CAFOD: Evaluation of South Sudan Recover, Re-integration and Sustainable Livelihood Program
Terms of Reference for the Evaluation of South Sudan Recover, Re-integration & Sustainable Livelihood Program Funded by Caritas Austria, Caritas Italiana, Caritas Belgium, SCIAF and CAFOD 17 November 2012 Background of Funding agencies These are Catholic agencies known as “Caritas” and are members of the Caritas Confederation/internationalis. Caritas agencies are basically the development and humanitarian aid wings of the Catholic Bishop’s Conferences in respective countries of origin. Some of the Caritas agencies funding this programme has got a presence in the country while majority operate from their countries of domicile in Europe with occasional visits. CAFOD has an established country office and presence in South Sudan, from where programme support has been based. There have been bilateral grant agreements for this specific programme between CAFOD and Caritas Austria, Caritas Belgium and SCIAF, as the legal financial project holder and responsible to provide oversight for programme implementation as well as administrative support to its sister agencies as well as implementing partners. Caritas Italiana and CAFOD signed MoU with the implementing partner CDO to collaborate in project implementation; funds were channelled directly to the partner. Similar tripartite MoUs were also signed in the case of CDTY and SUDAN AID between CAFOD and Caritas Austria, Belgium and the partners in additional to the grant agreements between the agencies. Programme Background CAFOD in partnership with its CI sister agencies namely Caritas Austria, SCIAF and Caritas Belgium and in collaboration with Caritas Italiana, through their local partners; Development and Peace Office of the Catholic Diocese of Tombura Yambio (CDTY), Caritas Juba Archdiocese and Catholic Development Office of Kosti Pastoral Region has been implementing a 3 year Recovery, Re-integration & Sustainable Livelihoods Programme, in the respective Catholic dioceses and pastoral region mentioned above. The programme started in January 2010 after a joint assessment in 11 counties across the 3 States in 2009, that involved CAFOD, Caritas Austria, CRS, respective implementing/local partners and government departments was conducted in Central, Western Equatoria States and Upper Nile State, followed at the end of the assessment with 5-day workshop to analyse the outcomes of the assessment leading to the design of the programme. The workshop as a result of the assessment findings identified four key objectives upon which the recovery, re-integration and sustainable livelihoods programme design was based upon. The key objectives are; 1. Increase market-driven agricultural productivity leading to improved household food security. 2. Promote diversification of livelihoods strategies among the vulnerable communities. 3. Support integration of return populations through the provision of basic agricultural services. 4. Promote adoption of Disaster Risk Reduction (DRR) by partners and local communities. To achieve the stated key programme objectives to address the vulnerability of food insecurity faced by the people of South Sudan in the targeted locations, a 5 year Recovery, Re-integration and Sustainable livelihoods programme was designed, with initial 3 years approved for implementation targeting a total of 7,970 households across the 3 implementing partners, with special focus on returnees, women, People Living with HIV&AIDS, elderly, women/child headed households, etc. Strong focus on learning was in built in the programme to enable effective roll out after the first 3years. Programme implementation and funding has been done at partner level with the respective implementing partners establishing their teams in their locations to carry out activities with funding from particular agencies. The programme through CAFOD resource mobilisation initiatives in collaboration with the partners managed to access funding from institutional donors like FAO, Sudan Recovery Fund (SRF) Common Humanitarian Fund (CHF) to boost livelihood activities especially in Renk and Maban under the CDO. The other Caritas agencies that channelled funding through CAFOD like Caritas Austria, SCIAF and Caritas Belgium funded DPO and Juba archdiocese respectively. Caritas Italiano funded CDO with funds transferred directly to Kosti Pastoral Region towards the common livelihood programme budget. The 3 year programme implementation period is coming to an end in December 2012, and during its 3rd year implementation period, the programme has been extended to Yei diocese under implementation by Caritas Yei with funding from CAFOD, Caritas Australia and Caritas Belgium. The funding agencies alongside its implementing partners are seeking consultancy services from competent firms to evaluate and assess the progress and short term impact of the first 3 years of the Recovery, Re-integration & Sustainable Livelihoods Programme implementation. CAFOD will facilitate and coordinate this process. The evaluation is also expected to come up with strong and practical programmatic, management and financial recommendations to inform the funding agencies and implementing partners to make informed decisions for future planning of the programme in South Sudan either in the same partners and locations or new areas of work in the next 3 years, 2013 – 2015. The evaluation will be conducted in specific locations of implementation with the implementing partners and