SEC Rules on Conflict Minerals: Positive Step but Threat of Lawsuit Lingers




Posted by Sasha Lezhnev and Darren Fenwick on Aug 22, 2012








Editor’s Note: This initial assessment of the SEC’s conflict minerals
regulation is based on information about the new rule provided by the
SEC in a factsheet today. The full text of the rule (356 pages) was
issued this evening.

After a more than one-year delay, the Securities and Exchange
Commission, or SEC, voted 3-2 earlier today to adopt conflict minerals
regulations for Section 1502 of the Dodd-Frank Financial Reform Act.
On the whole, this was a positive step for Congo and companies. It
sets the wheels in motion for companies to finally be able put out
fully conflict-free products and invest in a transparent, clean
minerals trade in Congo. Although the rule appears to have been
weakened to placate the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National
Association of Manufacturers, the threat of a lawsuit by these
associations remains.

The rule, which requires companies to publicly disclose their use of
conflict minerals—tin, tungsten, tantalum, and gold—that originated in
eastern Congo or neighboring countries, should have an overall
positive effect on promoting peace and stability in Congo—but a slow
one. The SEC’s rule that companies will be allowed to say “I don’t
know where my minerals come from” for up to two years should give
firms time to develop systems to purchase clean minerals from Congo.
The inclusion of many other companies—for example, companies that
design products—should mean that more companies will join audit
programs, and smelters will get audited. Several companies told us
following the adoption of the rule that they believe that this will
lead to more momentum behind the smelter audit programs such as the
Conflict-Free Smelter program.

However, the possibility of a lawsuit against the regulations remains,
as the U.S. Chamber of Commerce has threatened.

“Hopefully the industry associations and far-right groups won’t sue
the SEC, essentially suing for the right to foment war in central
Africa,” said Congressman Jim McDermott (D-WA) in response to the
vote. “It’s time to get on with the transparency that is so badly
needed here.”

Nevertheless, the SEC appeared to take away several of the key points
of opposition that the Chamber of Commerce had raised, such as
unrealistic cost analysis, the burden on small business, and
recycling. As a result, the chamber would appear to have little to
stand on if it filed a lawsuit. The SEC’s new cost estimate for
implementation was much closer to industry’s ($3-4 billion); small
businesses received a four-year phase-in; and recyclers will not have
to trace as deeply as some had feared. As Jonathan Gold of the
National Retail Federation noted, “The staff did take into account a
lot of the information that the industry provided.”

The Enough Project, along with other human rights organizations,
consumers, industry actors, corporations, and activists, attended the
highly anticipated vote this morning and listened to the five
commissioners explain their positions on the 3-2 vote.

“I am pleased that the commission has finalized this very challenging
project in such a thoughtful manner,” said SEC Chairman Mary L.
Schapiro. “We have received significant public input on this
rulemaking, and in response we incorporated many changes from the
proposal that are designed to address concerns about the costs. I
believe the final rule faithfully implements the statutory requirement
as mandated by Congress in a fair and balanced manner.”

The rule includes a two-year phase-in of the audit requirement for
larger companies who do not know the origin of the minerals in their
products and a four-year phase-in for smaller companies.
Unfortunately, those companies that choose to invest in the region
over the next two years (like HP, Intel and Motorola) will incur audit
costs for clean minerals coming from the region because the origins of
the material can be identified. By contrast, the Nintendo and the
Honda manufacturers of the world who choose to claim “I don’t know”
are exempt from those audit costs.

>From what we have been able to discern based on the factsheet issued
by the SEC, the rule maintains the “contract to manufacture”
requirement, meaning that a company that commissions another company
to produce a product that may contain conflict minerals would itself
be obliged to report to the SEC—a provision that retailers had
opposed. The final rule does not appear to define manufacture as
“necessary to the functionality of” a given product. These two
provisions would likely mean, pending a review of the final rule, that
more companies will be required to trace and audit their supply
chains, though slowly. The inclusion of most companies that use
conflict minerals, including retailers, means that more companies will
get engaged and likely push forward the process of auditing smelters
by joining projects like the Conflict Free Smelter program. This sort
of collaboration could help drive the completion of fully
conflict-free products. However, further analysis is needed. There are
many outstanding questions, such as which companies will have to file;
what does the reasonable country of origin inquiry look like; will
companies be allowed to rely on supplier representations instead of
doing a thorough analysis of their supply chains?

The Enough Project will continue to analyze the impact of these
regulations. This initial assessment will be followed by a more
in-depth policy brief once we’ve analyzed the full text.

Tracy Fehr contributed to this post.

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected].
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.


Reply via email to