---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: John Ashworth <[email protected]>
Date: Sat, Nov 28, 2015 at 7:42 AM
Subject: [sudans-john-ashworth] 'Enough of aid – let’s talk reparations'
To: Group <[email protected]>


"The reparations debate is threatening because it completely upends
the usual narrative of development. It suggests that poverty in the
global south is not a natural phenomenon, but has been actively
created. And it casts western countries in the role not of
benefactors, but of plunderers."

Enough of aid – let’s talk reparations

Debate around reparations is threatening because it upends the usual
narrative of development. The impact of colonialism cannot be ignored

Jason Hickel  |  Guardian
Friday 27 November 2015 13.06 GMT Last modified on Friday 27 November
201513.07 GMT

Colonialism is one of those things you’re not supposed to discuss in
polite company – at least not north of the Mediterranean. Most people
feel uncomfortable about it, and would rather pretend it didn’t
happen.

In fact, that appears to be the official position. In the mainstream
narrative of international development peddled by institutions from
the World Bank to the UK’s Department of International Development,
the history of colonialism is routinely erased. According to the
official story, developing countries are poor because of their own
internal problems, while western countries are rich because they
worked hard, and upheld the right values and policies. And because the
west happens to be further ahead, its countries generously reach out
across the chasm to give “aid” to the rest – just a little something
to help them along.

If colonialism is ever acknowledged, it’s to say that it was not a
crime, but rather a benefit to the colonised – a leg up the
development ladder.

But the historical record tells a very different story, and that opens
up difficult questions about another topic that Europeans prefer to
avoid: reparations. No matter how much they try, however, this topic
resurfaces over and over again. Recently, after a debate at the Oxford
Union, Indian MP Shashi Tharoor’s powerful case for reparations went
viral, attracting more than 3 million views on YouTube. Clearly the
issue is hitting a nerve.

The reparations debate is threatening because it completely upends the
usual narrative of development. It suggests that poverty in the global
south is not a natural phenomenon, but has been actively created. And
it casts western countries in the role not of benefactors, but of
plunderers.

When it comes to the colonial legacy, some of the facts are almost too
shocking to comprehend. When Europeans arrived in what is now Latin
America in 1492, the region may have been inhabited by between 50
million and 100 million indigenous people. By the mid 1600s, their
population was slashed to about 3.5 million. The vast majority
succumbed to foreign disease and many were slaughtered, died of
slavery or starved to death after being kicked off their land. It was
like the holocaust seven times over.

What were the Europeans after? Silver was a big part of it. Between
1503 and 1660, 16m kilograms of silver were shipped to Europe,
amounting to three times the total European reserves of the metal. By
the early 1800s, a total of 100m kg of silver had been drained from
the veins of Latin America and pumped into the European economy,
providing much of the capital for the industrial revolution. To get a
sense for the scale of this wealth, consider this thought experiment:
if 100m kg of silver was invested in 1800 at 5% interest – the
historical average – it would amount to £110trn ($165trn) today. An
unimaginable sum.

Europeans slaked their need for labour in the colonies – in the mines
and on the plantations – not only by enslaving indigenous Americans
but also by shipping slaves across the Atlantic from Africa. Up to 15
million of them. In the North American colonies alone, Europeans
extracted an estimated 222,505,049 hours of forced labour from African
slaves between 1619 and 1865. Valued at the US minimum wage, with a
modest rate of interest, that’s worth $97trn – more than the entire
global GDP.

Right now, 14 Caribbean nations are in the process of suing Britain
for slavery reparations. They point out that when Britain abolished
slavery in 1834 it compensated not the slaves but rather the owners of
slaves, to the tune of £20m, the equivalent of £200bn today. Perhaps
they will demand reparations equivalent to this figure, but it is
conservative: it reflects only the price of the slaves, and tells us
nothing of the total value they produced during their lifetimes, nor
of the trauma they endured, nor of the hundreds of thousands of slaves
who worked and died during the centuries before 1834.

