South Sudan yet to embark on road to civil liberties
The Huffington Post, 25/7/2012 – After promising but hesitant initial
steps, the Republic of South Sudan is at a crucial point in its
one-year-old existence. It has thus far benefited from sustained
international attention, which has encouraged it to protect
fundamental freedoms. But once the post-independence honeymoon is
over, there lurks a danger that it could slide into repression and
dictatorship instead of continuing the positive progress, according to
an investigative report from Reporters without Borders.
It was largely for the sake of freedom that the South Sudanese
population decided in 2011 to break away from Khartoum. Expectations
are high in that new state. That's why South Sudanese Deputy
Information and Broadcasting Minister Atem Yaak Atem's showed elation
when he noticed that, on the 2012 Reporters Without Borders freedom of
information map, South Sudan is colored orange (for "noticeable
problems") whereas Sudan is colored black (for "very serious
situation") . In Juba, "beating Khartoum" is permanent challenge and
potential source of satisfaction. "We do things very differently
here," Atem told Reporters without Borders. "We have never experienced
prior censorship, for example. Khartoum's laws were not implemented
here."
Promises of freedom are so widespread that any disappointments in this
area will be sorely felt. Though South Sudan may be able to claim to
offer more freedom than Sudan, Khartoum's heritage is still felt
everywhere. According to a South Sudanese consultant, "the authorities
in Juba were brought up in the Khartoum school, and now they are
getting ready to put what they learned about repression into
practice". Information and broadcasting minister Barnaba Marial
Benjamin, who is also government spokesman, does not conceal the
government's use of the media. In fact, he justifies it. "In a
conflict or post-conflict situation, the government's communication
with the people is crucial," he said. "Our job is to inform the
population but also to transmit messages. The media are a tool for
us." Getting the government's message across is the priority. News and
information can wait.
Although enjoying a degree of freedom, the media are still in terrible
shape. They have started virtually from scratch and the environment in
which they have to operate is barely viable. As media outlets are
created, others disappear and their number continues to be low.
Without external support, it is hard for news media to survive and
almost all those that have survived for any length of time have
foreign funding. Furthermore, the resumption of border hostilities in
recent months has made it harder to access information and has
complicated news reporting. Barnaba Marial Benjamin boasts of never
having imposed any restriction on the movements of journalists in
South Sudan, but access to remote areas is difficult and dangerous. It
is virtually impossible for news organizations to get to the war zones
in South Sudan.
The number one problem raised by all the people Reporters without
Borders talked to during its visit to Juba is the brutality of the
security forces and the Sudan People's Liberation Army (SPLA), as
South Sudan's armed forces are called. Journalists are rarely
subjected to formal arrest, but they are often briefly detained and
beaten. Violence and intimidation are common. Last year, Miraya FM
compiled a report on the increase in police involvement in crime.
Shortly after it was broadcast, the journalist who did the report was
beaten. "It's a classic case," said Jacob Akol, the head of the
Association For Media Development in South Sudan (AMDISS). "All this
goes completely unpunished. The interior ministry should be held
responsible for these abuses."
As a direct consequence of this brutality and the failure to punish
it, journalists are afraid and censor themselves. The comments of a
young woman journalist employed by a foreign news outlet were
revealing. She told Reporters Without Borders: "Of course I censor
myself. Yesterday (May 13, 2012), a woman was shot dead in broad
daylight in Juba... It's an incredible story and we ought to cover it,
but I think I'd better not investigate it. Firstly, because I don't
really have the resources and secondly, and even more so, because the
security forces could come looking for me." She added: "Let's be
serious. I am a woman. You are physically abused in prison. They can
do terrible, hideous things to you. So I prefer to take care."
Journalists reporting on the war situation usually resign themselves
to being tools of disinformation and propaganda. "The United Nations
and NGOs say nothing so we have no choice but to repeat what the
government says," a reporter for foreign media said. The few
newspapers on both sides of the border that try not to be used find an
accusing finger pointed at them. "If we try to be objective according
to western standards (...) we are branded as traitors and accused of
not defending the national interest," the Sudanese reporter, political
columnist and media consultant Faisal Salih said.
The media are in urgent need of a legal framework. With much to be
done to construct the South Sudanese state and progress being hampered
by the economic crisis and tension with Sudan, the government and
parliament do not see media legislation as a priority. They
nonetheless need to appreciate its importance. Media laws would
establish ground rules for a sector that has none and would end the
reign of the arbitrary. They could protect journalists and media,
which would as a result be better able to do their job of reporting
the news. They would also enable this young state to put freedom of
expression and information at the heart of its system of values and
governance.
A year after its independence, South Sudan must make a decisive and
historic choice as regards its media. Reporters without Borders urge
the authorities to choose the road of openness, diversity, tolerance
and development. The alternative is internal tension, increasing use
of bellicose and ultranationalist propaganda and recourse to
censorship and repression to deal with criticism and dissent -- a
choice similar to that made by Eritrea, one of the world's last
totalitarian dictatorships and Africa's biggest prison for
journalists, a choice that would have dramatic consequences for the
population and civil liberties in South Sudan.

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to