South Sudanese opposition faction says for states based on federalism
Article
Comments (36)
email Email
print Print
pdfSave
separation
increase
decrease
separation
separation
facebookmyspacetwitterbuzzyahoo
December 31, 2015 (ADDIS ABABA) – The recently established 28 states
have not been based on federalism which has been the popular demand of
the people of South Sudan for several decades, says the armed
opposition faction of the Sudan People’s Liberation Movement (SPLM-IO)
led by former vice-president, Riek Machar.
PNG - 36 kb
Officials of the opposition were responding to an argument by the
government that the 28 states were created in response to the interest
and calls from the people for more states.
“The government is attempting to fool the people. Their 28 states
proposal is not federalism. This is the reason the unilateral
amendment by the national legislature is silent about federalism. They
have shied away from enshrining federalism in the constitution when
they amended it in favour of creation of more states,” said James
Gatdet Dak, opposition leader’s spokesman.
“The government still calls the system decentralization, but with more
states. It is the same old system multiplied,” he said.
The opposition leadership, he said, maintained the call on President
Salva Kiir to reverse his decision which he said is a violation of the
peace agreement based on the constitutionally recognized 10 states.
He said the opposition does not recognize the 28 states and will
implement the peace agreement based on the 10 states.
Dak, however said the SPLM-IO is committed to the implementation of
the peace agreement and would not want to derail it, adding it will
address the matter through the right forums such as constitutional
amendment or making processes as stipulated in the peace agreement.
He also dismissed claims from the government that it only added 7
states to the initial proposal of 21 states by the SPLM-IO during the
peace negotiations in Addis Ababa, saying there was a big difference.
“No, there is a big difference. Our proposed 21 states have been
studied and are based on 21 former colonial districts with historical
boundaries. We also base their creation on federal system of
governance. Again, the government did not take all the 21 states
exactly as we proposed them and added 7,” he said.
He also argued that another difference in approach was that the
SPLM-IO tabled their proposal to the peace talks with the government,
which he said the government rejected and could not come up with a
counter proposal of 28 states for discussion, amendment or
endorsement, forcing the parties to sign the agreement on the basis of
the constitutionally recognized 10 states.
The majority of the 28 states, he added, are problematic as they
encourage tribal segregations and don’t have historical known
boundaries and therefore serve as a recipe for future conflicts
between communities whose lands have been taken away and given to
other communities.
The creation of 28 states, according to him, are also an attempt by
the government to reopen the peace deal for renegotiation, dismissing
government’s claim that the SPLM-IO will simply be given governorship
positions of the new states curved from the previous two states of
Unity and Upper Nile, plus their 40% of executive power sharing in the
two states plus Jonglei’s new three states, excluding Boma state.
“First of all, we did not agree with the government on how many more
states to be created and on which basis. So why would they
unilaterally decide on behalf of the rest of the parties to the peace
agreement? This is a serious violation. Second, 28 states will alter
the power sharing agreement and reopen the accord for renegotiation,”
he added.
He said there would be not only 28 executives now, but 28 state
legislative assemblies, explaining that the peace agreement only
provided for reinstatement and reconstitution of former elected
members of state assemblies.
Now that more state assemblies would be created from the scratch, this
would in violation of the agreement need renegotiation on how to share
the membership of the new state assemblies.
Dak also said the membership of the Council of States in Juba would be
affected by the change from 10 to 28 states, and this would require
another negotiation on representation to the upper house from the new
states, among others.
To avoid the situation of renegotiating the agreement, he said, the
matter will be tackled through the Joint Monitoring and Evaluation
Commission (JMEC) so that the government would be told to reverse or
suspend its 28 states and to keep it as a proposal for tabling during
the constitutional amendment or making process.
He said the SPLM-IO would stick to the 10 states in the agreement and
called on the international community to exert pressure on the
government to suspend its unilateral action, arguing that there was no
need for such actions when the opposition advance team was already in
the national capital, Juba, to implement the agreement with the
government.
(ST)
Comments on the Sudan Tribune website must abide by the following
rules. Contravention of these rules will lead to the user losing their
Sudan Tribune account with immediate effect.
