---------- Forwarded message ---------- From: John Ashworth <[email protected]> Date: Thu, Feb 23, 2012 at 12:33 PM Subject: [sudan-john-ashworth] The White Army To: Group <[email protected]>
The current White Army is not a standing army, but a force of armed civilians who are normally dispersed but can come together as an army when there is a general feeling within the community (and particularly within the armed youth) that it is necessary. Once they do so, they operate with remarkable cohesion and organisation under strong leadership. They have good communications and intelligence. Their current fighting style apparently contrasts with the Murle, who have been operating in very small groups, probably not under central command, staging small and widely separated attacks in true guerilla fashion. Amongst both the Lou Nuer and the Murle it is doubtful whether either traditional structures (chiefs, elders, women, etc) or "modern" leadership structures (members of parliament, senators, local government officials, civil society groups, etc) have any significant influence on the armed youth. As article 1 (below) states, there is some connection between the diaspora and the White Army, as much of the core message of the internet statements appears to reflect the feelings of the community on the ground. This is actually quite rare for the South Sudanese diaspora, whose pronouncements are often out of touch with the daily reality at home. Nevertheless it is clear that the pro-White Army propaganda from abroad comes from a very small group of individuals, perhaps as few as three or four, who may use false names and who fabricate imaginary conferences and networks to bolster their credibility. This has caused a reaction with "moderate" diaspora groups now producing their own statements in opposition to the "extremists". While it is good to hear that the diaspora in general does not support violence, there are two problems with this. Firstly, it just creates a new internet war, not uncommon for South Sudanese, with various groups claiming legitimacy and potentially attacking each other verbally. Secondly, even much of the "moderate" internet traffic still labels the Murle as the prime culprits, and thus is still partisan in a conflict in which all sides have committed atrocities against each other and each side has its own version of events. Neither of these dynamics is particularly conducive to peace. What is clear from the second article (below), is that people in Jonglei State take the law into their own hands and act, according to their own perception, in self-defence because the government has been unable to provide security for them. It should be a priority for both state and national government to create a climate of security within Jonglei State. In the short term that probably means hugely increasing the number of army and police in the state to provide buffer zones between communities, to guard population centres and protect people, property and livestock, and to react quickly to attacks. It also means training the security forces not to commit human rights abuses (see other articles I have circulated today and yesterday about misbehaviour by security personnel). After a climate of security and confidence has been achieved, which could take many months or even years, only then will the government be in a strong position successfully to go ahead with its planned disarmament process. Roads and other forms of development, provided in a way that is perceived as equitable by all communities in the state, are also part of the solution. At the same time, both high-level peace conferences and the churches' grassroots peace process need to go ahead side by side to try to address the root causes of these longstanding conflicts and to bring reconciliation; another process which could take years. John BEGIN 1. South Sudan Officials Rebuff the White Army Comeback Posted by Annette LaRocco and Nenad Marinkovic on Feb 22, 2012 Enough Project BOR, South Sudan – The recent spate of violence in Jonglei state has drawn the world’s attention to the cyclical problem of inter-communal violence in South Sudan. When another round of violence between the Lou-Nuer and Murle people reignited in late December 2011, it was accompanied by disturbing press releases from the so-called Lou-Nuer White Army calling for the extermination of the Murle people, which appalled the public in South Sudan and beyond. The original White Army came into being during the later years of the Second Sudanese Civil War as an irregular force of Nuer youths aligned with a breakaway faction of the SPLA. It remained active in South Sudan until just after the signing of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement, or CPA, when the government began dismantling and disarming the group. However, there has been a recent resurgence of a group of Lou-Nuer youths adopting the White Army's name. The group’s public messages have called for radical measures against the Murle community in Jonglei