These numbers tell only a small part of the story, but they do help us
imagine the scale of the value that flowed from the Americas and
Africa into European coffers after 1492.

Then there is India. When the British seized control of India, they
completely reorganised the agricultural system, destroying traditional
subsistence practices to make way for cash crops for export to Europe.
As a result of British interventions, up to 29 million Indians died of
famine during the last few decades of the 19th century in what
historian Mike Davis calls the “late Victorian holocaust”. Laid head
to foot, their corpses would stretch the length of England 85 times
over. And this happened while India was exporting an unprecedented
amount of food, up to 10m tonnes per year.

British colonisers also set out to transform India into a captive
market for British goods. To do that, they had to destroy India’s
impressive indigenous industries. Before the British arrived, India
commanded 27% of the world economy, according to economist Angus
Maddison. By the time they left, India’s share had been cut to just
3%. The same thing happened to China. After the Opium Wars, when
Britain invaded China and forced open its borders to British goods on
unequal terms, China’s share of the world economy dwindled from 35% to
an all-time low of 7%.

Meanwhile, Europeans increased their share of global GDP from 20% to
60% during the colonial period. Europe didn’t develop the colonies.
The colonies developed Europe.

And we haven’t even begun to touch the scramble for Africa. In the
Congo, to cite just one brief example, as historian Adam Hochschild
recounts in his haunting book King Leopold’s Ghost, Belgium’s lust for
ivory and rubber killed some 10 million Congolese – roughly half the
country’s population. The wealth gleaned from that plunder was
siphoned back to Belgium to fund beautiful stately architecture and
impressive public works, including arches and parks and railway
stations – all the markers of development that adorn Brussels today,
the bejewelled headquarters of the European Union.

We could go on. It is tempting to see this as just a list of crimes,
but it is much more than that. These snippets hint at the contours of
a world economic system that was designed over hundreds of years to
enrich a small portion of humanity at the expense of the vast
majority.

This history makes the narrative of international development seem a
bit absurd, and even outright false. Frankie Boyle got it right: “Even
our charity is essentially patronising. Give a man a fish and he can
eat for a day. Give him a fishing rod and he can feed himself.
Alternatively, don’t poison the fishing waters, abduct his
great-grandparents into slavery, then turn up 400 years later on your
gap year talking a lot of shite about fish.”

We can’t put a price on the suffering wrought by colonialism. And
there is not enough money in the world to compensate for the damage it
inflicted. We can, however, stop talking about charity, and instead
acknowledge the debt that the west owes to the rest of the world. Even
more importantly, we can work to quash the colonial instinct whenever
it rears its ugly head, as it is doing right now in the form of land
grabs, illicit financial extraction, and unfair trade deals.

Shashi Tharoor argued for a reparations payment of only £1 – a token
acknowledgement of historical fact. That might not do much to assuage
thecontinued suffering of those whose countries have been ravaged by
the colonial encounter. But at least it would set the story straight,
and put us on a path towards rebalancing the global economy.

http://www.theguardian.com/global-development-professionals-network/2015/nov/27/enough-of-aid-lets-talk-reparations

END
______________________
John Ashworth

[email protected]

+254 725 926 297 (Kenya mobile)
+211 919 695 362 (South Sudan mobile)
+27 79 832 8834 (South Africa mobile)
+44 750 364 2508 (UK/international)
+88 216 4334 0735 (Thuraya satphone)

PO Box 52662 - 00100, Nairobi, Kenya

This is a personal e-mail address and the contents do not necessarily
reflect the views of any organisation

--
--
The content of this message does not necessarily reflect John Ashworth's
views. Unless explicitly stated otherwise, John Ashworth is not the author
of the content and the source is always cited.

You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"sudan-john-ashworth" group.
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected]
For more options, visit this group at
http://groups.google.co.za/group/sudan-john-ashworth
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"sudans-john-ashworth" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an
email to [email protected].
Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/sudans-john-ashworth.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

-- 
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at 
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14oqcQQVjdnggL80_C9c%3DYwmSL%2Bgv9TOSfzwR5xDznz0cwQ%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to