- No inciting violence
- No inappropriate or offensive language
- No racism, tribalism or sectarianism
- No inappropriate or derogatory remarks
- No deviation from the topic of the article
- No advertising, spamming or links
- No incomprehensible comments
Due to the unprecedented amount of racist and offensive language on
the site, Sudan Tribune tries to vet all comments on the site.
There is now also a limit of 400 words per comment. If you want to
express yourself in more detail than this allows, please e-mail your
comment as an article to [email protected]
Kind regards,
The Sudan Tribune editorial team.
31 December 07:31, by Lotodo Awino Odug
That is what happen when you practice bad politics, a smart person
will take it and use it against you. now you got served with your own
coin.
repondre message
31 December 08:05, by Mi diit
Lotodo,
You are right to some extent. For example, Dr. Riek proposed
self-determination and somebody came in and used it.
Now he proposed federal system with 21 states and somebody
came in and partially implement it in a wrong way.
Don’t worry, these will be corrected.
repondre message
31 December 09:39, by Lotodo Awino Odug
Don’t cry of isolation, this the hedge farm you guys have
been cultivating.you think you are important to others, so be your
own.
repondre message
31 December 10:51, by Khent
Mi diit
Riek did not propose self-determination, you lying
scoundrel. South Sudanese spoke of self-determination many decades
before Riek counter-intuitively thought that allying with Khartoum
would somehow ensure self-determination. Even Garang spoke of
self-determination and was what required to achieve it almost two
decades before Riek.
repondre message
31 December 11:02, by Khent
Dr. John Garang also spoke of the need for federalism
more than 30 years before Riek. You seem to view Riek as a God of some
sorts and think that you can get away with ascribing to him every
progressive political cause, objective or struggle. I won’t allow you
to do that.
repondre message
31 December 13:23, by Mi diit
Khent,
Don’t forget that to say something is one thing
and to do it is another. True, many spoke of self determination and
federalism for several decades before Garang and Riek were born. But
Riek championed self determination like he is now championing
federalism.
Stop your stupid jealousy!
repondre message
31 December 14:08, by Khent
Mi diit
Riek did nothing to physically achieve
self-determination. He just gave lip service to it while enabling
Khartoum to take control of the oilfields. That’s his legacy. There’s
nothing to be jealous about. Why should I be jealous of an idiot that
was ’tricked’ [his words not mine] by Khartoum? That’s like being
jealous of a donkey...
repondre message
31 December 14:08, by Khent
How exactly did Riek champion
self-determination? Did he champion self-determination by getting into
a military alliance with the Ignaz Nazis? By unleashing a tribal
militia to slaughter thousands of civilians? By getting too dependent
on Khartoum that he couldn’t maneuver without their approval?
repondre message
31 December 14:09, by Khent
Did he champion the right to
self-determination when his pathetic agreement was entirely dishonored
by Khartoum? He didn’t bring self-determination, however, he did offer
himself to Khartoum and was treated like a prostitute as a result.
Riek is a male prostitute.
repondre message
31 December 14:10, by Khent
How did Riek ostensibly champion
self-determination? Oh, that’s right, he turned to Khartoum. You
cannot seek independence from someone when you’re wholly reliant upon
them for every nail, every litre of oil, every platform, every box of
ammunition and their logistical support. Everything!
repondre message
31 December 14:11, by Khent
You quite laughably try to
justify Riek’s stupidity by saying that he was the first to ’succeed’
in getting Khartoum to enshrine the right to self-determination in the
’constitution’. Khartoum doesn’t regard documents, conventions and
constitutions as worthy of compliance in the absence of force. Does it
have any regard for the Geneva convention!? Of course it doesn’t...
repondre message
31 December 14:12, by Khent
.. So what makes you think
that they would regard the KPA with even a smidgen of sanctity!? Riek
is a third rate warlord. They played that fool like a banjo. He was
trapped. He couldn’t do anything without their approval. He needed
Khartoum to supply him with platforms, weapons, ammunition, fuel,
food-relief... everything!
