Kenya's absent politicians (what I learned in Kisumu) - By Magnus Taylor
Posted on March 16, 2014 by AfricanArgumentsEditor      
KenyanPoliticians

Uhuru Kenyatta, Peter Kenneth, Musalia Mudavadi, Martha Karua and
Raila Odinga during the televised Presidential debate prior to Kenya's
2013 elections.

I have just spent a couple of days in the Western Kenyan town of
Kisumu in Nyanza Province, which sits on the edge of Lake Victoria.
The previous time I was there was back in 2009 when the burnt out
buildings on Oginga Odinga high street were yet to be rebuilt after
07/08 post-election violence. Kisumu is predominantly a Luo town,
although its general multi-ethnic quality should temper such crude
stereotyping.

On that trip my travelling companion and I negotiated a ride on a
barge that was transporting bags of cheap plastic sandals across the
lake to the Tanzanian port of Mwanza. We slept on deck and hoped the
thing wouldn't sink. The shipping company is Indian-owned, as are many
of the more successful businesses in the town - it is a busy,
energetic and noisy place.

Kisumu is also the traditional heartland of opposition politics in
Kenya and its most famous (living) son, Raila Odinga, is a member of
an equally historic oppositionist political dynasty. Raila's father,
Oginga Odinga, formed the Forum for Democracy (Ford) in 1991, which
facilitated the start of Kenya's new era of multi-party politics and
was previously Vice President under Kenyatta #1.

So when I was there I wanted to meet some 'opposition' people ie
members of Odinga's Orange Democratic Movement, and see what they
thought of the last 12 months of Jubilee government and the election
that preceded it. I vainly chased a local ward representative around
by phone for a day and a half, but found out that he had missed his
flight and was still in Nairobi. Another possible lead had to go to a
funeral.

But as ever, if you want to take the political temperature of a place
the best thing to do is just to talk to lots of people. You might not
get the absolute, objective truth about what's going on there, but
you'll find out what people think is happening, which in many respects
is just as important.

So in my quest for someone to talk to I visited ODM's Kisumu Central
constituency HQ. I was expecting at least some measure of party
activity there, even if it just consisted of a few apparatchiks asleep
at their desks. But the building was pretty much empty and reminded me
of a rural school (minus the children) with one desk (no one was sat
at it) and a few plastic chairs.

A pair of mild-mannered guys sat by the door and after we had
completed the normal handshakes and politeness they introduced
themselves as the building's caretaker and the Kisumu Central 'Youth
Organiser'. After a brief chat about the election (stolen) and the ODM
leadership (Raila Forever!) I left, slightly puzzled.

I wondered whether I'd gone to the wrong place, or whether this
constituency was a particularly poorly run one and mentioned this to a
couple of journalists I met at the Kisumu bureau offices of Nation
Media. They laughed and explained that in Kenya political parties
don't really bother with big physical structures - these offices were
just a base where party activists or supporters could be brought
together on occasion to campaign for the Big Man.

This is because political parties in Kenya are loose, temporary
formations surrounding individual politicians such as Odinga. If you
actually want to meet any major politicians who represent, in this
case, Kisumu, then don't bother actually coming here - they all live
in Nairobi. Raila may 'vie' (a nice Kenyan way of saying 'campaign')
as the chosen representative of Western Kenya, and particularly the
Luo people, but his supporters are as much a vehicle for his own
political advancement.

Big deal, you might say - isn't that always the case in a democracy?
Yes, but in many poorer countries with misfiring democracies, and I
don't see Kenya as unique in this regard, the relationship is
unbalanced. The Big Man gets more out of it than he gives back. And
let's not forget, Kenya's MPs are the best remunerated in the world,
so political power pays - literally.

I don't mean to specifically pick on Raila here; all Kenya's regional
political leaders have their own personalised parties which they roll
out at elections and then form alliances with suitable allies, largely
on the basis of ethnic arithmetic. In 2013 Raila's ODM combined with
his deputy, Kalonzo Musyoka's Wiper and Moses Wetangula's Ford-Kenya
to form the Coalition for Reform and Democracy (Cord). Uhuru
Kenyatta's Jubilee Alliance was made up from his own 'The National
Alliance' (TNA) party, William Ruto's URP, Najib Balala's RCP and
Charity Ngilu's Narc - all vehicles for the personal elevation of the
leader, with promises of great returns for their supporters.

In terms of local representation ie who becomes MP, or under the new
devolved system, Governor, Senator or other local political
representatives, it's less about what happens on the day of the
general election, and more about who wins each party's primary
elections - which select the candidates who get to run for each seat.
The most violent part of the 2013 election were the primaries, as
local people, particularly in the case of ODM, resented the candidates
they thought had been imposed upon them from the top.

Most constituencies in Kenya are dominated by one ethnic group or
another, which means they generally vote overwhelmingly for a
particular candidate. There aren't too many constituencies where the
population demographics result in a close race. It's notable that in
2013, candidates who tried to run national campaigns that were
distinctly technocratic and non-ethnic - notably Martha Karua
(Narc-Kenya) and Peter Kenneth (Kenya National Congress) - did
disastrously on polling day.

It seemed amusing at the time, but the fact that Mohamed Dida
(Alliance of Real Change) - a previously unknown Kenyan-Somali teacher
from Wajir - should have beaten the experienced Martha Karua into 5th
and only trailed Kenneth by 20,000 votes is very revealing. That being
said, if I was a Kenyan-Somali I would probably have considered voting
for Dida too, having experienced many indignities and little
development effort under previous more mainstream leadership.

A Kenyan friend, whose analyses I rate considerably more highly than
my own, has already half jokingly warned me against only talking to
civil society, whose opinions - whether they are right or wrong -
regarding the current government, are extremely negative.  So I hope
this post redresses the balance a little- I did quote Gladwell Otieno
once, but I think her argument here is reasonably uncontroversial.

What I learned on this trip to Kisumu, other than the virtue of
patience, was that political mobilisation in Kenyan is very much about
human capital. And in many ways it is amazingly effective - Kenya had
85% turnout in 2013, which is absolutely astounding. This is proof
that the country's political parties had a very good ground game, but
to what end you might ask? What exactly is at stake in this game of
political mobilisation? Another post on that in a few days, I think.

Magnus Taylor is Editor of African Arguments.

-- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14oojjq86SB6bzoHH2Wanb01%2BByRO%3D2Akxj0ArGerEhiosw%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to