Secret letters: Why Kibaki shamed UK

By David Ochami

President Kibaki rejected British government’s invitation because of
unwillingness to account for post-election violence and also face
questions on the turning of Kenya away from the West and embracing
China.

The President also turned down the 2010 invite that would have seen
him meet Queen Elizabeth II because it was rated as "a non-ceremonial
guest", something top Foreign Affairs officials in Nairobi advised was
beneath his dignity as Head of State.


The Standard established the feelings by Kibaki’s allies the British
were conspiring against him and his regime began on 2008 and may have
only been compounded by the controversial UK ‘dossier’ brought to
Parliament last month.

Among allegations made in the dossier are that President Kibaki was
under investigation for the 2008 post-election violence and could be
tried after his retirement next year.

The claims in the ‘dossier’ that among other things suggested Prime
Minister Raila Odinga was the West’s preferred successor to Kibaki and
that two of The Hague suspects with presidential ambitions would be
locked up, are now under investigation by parliament’s Defence and
Foreign Relations Committee.

Secret letters seen by The Standard show that Kibaki’s aides felt the
British were plotting to meet the Kenyan leader to lecture him and
"regain some political clout in Kenya" during the visit.

Post-election violence

The president’s visit would have coincided with International Criminal
Court (ICC) investigations into Kenya’s post-election violence that
has now led to the indictment of two of the President’s close
confidants — Deputy Prime Minister Uhuru Kenyatta and former Head of
Civil Serice Mr Francis Muthaura.

The post-election violence not only broke out because defunct
Electoral Commission of Kenya’s controversial declaration of Kibaki as
winner but marked Kenya’s darkest period as the President and his
insiders strove to remain in power, something ICC blamed for the
extra-judicial and revenge killings executed by state agents and their
allies then.

Between 2005 and 2009 the Kibaki regime also bought huge amounts of
weapons from the Chinese, according to Western thinktanks, some of
which it transferred to third countries, against UN regulations.

The regime was also, extremely divided over justice for victims of the
post-election violence without progress on a new constitution, war on
terrorism, major reforms and also under intense scrutiny for its human
rights record including extra-judicial killings and an insurgency in
Mount Elgon that forced a visit by former UN rapporteur for
extra-judicial killings, Prof Philip Alston.

Sense of paranoia

On the failed visit Kibaki felt an invitation by former UK Prime
Minister Gordon Brown, was low key and his advisers convinced him the
British were biased against his regime after his disputed re-election
in 2007.

The British themselves inflamed the Kenya regime’s sense of paranoia
when the UK High Commission (BHC) in Nairobi attached a message to an
earlier invitation by Brown characterising Kibaki’s planned visit as
"a non-ceremonial Guest of Government," a characterisation that threw
the Kibaki regime into fits of anger and whining.

It is apparent that the British extended the invite late 2009, which
was followed by a clarification from British High Commission on
December 17, 2009 and finally sealed with a formal letter by the
former UK premier on January 13, 2010.

Significantly the BHC letter only reached the Kenyan officials on
February 19, 2010. "The trip is off," an unnamed official at the
Foreign Affairs ministry screamed in an advisory to the president’s
office after receiving the clarification note from BHC.

The official’s brief notes against the invitation accuses the British
of providing "a shallow itinerary and programme" beneath the dignity
of the Kenyan leader.

But the spirit and temper of the denunciation was elaborated in
confidential notes by new Foreign Affairs minister Sam Ongeri to the
Defence and Foreign Relations Committee last week.

When he testified before the committee on Wednesday Prof Ongeri
acknowledged Brown invited Kibaki and that the Kenyan leader turned it
down because the planned protocol was "inappropriate".

He complained that after Kibaki’s failed trip the British were
planning to roll out a State visit "to another State shortly." He does
not name the alleged State but argues that the kind of visit planned
for Kibaki did not amount to a State visit. "Further," Ongeri laments,
"the president was to be hosted for dinner by the Foreign Secretary
(Mr David Miliband)."

In his invitation Brown inflamed the suspicions of Kibaki’s handlers
by declaring that besides offering British support "through current
challenges facing you" he intended to make the planned meeting with
Kibaki "a valuable opportunity to discuss Kenya’s reform path, as well
as to pursue co-operation on shared bilateral and regional interests."

But the Kenyan authorities read a lot more in Brown’s apparently plain
letter deciphering the devil in its details and their fears are
confirmed in BHC’s clarification which read in part:

"The visit will be a non-ceremonial Guest of Government visit which
will include a call on Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth, dinner with Hon
David Miliband MP, Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth
Affairs and a call on Hon Gordon Brown, Prime minister."

The advisory from Kenyan Foreign Ministry at the time discerned
mischief in BHC’s and Brown’s statements. Kibaki’s advisors concluded
that "a call on Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth" was a diplomatic nicety
that concealed the real intentions of the meeting planned with Brown.

Bilateral co-operation

According to Kibaki’s advisors mischief was also evident in the phrase
"dinner with Hon David Miliband" for they considered this a
degradation of Kibaki and Kenya’s value to the British.

Whereas the advisory from the Kenyan Foreign ministry curtly derides
the invitation as "shallow and degrading", Ongeri wrote last week "the
(failed) visit was not actually intended to be an occasion to promote
further bilateral co-operation and exchange."

The unnamed Foreign Minister wrote to BHC: "The trip is off. It is
important to establish how such a shallow programme/itinerary that
lacks in dignity and content was arrived at."

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit this group at 
http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob?hl=en.

Reply via email to