specific evaluation and impact reports produced for each partner programme implementation with specific findings, lessons learnt challenges and recommendations. An overall summary report for the overall programme will also be required. Evaluation Focus for each implementing partner (DPO, CAJ & CDO) The evaluation will focus on programme implementation technical aspects and management aspects and ensure that in each aspect of the evaluation; efficiency, effectiveness, appropriateness, sustainability, coverage and coordination issues are adequately addressed and clearly highlighted. Implementing partners will provide additional details to enhance the broader evaluation focus areas below, based on their local situations. A. Programme implementation technical aspects 1. Assess and evaluate implementation against set outcomes and planned activities as per respective project matrices for each partner to ascertain programme progress and achievements as per set objectives for each implementing partner. 2. Assess and evaluate the impact of the programme in the communities especially among the targeted beneficiaries taking into account beneficiary selection criteria, numbers and gender. 3. Assess and evaluate realism of activities planned by partners for each year, outcome practicability, relevance of the indicators per outcome, and budgets to ascertain cost benefit analysis for each project/partner. 4. Evaluate the relevance and impact of various livelihood methodologies and approaches applied by each of the implementing partners. B. Programme management 1. Assess and evaluate the effectiveness of team structures and management capability in the delivery of the programme taking into account the respective necessary details for each team/implementing partner and facilitating agency, CAFOD. 2. Review, assess and evaluate systems employed in financial, procurement, HR and general logistics procedures, management and communication flow to support the delivery of the programme for each partner. 3. Assess and evaluate networking abilities and value added to the project as a result of both internal networking within the implementing institution and with external stakeholders including with government departments, INGOs/NGOs, UN Coordination Clusters, business community. 4. Partnership relationships with the funding agencies focussing on technical support to build implementing partner capacity to deliver the programme, communication flow and reporting. Evaluation Methodology The consultant firm is required to submit a technical and financial proposal for this consultancy work. The technical proposal will highlight clearly and in details the methodology to be used in conducting this exercise, ensuring that there is maximum participation of the implementing partners, beneficiaries and funding partners as well as the selected general community and other stakeholders. The financial proposal will highlight in details the budget and financial implications needed in conducting this evaluation successfully. Evaluation Duration The evaluation is expected to start first week of mid October and end 30th November 2012 with a final report submitted by 1st week of December 2012. The selected consultancy firm will need to deploy its staffs concurrently in Western Equatoria to cover DPO implemented activities, in Central Equatoria to cover Caritas Juba Archdiocese implemented activities and in RenK/Maban to cover CDO implemented activities. Expected Evaluation Output 1. Feedback workshop with respective implementing partners and invited stakeholders. An independent evaluation report for each implementing partner. A total of 3 independent reports clearly highlighting and addressing evaluation focus points/issues, with clear findings, lessons learnt challenges and recommendations. 2. Overall programme evaluation report summarising the Key issues and recommendations in the 3 independent partner evaluation reports. Consultancy Specifications for the assignment 1. Should be a consultancy firm that has engaged in wide scale and complex livelihoods related evaluation exercises preferably with international NGOs, UN agencies and faith based institutions. 2. Has experience in participatory evaluation approaches and community mobilisation skills. 3. Strong experience in food security and other aspects livelihoods programming. 4. Practical ability to design/utilise community friendly or appropriate data collection tools with knowledge of data collection techniques and good analytical skills to analyse collected data comprehensively. 5. Previous similar assignment in South Sudan/Sudan is an asset but not compulsory. 6. Good command of English language 7. Submit CV for lead consultants and organisation profile 8. Reference from at least 3 firms that you have provided with consultancy services. Reference from church/faith based institutions is an asset but not a MUST. 9. Knowledge of South Sudan and its socio-economic and political is an advantage. How to apply Submit your Technical and financial proposals subject “SLP EVALUATION” with a cover letter to the Livelihoods Programme Manager, by 23rd November 2012 to this email address; [email protected] (there is an underscore between jobs and sudan) website:http://www.cafod.org.uk Posted in: Tender Announcements, General Announcements -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "South Sudan Info - The Kob" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected]. For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.
