate is to bring in new methods or ideas to make
changes. It can be seen that revolutionary leadership is associated
with change and innovation. This suggests that a revolutionary is
creative and innovative unlike the somewhat backward looking
reactionary. A revolutionary does not accept fossilised principles as
a faith but a developing and creative science that reflects objective
reality. They scrutinise reality, studying all aspects and developing
theoretical conclusions to bring them in line with requirements of
life on the ground. In short revolutionaries base their actions on
scientific analysis and objective reality in addressing challenges.
This is in contrast to the utopia of reactionaries who are whimsical
in their actions. Reactionaries may rely on daydreaming in addressing
challenges. In most case they get it wrong because of poor targeting
and being unrealistic where challenges are not properly addressed. It
is therefore no wonder that when the leadership is reactionary
progression to a failed state situation may be rapid. Dynamic,
progressive and revolutionary leadership may fare better in addressing
challenges than reactionary leadership.

Choice to make

The choice here is between reactionary and revolutionary leadership.
However, it is not so simplistic. There is no black and white dividing
line between reactionary and revolutionary leadership. There are
elements of both reactionary and revolutionary in a leader. It may be
the degree to which one is inclined to either be a reactionary and
revolutionary. Formation of political parties may give a clue as to
whether they are reactionary and revolutionary. This may be revealed
in their respective manifestos. However, manifestos may mostly reveal
intentions of future course of action but not necessarily what has
already been achieved. It is therefore unreliable to conclude from
manifestos that one party is reactionary and the other is
revolutionary. According to their manifestos all political parties
would appear revolutionary. One factor, however, is missing from the
equation. The equation is manifesto plus action equals reactionary or
revolutionary (manifesto+action=reactionary or revolutionary). The
missing factor is action. Evaluation is often carried out on the basis
of what has been done (action) corresponding to the expressed
intentions or objectives. More often action does not tally with the
manifesto hence in practice mismanagement of state affairs may be sky
high which may also progressively lead to a failed state situation. It
is therefore what has been done (action) that can demonstrate whether
a state has reactionary or revolutionary leadership. Making an
informed choice is dependent on knowledge of leadership that is
pragmatic, patriotic, uncompromising and has done what they had
announced in public as their priorities. After a year in office one
may have a fair view whether a leader has been reactionary or
revolutionary. At the end of the term of office a fairly clearer
picture will emerge whether the state was ruled by a reactionary or
revolutionary leadership. The electorate then will have an informed
choice assuming bribery or irregularities do not take place.

Political reforms

In any political system reforms are naturally inevitable. This is
because the world is not monolithic but dynamic. Changes occur and it
is through reforms that people keep pace with developments.
Dictatorship either by reactionaries or revolutionaries may lead to
tyranny and creation of the world of psychopants who sing songs the
one in power wants to hear and be entertained with. How damaging this
may be to nation-building is not clear. However, to steer clear of
dictatorship reforms are necessary. One political reform is where any
member of a party can nominate themselves or be nominated to fill any
office in the political system. The restrictive nomination and
endorsement system by a party polit-bureau is undemocratic as the bulk
of ordinary members and sympathizers are excluded from the exercise.
An example is the overwhelming success of one independent over the
official candidate for the governorship of Western Equatoria State.
The official candidate was nominated and endorsed by the party
polit-bureau but the one not nominated and endorsed by the same party
polit-bureau convincingly won in the elections. Other members were
also nominated and endorsed by the party polit-bureau but failed
miserably. This seems to call for reforms for the party to be
reflective of democratic principles.

Conclusion

An electoral system where nominees battle it out in the open for
members and sympathizers to elect the most popular nominee for a
candidate for a political office is worth consideration. This system
brings out the most popular candidate for election to political
office. The popular candidate becomes the flag bearer of their
political party. This is unlike when nominations and endorsements of
candidates are done behind closed doors in the absence of popular
participation by ordinary members. Some of the results in the last
election showed clearly that what the party polit-bureau considered
suitable candidates were not necessarily suitable to the electorate.
This clearly should be a lesson for reforms to take place.

In conclusion, reactionary leadership is most likely to lead a country
to a failed state situation. This is because reactionary leadership is
preoccupied with survival skills of destruction without being
innovative to overcome the characteristics of a failed state. When
making a choice it is important to evaluate what has been done in
relation to the party’s manifesto. More often the party’s manifesto
hardly tallies with the actions promised to be carried out. In such a
situation the choice should be obvious.

The author can be reached at [email protected] This e-mail
address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled
to view it


  Disqus.
 Login About Disqus...Glad you liked it. Would you like to share?Facebook
Twitter
ShareNo thanksSharing this page …
Thanks! Close

Login Add New Comment

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob?hl=en.

Reply via email to