Alan Boswell's White Whale
Enough Project responds to criticism of its South Sudan advocacy.
BY JONATHAN HUTSON | JULY 25, 2012

Journalist Alan Boswell took to these pages in an article called "The
Failed State Lobby" to malign certain human rights advocates including
George Clooney and staff of the Enough Project and the Satellite
Sentinel Project (SSP). He characterized their efforts to end genocide
and hold all parties in the Sudans accountable for mass atrocities as
"morally charged and culturally hip do-goodism" in service of a "clear
political agenda."

COMMENTS (1)
 SHARE:
Share on twitterTwitter

Share on redditReddit

 More...
Like others who have gone before, Boswell is entitled to his opinion,
but not his own facts. Rather than making a fact-based reportorial
case, Boswell ends up indulging in the kind of moral indignation he
claims to deplore.

He knocks his peers for allegedly giving the Enough Project "a free
pass." They do this, he claims, by "frequently citing its version of
events as objective, independent analysis," when he suggests, it is
not. However, Boswell offers no examples of misreporting by anyone or
any failures of objectivity on the part of the Enough Project.

Instead, Boswell besmirches an Enough Project Sudan policy analyst,
implying that her prior role as a legal adviser to the government of
South Sudan and the Sudan People's Liberation Movement (SPLM)
inherently biases her toward the South. Providing legal advice to an
entity or individual does not impute the values or beliefs of that
entity onto a legal adviser. To insinuate otherwise in this, or any
other, context is inaccurate and unfair. I know our policy analyst to
be a fair-minded professional of integrity.

As Boswell concedes, the Enough Project does not turn a blind eye to
human rights violations, and it is not blindly pro-South Sudan. For
example, Enough called the Republic of South Sudan (RSS) to account
for failing to do enough to protect civilians from anticipated
intercommunal violence in South Sudan's Jonglei state in August 2011.
In a January 26 report, Enough wrote: "The RSS made no systematic
sustained effort to facilitate negotiations to return the people
abducted and livestock stolen in the August attack. The government did
not reinforce and bolster its security forces deployed between and
among the communities to serve as a buffer and protect civilians.
Nothing was done about the general disempowerment and deprivation felt
by the youth of both the Lou-Nuer and Murle communities."

Nevertheless, Boswell complains, "Enough's policy papers are filled
with calls for punitive measures toward Khartoum and greater
engagement with Juba." He implies that it is wrong to call for the
international community to increase its engagement with South Sudan,
the world's newest nation, in order to improve its human rights
record; and that it is wrong to suggest further sanctions against
Khartoum, aimed at improving the record of a notorious human rights
violator.

Then Boswell assails Enough Project Co-founder John Prendergast for
having the temerity to recruit celebrities to help generate media
attention in the service of ending genocide and mass atrocities -- as
if this were a bad thing. "Prendergast's biggest catch of late is
George Clooney," Boswell sneers, "who has made Sudanese President Omar
Hassan al-Bashir something of his own personal white whale."

But Herman Melville's white whale, Moby Dick, is a poor metaphor for
what drives Clooney, who is a thoughtful and dedicated humanitarian.
Clooney has traveled to the region six times, got malaria twice, and
recently entered a conflict zone with Prendergast at the invitation of
South Kordofan's Nuba people. There he filmed, among other things,
evidence of war crimes. He has not only put his body on the line, but
put his money where his mouth is by co-founding and financing the
Satellite Sentinel Project.

And let's take a moment to consider Boswell's misplaced metaphor. To
Captain Ahab, Moby Dick embodied evil and a reason for reckless
revenge, for the creature had taken Ahab's leg. But the novel's
narrator, Ishmael, suggests that the way in which one perceives the
whale's whiteness reveals more about you than the whale.

So it is with Boswell, who naively suggests that Prendergast and
Clooney, in cooperation with others have run a "bizarre moral
campaign" grounded in "moral idealism" that in turn has somehow driven
U.S. foreign policy on the Sudans for a generation. "But the activists
made a critical mistake," he asserts, without evidence. "They seemed
to think the SPLM rebels represented a virtuous mirror image of
Khartoum's evils."

"Clooney's eyes in the sky have visually confirmed several events on
the ground," Boswell concedes, dismissively. He fails to mention that
these events include apparent mass graves at eight sites in Sudan, the
government of Sudan's indiscriminate bombardment of civilians, Sudan's
blockade of humanitarian relief to civilians facing near-famine
conditions, and evidence of military escalation by both sides in the
disputed border region of Abyei. "But, its satellites also have a
clear agenda: Read through the group's reports," he advises. He then
claims, offering no evidence, that SSP does not provide "comparably
critical scrutiny" of the forces of both nations. In fact, that is
exactly what SSP does -- although what SSP learns does not always lead
to comparable evidence of criminality.

Boswell seems unable to accept that there is no controversy about the
disproportionate scale of Khartoum's operations and that it continues
to live up to the reputation it earned while committing horrific
crimes against humanity in Darfur -- for which four of its leaders
have been indicted by the International Criminal Court.

Boswell's method is transparent: He smears those who seek forensic
evidence of war crimes, by eliding the facts instead of reporting
them. He then posits a false moral equivalence between the Sudans.

Boswell's unsupported accusations notwithstanding, SSP has since its
launch in 2011, focused on both southern as well as northern-aligned
forces, and documented, among other things, evidence of looting by
South Sudan's army in the border area of Heglig. If Boswell had really
been reading how SSP handles reporting on the southern side, he might
have noticed that on April 23, 2012, SSP cited Boswell's own reporting
for Time magazine as part of its documentation of evidence of possible
war crimes.

Although Boswell gets his facts and his white whale metaphor wrong,
there is a Melvillian simile that applies. So quick is Boswell to jab
at Clooney and fellow human rights advocates that, like Captain Ahab,
he becomes entangled and upended by his own harpoon.

ALAN BOSWELL RESPONDS:

I fully stand by my reporting. I don't see anything here that
substantively challenges the facts of my report. Anyone who is
interested in my full reporting from the ground can read my regular
stories on mcclatchydc.com and time.com, or on Twitter at
@alanboswell. Anyone wishing to raise factual issues about my work are
welcome to email me at [email protected]. My report addressed
an important policy question, and I hope the debate on the policy side
of these issues continues.

Save big when you subscribe to FP. Win McNamee/GettyImages

 SUBJECTS: HUMAN RIGHTS, AFRICA
 Jonathan Hutson, Communications Director of the Enough Project, led
negotiations to launch the Satellite Sentinel Project, a partnership
between Enough and DigitalGlobe which aims to deter full-scale war
between Sudan and South Sudan.

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to