repondre message
31 December 14:13, by Khent
A genocidal, State
sponsor of terror doesn’t give a damn about some flimsy document,
otherwise they wouldn’t have murdered millions of people in
contravention of the Geneva convention. The Sudanese ’constitution’
quite hilariously also speaks about how all Sudanese should be treated
equally. It is worthless.
repondre message
31 December 14:15, by Khent
The fact that
Khartoum feigned sincerity when it enshrined the right to
Self-Determination in the Constitution speaks volume of their cunning
and political skill... and of their ability to manipulate the stupid,
the naive and the myopic. Khartoum had no intention of honoring these
commitments, especially when it was they that armed, fed and provided
Riek’s forces with logistical support.
repondre message
31 December
14:17, by Khent
The late Dr.
John Garang very well understood that you couldn’t possibly be taken
seriously by Khartoum and achieve a political settlement with the
Ignaz Nazis, without an independent army... with an independent source
of funding, a separate source of weaponry and ammunition and a
separate line of logistics.
repondre message
31
December 14:18, by Khent
In his
1972 letter to Joseph Lagu, Dr. John Garang warned that the Addis
Ababa Agreement would be dishonored in its entirety if the South
didn’t have a truly independent army. You guys went the other way
round. You got it backwards. You thought that Khartoum would take you
more seriously the more dependent you became. Riek admitted that he
got cheated. He didn’t get cheated, he’s just an idiot.
repondre message
31
December 14:19, by Khent
Dr.
John Garang made it clear in his 1972 letter to Joseph Lagu that South
Sudan had the right to secede but he also understood that autonomy or
independence couldn’t be "guaranteed by a few phrases scribbled on
some sheets of paper stapled and bound together and christened “The
Constitution”."
repondre message
31
December 14:19, by Khent
Dr. John Garang made the point "that a region retains the right to
secede from the federation if its interests are not adequately served
by the federation."
Furthermore, he said:
"It must be clear to Southerners that the retention of the right to
secede from such a federation must be guaranteed by the federal
constitution and by the existence of a physical Southern Armed
Forces."
repondre message
31 December 14:20, by Khent
Allow me to quote other parts of the 1972 letter:
"There is no reason, absolutely no objective reason for clearheaded
Southerners and Northerners alike to believe after eight years and
more of continuous warfare and the repeated failures of some forms of
constitutional guarantees that paper constitutional guarantees are now
going to solve the war in the Sudan."
repondre message
31 December 14:21, by Khent
Any Southerner who holds the mistaken view that Arab Nationalism
now sincere, now means good business, now gives the South local
autonomy in good faith and that this autonomy will be guaranteed by a
few phrases scribbled on some sheets of paper stapled and bound
together and christened “ The Constitution”...
repondre message
31 December 14:22, by Khent
..that Southerner either suffers from acute historical myopia
or else advocates the treasonable stand of opportunism, national
subjugation and continued Arab Chauvinism and domination; in short,
such Southerner calls for surrender in a camouflaged form. (Captain
John Garang Letter to Gen. Joseph Lagu of Anyanya One, January 24,
1972)
repondre message
31 December 14:23, by Khent
Citing Dr. John Garang
Self-determination is not given, one determines his
future, we do have self-determination in the areas we have control,
and if you believe that the Khartoum government has given you
self-determination, then go back and ask Khartoum to withdraw its
troops from the three capital cities of South Sudan–Juba, Malakal and
Wau–and I (Garang) promise that I will not attack you..
repondre message
31 December 14:23, by Khent
Your claim of self-determination of the South Sudan
while in Khartoum means that you have surrendered. I also believe that
when the people of South Sudan are given an opportunity to vote in the
referendum, they will vote almost 100% for independence.
repondre message
31 December 14:24, by Khent
Did you read that Mi Diit? Dr. John Garang knew
that Riek’s pathetic agreement with Khartoum was a mirage and a cruel
hoax, and he challenged Riek to demonstrate that Khartoum was sincere
with regards to self-determination by having Khartoum withdraw its
forces from Juba, Malakal and Wau... but Riek couldn’t even get
Khartoum to withdraw from Bentiu - the capital of his home State...
repondre message
31 December 14:25, by Khent
..In fact not only did Khartoum not withdraw
from Bentiu, they expelled Riek and his forces out of Bentiu and Unity
State in general. That is how incredibly stupid Riek is. This man is
wise in your eyes? This is the man I am supposedly ’jealous’ of? LOL!
