Seven years of shifting sands: South Sudan's government must make the change
Opendemocracy, 24/7/2012 – In seven years of independent control,
South Sudan has not diversified its economy. Now the domestic
agricultural sector languishes and international agri-businesses
procure land for export markets. This failure could fuel conflict, if
real change is not made.
A year ago amid great jubilation South Sudan became an independent
nation. That 98% of the population voted for separation from Sudan is
stark evidence of the citizenry’s strong desire to rid themselves of
Khartoum’s centuries of inflicted poverty, oppression and
marginalisation. Much has been written in the media about the
challenges and achievements of the past year since independence.  This
piece is a response to one such article by Mr Aggrey Tisa Sabuni, an
advisor to the government of South Sudan. Mr Sabuni’s article is aptly
titled 'South Sudan: building the foundation of the world’s newest
nation'. Indeed South Sudan is at the foundation level of development.
Every good building must begin with a solid foundation, the
fundamentals of which are a good plan, identification of appropriate
resources and sound management. In all of these requirements South
Sudan has failed: it appears to have set its foundations on sand,
which shifts and washes away with every rising storm.
The challenges have undoubtedly been enormous for a country that is
starting from ground zero. Mr Sabuni has enumerated some of these
challenges accordingly but in my opinion he has failed categorically
to provide convincing evidence of achievements. Instead, like most
government mouthpieces, his article labours over sweeping statements
about general plans and the determination to build long term
prosperity.
The government of South Sudan’s decision to shut down oil production
remains controversial. Clearly, this decision was carried out without
strategic analysis of the consequences and clear alternative plans as
disclosed in a recent cringe-worthy report by the World Bank. It was
an emotive, hasty and irrational decision that has seen South Sudan
now finding itself between a rock and a hard place, having found no
means of financing an alternative pipeline to transport its oil to the
market. So what does the government do? It offers a $3.2 billion
compensation package and $4.9 billion worth of debt relief to woo
Khartoum back into the fold. It would appear then, that the country
has gone full circle while needlessly exacerbating the level of
poverty among its people who have not even begun to reap the peace
dividend.
The world food programme warns that 4-7 million people face food
insecurity in South Sudan. For a country whose economy relies so
heavily on its oil, South Sudan has failed miserably over the past 7
year since the signing of the CPA to diversify this economy. Mr
Sabuni’s claim of a rise in non-oil revenue of 250% since July 2011 is
a grossly misleading interpretation of the data.  What he selectively
omitted from this information is that only a few well-placed
individuals are siphoning the collected tax revenues. The country
relies heavily on imported items from both the East Africa region and
the Sudan. Compounded by the resurgence of open hostilities in the
border area with Khartoum, it is precisely the lack of foresight in
strategic planning and implementation of economic diversification by
the government of South Sudan that has caused rising domestic prices
for basic commodities.  It has been seven years since the country
acquired the driving seat of its national affairs yet still it imports
everything from bananas to meat products, despite the wealth of
livestock and the fertile environment with which it is endowed. Again,
Mr Sabuni’s claim that agriculture provides livelihood to 80% of the
population must be set into context. The truth is that 80% of the
population is dependant on foreign aid, supplemented by subsistence
farming of the most primitive kind.
While international and non-governmental organisations (FAO, AGRA,
USAID, CRWRC, etc.) have been instrumental in their effort to develop
the agriculture sector, the ministry of agriculture has been engaged
in elaborate back seat drafting of plans and little else in terms of
implementation. Like most government ministries staff skills are
grossly misplaced and management systems are not in place. The notion
that South Sudan does not have human resource capacity has been
conveniently exaggerated. Those with real skills might be few but
indeed they exist and are eager to demonstrate their skills.
Unfortunately for them, the recruitment process all the way from top
down favours who you know, not what you know, and there is little by
way of monitoring and evaluation of staff performances against set
objectives. Within the agricultural sector in particular, there is
greater need to engage in research and implementation of advanced
farming methodologies (in terms of environmental management,
mechanisation and crop science) in order to alleviate food insecurity,
growing urbanisation and unemployment. It does not help that over the
past few years the Oakland Institute report on South Sudan estimates
that 5.15 million hectares of land has been sought or secured by
private investors in the agribusiness sector through shady deals with
government officials and community leaders. The land rights of
community land owners have been ignored, and this is already emerging
as a grave source of conflict. Further, these large scale investments
have hitherto yielded nothing in terms of food production for local
consumption.
While South Sudan’s children are dying of nutritional deficiencies
from the severe lack of vitamins and protein, the country’s livestock
are dying out through starvation, uncontained serious diseases and
even old age. What has the ministry of agriculture done in terms of
developing disease control, veterinary services and grazing land over
the past 7 years of its existence? The answer is sadly nothing.
Investment in livestock management should have been set as one of the
top priorities of the ministry of agriculture given that this has the
significant potential of curtailing livestock migration over great
distances in search of water and grazing land, thereby containing
diseases while contributing to the prevention of conflict between
communities, such as that witnessed between the Dinka herdsmen and
Zande farmers in the Western Equatoria state.
South Sudan continues to struggle (even more profoundly since the oil
shut-down) to provide basic services in terms of education and health
care to its population, despite having acquired over $12 billion USD
in oil revenue over the past 7 years. It is fair to say that the
challenges of starting from scratch have been daunting and there is
some truth to that old and tired, self-handicapping adage favoured by
the government when trying to justify its dismal record of achievement
– that Rome was not built in one day. Indeed Rome was not build in one
day. A lot of foresight and proactive incremental steps went into
building Rome. That, together with a transparent and responsible
management of both the financial and human resources. The populations
at large have seldom seen signs of tangible incremental steps toward
service provision. Instead, rampant corruption by the president’s own
admittance, and as laid bare in the country’s auditor general’s report
speaks of the real reasons why we have not seen the seeds of
development sprouting. Many a time lip service has been paid to
combating corruption. That is all - lip service without any evidence
of a prosecution.
President Kiir made promises to start building 30 primary schools and
four secondary schools during the first 100 days of his government, in
office since independence. Even before the oil shut-down took place
this target was not met and nothing more has since been said about it,
just like many other elaborate promises made by the government.
Non-governmental organisations, with their lack of a harmonised
approach to the provision of services, continue to be the thin
concentration of oxygen that is keeping the country on life-support
machine. This in itself is not a good thing by any stretch of the
imagination. South Sudan cannot continue to hand out its territories
to NGO franchises that come in and encourage the culture of dependency
among the population.
Mr Sabuni’s assessment of the past year is nothing more than a
scraping of the barrel for positive things to report.  That is not to
say there is absolutely nothing positive to report. Unfortunately
damning evidence overshadows the minute slim pickings in the
achievement camp While one year is not enough time to expect much in
terms of development, we must remember that this government has been
firmly in control of national affairs for the past 7 years; hence my
assessment is based from the viewpoint of that duration. The most
resolute achievement to have come out of South Sudan in its first year
since independence is the independence itself. The decision of 98% of
the population, who voted for secession from the north, and their
absolute resilience and hope in the face of the continuing adversity
brought on largely by poorly thought out leadership decisions, lack of
implementation and rampant corruption, should serve as the
inspirational impetus for change.

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to