state, offering mass extermination as the “solution” that would once and for all end the long-standing inter-communal conflict between Murle and Lou-Nuer and Dinka in Jonglei. In a press release from late December, 2011, they called for massive mobilization of Lou-Nuer youth to wipe out Murle population: "The Nuer Youth White Army will continue operations on the daily basis until all Murle are finished so that they will not raid the Nuer anymore. We call on SPLA soldiers who do not want to die this year to stay out of our way. The Nuer White Army is well armed and no power can stop it." Despite the shocking rhetoric, leading officials from Jonglei state, including the governor himself, do not give too much importance to these statements, attributing them to Lou-Nuer diaspora, as opposed to youth residing in Jonglei. In a meeting with the Enough Project, Jonglei state governor Kuol Manyang Juuk laughed at the White Army’s bombastic remarks, including the suggestion that the president of South Sudan, Salva Kiir, would end up like the fallen Libyan dictator, Muammar el-Qaddafi, if Kiir attempts to disarm the White Army. Extraordinary statements like this have caused government officials to view the new White Army’s calls with ridicule, rather than concern. Governor Manyang confidently stated that the new “White Army” is merely made up of “fanatics” from Lou-Nuer diaspora in the United States waging an “internet war.” Like the state’s governor, the chief of security agencies in Jonglei, Duop Lam, is convinced that the press activities of the new White Army are tangential to current situation on the ground. He believes the newly reconstituted White Army is actually a small group of Lou-Nuer diaspora attempting to use the media to manipulate local politics in Akobo County, the epicenter of where Lou-Nuer youth are mobilizing against the Murle in Jonglei. Indeed, it appears that the bulk of these press releases have originated from the Lou-Nuer diaspora abroad. While the diaspora’s level of involvement in the escalation of the violence remains unclear, a South Sudanese immigrant living in Seattle has recently drawn criticism for his role in raising $45,000 for Lou-Nuer youth in Jonglei. Many officials in Jonglei state believe the Lou-Nuer diaspora are using the current atmosphere of inter-communal violence and tension in an attempt to further their extreme political views from afar. Presumably, however, there could be some level of communication between armed groups in Akobo and their "spokespeople" abroad, though this may not necessarily indicate that the armed youth on the ground see the members of the diaspora as their legitimate emissaries. Despite the confidence of the Jonglei state government, the rhetoric of ethnic cleansing coming from the new White Army should be a cause for concern. Historically, members of the South Sudanese diaspora, acting along ethnic lines, have tried to influence political events in South Sudan. Unlike in the past, when the diaspora engagement was usually divorced from the realities on the ground, this group of Lou-Nuer activists in the U.S. appears to be in sync with current events in Jonglei. The rhetoric of their statements is in line with the sentiments expressed by Lou-Nuer from Akobo County in discussions with high-ranking South Sudan officials sent from Juba to mediate and in interviews with Enough. Many questions remain unanswered about the alleged re-emergence of the White Army in South Sudan. However, the governor insisted that the answers lay not in Jonglei state but with the diaspora. He suggested Enough reach out to these individuals who claim to represent the White Army. “Go to the United States and ask them [the Lou-Nuer diaspora] what they think,” said Governor Manyang, dismissing the suggestion that the recent violence in Jonglei marks a resurgence of the White Army. Regardless of the connection between Lou-Nuer youth in Jonglei state and diaspora members, inter-communal violence in South Sudan is a very real issue. Rather than dismissing the diaspora’s rhetoric out of hand as an external issue, Governor Manyang and others within the government of the Republic of South Sudan would do well to examine the linkages between diaspora rhetoric and monetary support, on the one hand, and outbreaks of violence in Jonglei state, on the other. Whether or not the youth of Jonglei are united under the banner of the White Army, the fact remains that inter-communal violence in Jonglei state, and throughout South Sudan, threatens to erode the fragile social and political stability of the new nation. http://enoughproject.org/blogs/south-sudan-officials-rebuff-white-army-comeback END1 2. Armed Civilians Challenge South Sudan Government Posted by Nenad Marinkovic on Feb 15, 2012 Enough Project BOR, South Sudan -- While the government of South Sudan is pondering the best way to tackle growing insecurity and prospects of persistent inter-communal hostility, the restive state of Jonglei, the scene of the recent deadly clashes, is