---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: "Eric Reeves" <[email protected]>
Date: 6 Jan 2016 03:24
Subject: A Massive Catastrophe Looming in Darfur: Forcing displaced persons
from camps in Darfur is a prelude to camp dismantling
To: "Eric Reeves" <[email protected]>
Cc:

*A Massive Catastrophe Looming in Darfur: **Forcing displaced persons from
camps in Darfur is a prelude to camp dismantling*

Eric Reeves | January 5, 2016 | http://wp.me/p45rOG-1Qo

Recent statements from the Khartoum regime’s Second Vice-President, Hasabo
Mohamed Abdelrahman, suggest that the National Islamic Front/National
Congress Party is in fact moving more aggressively toward its *long-announced
plans to shut down and dismantle the camps for displaced persons in Darfur*,
a move that will have catastrophic consequences for these highly vulnerable
populations, many of which are badly weakened by years of compromised
humanitarian services and the fact of recent displacement. Outside the
camps they will confront a vast, chaotic, immensely destructive maelstrom
of violence, chiefly that orchestrated by Khartoum’s regular Sudan Armed
Forces and the regime’s primary Arab militia ally, the Rapid Support Forces
(RSF):

In a speech delivered before the representatives of former rebel groups and
IDPs in El-Fasher, North Darfur on Monday, [Second Vice-President Hasabo
Mohamed Abdelrahman] said *Darfur has "completely recovered from the war *and
is now looking forward to achieve a full peace, stability and development."

"IDP camps represent a significant and unfortunate loss of dignity and
rights of citizens in their country" he said and *called on the displaced
"to choose within no more than a month between resettlement or return to
their original areas."*

He further reiterated his *government’s commitment to take all the measures
and do the needful to achieve this goal, stressing that "the year 2016 will
see the end of displacement in Darfur."* Abdel Rahman told the meeting that
he has just ended a visit to *Karnoi and Tina areas in North Darfur, adding
the two areas which were affected by the conflict have totally recovered.* He
said his visit with a big delegation to the two areas "is a message
sceptics in the fact that *security and stability are back in Darfur"…*(Sudan
Tribune, December 28, 2015
<http://www.sudantribune.com/spip.php?article57524> | El Fasher, North
Darfur) *[all **emphases **in all quotes have been added—ER]*

[image: 54c3683414b9e]
<http://sudanreeves.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/54c3683414b9e.jpeg>

*"Darfur has completely recovered from the war..." Second Vice-President
Hasabo Mohamed Abdelrahman* (photograph of militia fighters is from
November 2015)

*Radio Dabanga* also reported on this highly significant, if utterly
mendacious pronouncement:

*Sudan’s Second Vice-President, Hasabo Mohamed Abdelrahman*, said that
his *government
is determined to close the camps for displaced people in Darfur next
year **[i.e.,
2016—ER]*.

According to *Sudan Tribune*, the Second Vice President said Darfur
has *“completely
recovered from the war and is now looking forward to achieve a full peace,
stability and development.”*

“The camps represent a significant and unfortunate loss of dignity and
rights of citizens in their country,” he said, and called on the displaced
people *“to choose within no more than a month between **resettlement or
return to their original areas.” *(Radio Dabanga, December 29, 2015
<https://www.dabangasudan.org/en/all-news/article/vp-sudan-determined-to-close-darfur-camps>
|
Um Baru, North Darfur [“Vice President: Sudan determined to close Darfur
camps”)

[image: 268_1_0]
<http://sudanreeves.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/268_1_0.jpg>

*The Khartoum regime's Second Vice-President, Hasabo Mohamed
Abdelrahman---point-man in the dismantling camps for displaced persons in
Darfur*

The international community should hear Hasabo’s words with the greatest
concern, particularly in his speaking of his “*government’s commitment to
take all the measures and do the needful to achieve this goal”* of
compulsory “repatriation.” The consequences of what will ultimately be
forced expulsions from camps will be tremendous increases in violence, and
mortality related to violence, a fact of which Darfuris are well aware. The
response from the camps to Hasabo’s comments was predictable:

The Darfur Displaced and Refugees Association described the *plans to
dismantle the camps as “a major risk” and a violation of international
humanitarian laws* and human rights charters. Hussein Abu Sharati, the
spokesman for the Association, told Radio Dabanga that there are no
sufficient justifications for the dismantling of the camps.

“If the government would have realised a comprehensive peace in Darfur and
Sudan, the displaced would have returned to their villages already – with
the support from humanitarian organisations,” he said. *“But we are still
living in a war-like situation, with almost daily attacks by militiamen who
kill, plunder, and rape with complete impunity.”*

*“The current situation in Darfur is much too dangerous for any return,”* Abu
Sharati added. “The entire region has been handed to militias. If the
government cannot protect themselves in Darfur, how can it protect the
people returning to their places of origin?” He stressed that *the
displaced would very much want to return, “yet only after the militiamen
have been disarmed, and a secure and stable situation has been realised.”*

These comments would take the same form in any of the IDP camps in Darfur.
To the duplicitous inducement offered by Khartoum officials—offering to
provide displaced persons with new, “model villages”—the response has also
been unambiguous:

