South Sudan: A False Start .




[Getty Images/File Photo]
.
By Dr Lam Akol

July 24, 2012 (SSNA) -- Aggrey Tisa Sabuni's article, South Sudan:
building the foundations of the world's newest state, gives the
impression that the building of South Sudan started with its
independence on the 9th of July last year. Nothing could be further
from the truth. Since the beginning of the implementation of the
Comprehensive Peace Agreement in July 2005, South Sudan was, for all
practical purposes, fully autonomous economically and politically. It
ran its own affairs and enjoyed freedom of action. Financially, it had
a more than 50% share of the revenue of oil extracted in the South,
foreign grants, money from the Multi-Donor Trust Fund and funds voted
to it from the national budget. Added to this is the internally
generated revenue in South Sudan. It was also free to borrow money
from banks, local and foreign. The revenue from oil alone amounted to
about 3 billion US dollars annually (including the 2% for the
oil-producing Unity and Upper Nile States) for the entire six years
interim period preceding the referendum on Self-Determination. These
are enormous resources. They were sufficient to set building the
foundations of South Sudan on course. The money was squandered in Juba
and the population saw nothing of it in terms of basic services and
improved security; a missed opportunity.As is well known, oil as a
resource is problematic: not only do its prices fluctuate considerably
but it is also non-renewable and exhaustible. Relying on it as the
sole resource is the surest way to economic uncertainty. Common-sense
would dictate that oil resources, while they last, should be used to
develop important sectors of the economy that are essential and
sustainable for the development of South Sudan, especially
agriculture. However, this was exactly the course of action that the
SPLM-controlled government in South Sudan eschewed from 2005 up until
it shut down oil production last January, six months after
independence. South Sudan boasts no industry and no private sector of
any kind. What economy are we talking about? If South Sudan had
invested oil money in agriculture, both plant and animal, it would
have achieved self-sufficiency in food well before 2009 and would have
simultaneously started agro-industry, such as sugar and other food
industries, tanneries, etc. No country can develop without a viable
industry.

It must also be underlined that agriculture in South Sudan is not
modernized; it is still traditional and fully rain-fed. A lot needs to
be done in order to improve production and increase productivity. What
Sabuni presents as "not insubstantial achievements"- the rise in
non-oil revenue of 250 per cent since July 2011- could have been
achieved in 2006 or 2007 at the latest. This is an insubstantial chunk
of the budget, it is only raising the non-oil revenue to just 5
percent of the budget! How do you cover the remaining 95 percent? It
is mind-boggling how with oil revenue unavailable the government in
Juba would get the money to run its "austerity programme" without
borrowing money. In fact, after closing down oil production, the
country has been borrowing money against the oil underground which
does not augur well for future generations.

Sabuni is absolutely right when he averred that "Being the world's
newest country affords us one clear advantage in this respect: we can
learn from the past mistakes of other countries." The question is: did
they learn anything from those mistakes? Not at all. They slid into
the same beaten path most African countries traversed: rocketing
inflation, total reliance on imported goods including food, insatiable
lust for foreign aid and corruption – a word Sabuni could not dare
mention in his article. Today, more than half the population needs
food aid and the World Bank had warned of an economic calamity if
nothing changes soon. By October, Juba may not be able to pay its
employees.

One would expect a newly born state like South Sudan to use its
resources judiciously before seeking assistance from others. What we
saw and still see is a government on a spending spree. The calls from
the opposition since 2010 for a lean government after independence
were contemptuously dismissed. Now, South Sudan has a government,
apart from the President and Vice President, of 56 ministers and
Deputy ministers; six Presidential Advisors; two chambers of
Parliament of too many members (one composed of 50 appointed members
and the other with 332 members, 49 percent of whom were appointed); 21
Chairpersons of National Commissions and a huge civil service. Sabuni
himself was until recently one of two Under Secretaries in one
ministry. In the Foreign Service, (91) ambassadors were appointed for
a population of less than 9 million souls. Compare this with Kenya's
about 60 and Zimbabwe's less than 40 ambassadors. These countries have
been independent for 50 and 32 years, respectively, and hence would be
expected to have established relations with more countries than a
newly born state would have.

In terms of pay, a minister in South Sudan, for instance, receives an
emolument in excess of 30,000 SSP monthly excluding other services and
perks, which is a staggering 100 times (or 10,000 percent) more than
what an SPLA soldier gets. Most developing countries are careful that
the pay of the highest paid government officials should not be far in
excess of the minimum pay. The huge government in South Sudan is not
by accident, it is a reflection of the distribution of patronage and
clientelism in the ruling party. No austerity measures will reverse
that trend. This also appears to be the biggest obstacle against
fighting corruption, rhetoric notwithstanding.

Let us take an example of how the priorities of the Government of
South Sudan are totally reversed. According to the 2011 budget
figures, health and education all over the country received 3.8 and
5.6 percent of the budget, respectively, compared to 3.7 and 5.1 per
cent in 2010 (both ministries received less than 10 percent of the
whole budget over those two years!). In contrast, the Office of the
President received 6.6 percent of the budget in 2010 and 4.8 percent
in 2011. In other words, the Office of the President has received more
than what went for health in the two years considered, and only
marginally less than the share of education in 2011.Another area of
concern is the overspending of all ministries over and above their
budget allocations. A cursory look at the 2005 and 2006 audit reports,
the only two carried out so far, reveals how some ministries have
spent in excess of up to almost 2000 per cent of their budgets. These
audit reports also contain very worrying revelations such as outright
embezzlement ans some government institutions refusing to be audited.

The biggest malaise of South Sudan's economy, all agree, remains what
Sabuni chose to ignore; rampant corruption. There can be no way "to
continue laying the foundations for long term economic prosperity"as
Sabuni puts it – when corruption in the high echelons of government
continue to eat into our meagre resources. In addition to its
crippling effect internally, corruption has caused foreign donors to
be reluctant in giving more aid money.

Regarding the difficult talks with Khartoum, could it be that "their
unwillingness to compromise" is based on the knowledge that South
Sudan has little options given its single resource "economy"?

The "South Sudan Development Plan" mentioned by the author, was not
heard of before the 9th of July 2012. What it is and for how many
years, none other than the government seems to know. A national plan
cannot be discussed behind closed doors; it is a matter for the whole
nation to debate. It must be discussed by both the Government and the
Opposition, and also by the civil society and other stakeholders, if
it is meant to last for any reasonable length of time for it to
deserve being termed a plan. How come it was so shrouded in secrecy?

One would agree with Sabuni that "the foundations are the first step
in building a strong and resilient nation". But all the indications
are that the foundations of the newly born South Sudan were laid not
on rock but on sand. The challenges are not only economic; good
governance with its six pillars calls for action. South Sudanese of
all hues and colours need to return to the drawing board to get things
right. The country's independence will not be consummated until it
enjoys good governance and attains economic self-reliance.

Dr Lam Akol is the Chairman of the SPLM-DC, the official Opposition
party in South Sudan. He was previously a Lecturer at the University
of Khartoum (1980-1986) before he joined the SPLM/A. The last position
he held was as Sudan's Minister of Foreign Affairs (2005-2007).

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to