Lakes State governor and "doctrine of necessity"
Article
Comments (1)
email Email
print Print
pdfSave
separation
increase
decrease
separation
separation
facebook
myspace
twitter
buzzyahoo
By Adhil Malok, Jnr
July 7, 2013 - To ‘take someone for a ride’ is idiomatic expression
for deceiving someone or a group of people. In this respect, someone
somewhere is trying very hard to deceive the people of Lakes state, in
particular the law-making institutions (Council of states and the
state legislative assembly) as to why the care-taker Governor, Retired
Major General Matur Chut Dhuol should continue in wielding power,
despite the fact that his very existence in office is not in
accordance with the constitution of the country.
Lakes state’s military caretaker governor, Matur Chut Dhuol was
installed by President Salva Kiir in January 21st, replacing the
elected governor (Chol Tong Mayay) on the backdrop of inter-communal
conflict that took the lives of scores of people, which is endemic to
almost all ten states of South Sudan.
Under South Sudan’s constitution, the president has the power to
replace a governor on national security grounds, but a new governor
should be elected within 60 days. This has not happened.
The care-taking period for Governor, Retired Major General Matur Chut
Dhuo expired on 31st of March 2013. But he is still in office. His
continued stay is therefore unconstitutional.
A group of state government’s constitutional post-holders whom the
General removed unconstitutionally from their positions petitioned him
before the Council of States-an upper house law-making body. In light
of that petition, the Justice Minister, John Luk, Jok appeared before
the Council of States on 25th of June to clarify on the legality of
the Lakes state’s governor tenure.
The justice minister told lawmakers that the caretaker governor was
being kept in the position based on a “doctrine of necessity.” The
Doctrine of Necessity is described as the basis on which extra-legal
actions by state actors, which are designed to restore order, are
found to be constitutional. Such doctrine, as it is called, is derived
by necessity. Such necessity does not exist in Lakes state, and if it
does, it is not in Lakes state alone. It can only be used, for
example, to rescue a particular situation from gross human rights
violation. Is General Matur here a part of solution or a part of the
problem?! To many People, he has become a big problem.
As a result of the governor’s strange policies, insecurity and
communal conflicts, for which the elected governor was removed,
continue unabated, as evidenced by the events which are occurring
almost on daily basis and are being reported by the media. Because of
such reports the governor has developed problems with media houses,
leading to closure of a Catholic Church operated Radio Good News,
which is very popular and useful source of information to the local
audience.
Inter-communal conflicts are not peculiar to lakes state, because such
conflicts are happening in almost all ten states. The records of such
violence in terms of losses in human lives and property in some states
are by far worse than what happened in Lakes state. So, what or who is
behind unconstitutional political changes in Lakes state?
To some of us who have been following the situation keenly, political
turmoil in Lakes state started with last year’s visit to the state by
the Chairman of SPLM in the state, Mr. Daniel Awet Akot, who is also
the Deputy Speaker of the National Legislative Assembly. During his
visit, Mr. Awet wanted to make changes within SPLM state secretariat
which brought him into loggerhead with some SPLM members; who
challenged the changes he wanted to make as unconstitutional. There
was a big row caused by Awet’s moves which polarized the party members
in Lakes state. Chairman, Awet mistakenly associated the opposition to
his unconstitutional changes with the then governor, Chol Tong Mayay.
Awet wanted to make changes that would allow him secure re-election as
the state chairman and probably as a governor, come 2015 general
elections. When his efforts were thwarted in Rumbek, Chairman Awet
came back to Juba with grudge against Governor Chol Tong and some of
his ministers/commissioners. Awet reported to SPLM leadership in Juba
that the situation he found in Lakes state was hostile to him and
probably others who are holding elected positions within SPLM or the
government. He therefore suggested that the government of Chol Tong be
unseated or else they (Awet and Company) will not win come next SPLM
or General Elections.
The plan to unseat governor Chol was hatched and the plotters waited
for an opportune moment, which was provided by clashes between Kuei
and Rup sections of Rumbek Central County. Chairman Awet and other
senior government officials in Juba, especially those close to the
president, such as advisors and ministers from Lakes state, conspired
against the elected governor, Engineer Chol Tong Mayay.
The undercurrent struggle for top leadership of the ruling party
(SPLM) is another factor in the political instability within Lakes
state. Scores of SPLM members are divided as to who should be the
leader and torch bearer come the next general Elections. In this
exercise, people are being labelled as supporters of X or Y. As a
result, Lakes state has become a grass, while elephants are fighting
for the top job. In the light of the above analysis, there is a strong
belief on my side and probably many others that Minster of Justice did
not do justice by failing to tell the lawmakers the truth, when he was
summoned last week to appear before the Council of State, to answer
questions as to why General Matur is still holding the important
position of state governor unconstitutionally. The situation in Lakes
state does not warrant the so called “Doctrine of necessity”.
Adhil Malok, Jnr, is a political analyst in Rumbek, Lakes state he can
be reached at : [email protected]
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
To view this discussion on the web visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14orCU%3Dg5jj1ds_2suB-u2FFmz2Fmd4QOfaOZBzC5gPt%2BBg%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/groups/opt_out.