The man is an idiot. I know toddlers smarter than him. ROFL!
repondre message
31 December 14:27, by Khent
To cite Dr. Douglas H. Johnson:
Those sympathetic to Riek claim that he
was genuine in his desire to disentangle himself from Khartoum and saw
acceptance by the NDA as his last chance to obtain alternative sources
of arms, which alone would free him from dependence from Khartoum.
repondre message
31 December 14:27, by Khent
If this was true, it is consistent
with the confused, almost schizophrenic attitude towards liberation
and collaboration, which he displayed from the beginning of the failed
Nasir coup attempt in August 1991 to his resignation from the
government in February 2000.
repondre message
31 December 14:29, by Khent
"The government benefited
substantially from the split inside the SPLA. The government had
encouraged the split by sending false signals that it might let the
South secede." (Sudan-Contested identities, Ann Lesch)
repondre message
31 December 14:29, by Khent
Once the split occurred, the
government developed a four-prong strategy that encouraged Riek machar
to fight the SPLA. It backed away from offering independence, mounted
large scale offences against Garang’s forces and used the
disintegration of the SPLA to facilitate its repression of the African
people in Southern Kordofan, Darfur and Southern Blue Nile.
(Sudan-Contested identities)
repondre message
31 December 08:09, by Eastern
...Kiir is not playing smart politics either; he’s simply
gambling with governance! He’s recently told governors sworn before
him that some will have to resign to pave way for SPLM-io appointees.
He said he didn’t appoint women governors because they are weak and
could be abducted. What’s really wrong with this cattle camp leaders?!
repondre message
31 December 08:32, by Lotodo Awino Odug
his argument on the choice of women governors is lame
although he can still score some points on it. on the rebels’ side,
Riek was wrong to proposed his 21 states in the first place. a real
freedom fighter will not have divided the country with the hope to
rallied disgruntled Equatorians, to join his side. this is downright
unpatriotic and traitorous.
repondre message
31 December 11:04, by okucu pa lotinokwan
Please Dak come and us let talk on it from Juba than talking ro Adis
repondre message
31 December 15:33, by Frak Cho
Gatdet Dak needs to remember that, the advance team of 150
members got 21 members as governors. Again, when President Bashir of
Sudan ordered creation of 10 States in the South, SPLM - mainstream
didn’t say anything but only pushed ahead for peace. 98% of the
population received 28 States with jubilation, so accept the reality
please and lets move on. Do not dwell on colonial thing!
repondre message
31 December 08:27, by jubaone
I like James Gatdet´s consistent, logical and sequential ppproach
of putting the SPLM-IÖ position against the 28 states of Kiir and his
jaang congregation of evilmen jce. Sadly, Kiir has been misled and
fooled even by his legal advisor, Korbandy (Kor-Bandit). Soon he will
drop the 28 states, jusr wait.
repondre message
31 December 09:18, by Uncle J
Gadet Dak anabonga "gas" anyway because his argument is making no
sense...suppose he refer to it as a tug of war between Nuer and Dinka
in politics. Nuer mentality thinks federal system introduced by dinka
is not a federal system, what a silly politics!!!
repondre message
31 December 11:07, by Mapuor
We need peace guys. Decentralization is a component of
federalism,infact it is a stage in transition to full federal system.
Borders were very clear between counties in greater Upper Nile. We
don’t see any problem in demarcation of borders. The biggest problems
are border between Western Lakes and Southern Liec state(Madol and
Abhor-Bhor Jani)
--
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14opAnXWmMesUgP0uNTyonwE-r_x5u1pQphrS6X0m-Ld2pw%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.