enveloped in fear, anxiety, and anticipation of likely reprisal attacks—a situation which, if not handled sensibly, may escalate. Nothing but a single metal pole, driven into the ground, marks the border dividing two hostile communities, the Murle in Pibor and the Dinka in Bor County. Civilians from either side rarely cross this ambiguous borderline. “There are no Murle people in the state capital,” said Orozu Daky, a pastor at the Presbyterian Church who hails from Pibor, the epicenter of the recent clashes. Pastor Duky blames the government for marginalizing the Murle community, saying that, unlike other communities, the Murle don’t have many high-level advocates. “There is no one to bring our case out. We don’t enjoy basic rights in Jonglei state,” Duky told Enough. Pibor still bears marks of the recent conflict: households burned to the ground, trenches along the town’s defense lines, and talk and fear of the massive mobilization in Lou Nuer and Bor Dinka areas to “finish” the conflict once and for all—a continuation of the rhetoric used prior to the December attacks that raised concerns about ethnic cleansing and even genocide. South Sudan police have reported nearly two-dozen cases of raiding and killing just in the past few weeks in both Bor and Pibor County. In a dramatic show of force in late December and early January, Lou Nuer and Bor Dinka unleashed major destruction against the Murle community in Pibor County. Locals in Pibor town say more then 3,000 were killed, some 1,000 children and women were abducted, and 375,000 cattle were stolen. The United Nations, however, cautioned against such inflated estimates of casualties. Humanitarian aid groups warn the recent clashes could trigger a large-scale humanitarian crisis in South Sudan. On the way to the Jonglei capital of Bor, the checkpoint along the road looks over the flat and nearly bare grassland and seems to be manned by as many trained men the state government could assemble, from traffic police officers, the wildlife protection corps, and prison guards. Beyond that point, villages stand abandoned, one after another, in troubling tranquility. Jonglei Deputy Governor Hussein Mar Nyuot said that Bor is overwhelmed by people moving to be closer to overt government presence. “There are goats and cattle on the streets as people from the villages are moving to town,” he said. Security concerns have forced businesses and hotels in town to close earlier than usual, and the increased presence of armed forces is apparent. John, a Dinka from Bor, said people have left their villages and headed to the capital for safety. John said he travelled from Pibor to attend the funeral of his young nephew who was killed by Murle. His nephew was part of a group of young Bor Dinka who attacked the town of Gurmuk in Pibor County on February 7, killing nine Murle and wounding 11 more. John said he was in Pibor, helping an international aid agency distributing food to displaced Murle, when his nephew attacked Gurmuk. “If I was in Bor at the time, I wouldn’t let him go,” John said. John’s story is a common one in Jonglei state. The poisoning residue of South Sudan’s war-ridden past is abundant in these parts of the new country. Unlike educational or economic opportunities, weapons are plentiful for local youth, regardless of the government’s recurrent disarmament activities. And Lou Nuer and Bor Dinka hold a massive grudge against the Murle as a whole for their notoriety as child abductors and cattle thieves—a perception government officials and community leaders have done too little to address, and in some cases, have even stoked. “What criminals from Murle community are doing can only be described as terrorism,” Deputy Governor Hussein told Enough. “If we don’t disarm civilians, South Sudan may turn into a failed state,” he said, and then in an allusion to Somalia, added, “We may start running our country from a hotel while being protected by the international forces.” http://enoughproject.org/blogs/armed-civilians-challenge-south-sudan-government END2 ______________________ John Ashworth Sudan, South Sudan Advisor [email protected] +254 725 926 297 (Kenya mobile) +211 919 695 362 (South Sudan mobile) +27 82 050 1235 (South Africa mobile) +44 750 304 1790 (UK/international) +88 216 4334 0735 (Thuraya satphone) PO Box 52002 - 00200, Nairobi, Kenya This is a personal e-mail address and the contents do not necessarily reflect the views of any organisation -- The content of this message does not necessarily reflect John Ashworth's views. Unless explicitly stated otherwise, John Ashworth is not the author of the content and the source is always cited. You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "sudan-john-ashworth" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.co.za/group/sudan-john-ashworth -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "South Sudan Info - The Kob" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected]. For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob?hl=en.