*The residents of villages in the area of Aro in Wadi Azum locality,
Central Darfur, took to the streets on Tuesday in protest against the
construction of a model village in the area.* The coordinator of Central
Darfur camps for the displaced reported that the demonstrators moved to the
Aro Basic School, chanting slogans against the commissioner of the
locality, who was holding a speech at the school. *The police responded by
firing into the air to disperse the crowd. The shooting ignited fire at
three school classes…*

The Qatari government planned to fund the construction of water wells in 11
Darfur localities, as well as 10 model villages at a total cost of $70
million… *[The Qataris are here simply attempting to “buy” the success of
their ill-conceived, ill-fated, and diplomatically disastrous “Doha
Document for Peace in Darfur” (see below) for which they provided auspices;
there is no consideration of the security needs of displaced persons—ER]*

The Darfur displaced reject their relocation to model villages as they
consider the situation in the conflict-torn western region far from secure
enough to leave the camps. Radio Dabanga, December 31, 2015 | Wadi Azum,
(Central)/West Darfur [“Central Darfur villagers reject model village
<https://www.dabangasudan.org/en/all-news/article/central-darfur-villagers-reject-model-village>
”]

Even more emphatic were these words from North Darfur, where violence is
greatest:

*The reactions of the displaced have continued to escalate following the
announcement by the Second Vice President, Second Vice-President Hassabo
Abdelrahman, that all camps will be dismantled in 2016.* The displaced of
the camps in Darfur have demanded the causes of the problems be solved
first, before agreeing to the government’s option of dismantling the camps.

*Omda Ahmed Ateem, coordinator of North Darfur camps, told Radio Dabanga
that “now is not the time for the government’s option of dismantling the
camp.” He said “the regime has committed crimes of genocide and ethnic
cleansing*. It must be removed first.” He asserts that all the camps are
under the responsibility of the UN. “The UN has a right to act and not the
government…”

The displaced of Central/(formerly West) Darfur camps have also refused the
government’s plans of re-planning and voluntary return. *The Coordinator of
the Central Darfur camps told Radio Dabanga that the process of dismantling
the camps is the government’s declaration of war and genocide again through
starvation and forced displacement. He said the villages from which they
have been displaced are now occupied by new [Arab] settlers.*

*He asserted that “the government’s move to dismantle the camps should be
seen in the context of transferring the ownership of the displaced people’s
lands to the new settlers.” *(Radio Dabanga, January 1, 2016 | North Darfur
<https://www.dabangasudan.org/en/all-news/article/anger-escalates-over-sudan-s-plans-to-dismantle-camps>
[“Anger
Escalates Over Sudan’s Plans to Dismantle Camps”])

That the international community fails to hear these assessments from
Darfuris—or to understand the implications of Hasabo’s words, or to take
seriously Khartoum’s plans—only encourages the regime to proceed. Hasabo’s
comments were, as such comments typically are, a test of the international
response; and so far the world has failed miserably in responding to the
immense dangers reflected in Khartoum’s newly energized ambitions—or to the
character of those announcing these ambitions.

In its singularly important report on the current violence in Darfur, Human
Rights Watch reported (September 2015) on the character of the Rapid
Support Forces
<https://www.hrw.org/report/2015/09/09/men-no-mercy/rapid-support-forces-attacks-against-civilians-darfur-sudan>,
now the primary militia force deployed by Khartoum in Darfur, working in
concert with the regular Sudan Armed Forces (SAF). One moment in particular
stands out in this report. According to a defecting militiaman—speaking
with the lead Human Right Watch investigator—in December 2014, the same
Second Vice President, Hassabo Mohammed Abdel Rahman, exhorted SAF regular
troops and RSF militiamen in North Darfur in the following terms:

“Hassabo told us to clear the area east of Jebel Marra...*to kill any
male.”*

“He said East Jebel Marra is the kingdom of the rebels.”

*“We don’t want anyone there to be alive.”*

“He said we want to clear the area of* insects…”*

[image: 5505641e5a0231]
<http://sudanreeves.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/5505641e5a0231.jpeg>

*Darfur's "insects"*

This is the real face of Vice President Hasabo, and the Khartoum regime as
a whole. We are currently witnessing a reprise of the brutally destructive
dry season offensives of the past three years, offensives animated by the
views expressed here by Hasabo—words he was evidently confident would never
be published in any venue.
*What Hasabo’s words about displaced persons really mean*

We must make no mistake here: *forced expulsions, by one means or another,
are what Hasabo is speaking about.* The project in its simplest and least
persuasive form was first announced early in the genocide, when violence
was at its most extreme. In the *summer of 2004*, just as humanitarian
capacity was ramping up quickly and displacement was exploding throughout
Darfur, plans for returns were being considered, and senior regime
officials spoke publicly of returns as being in “full swing”—a crude effort
at making something so by declaring it so. *Abdel Rahim Mohamed Hussein,
then Minister of the Interior and the regime’s special representative on
Darfur*, announced on Sudanese government-controlled radio on July 9, 2004
“that *86 percent of the Internally Displaced Persons had already returned
to their villages.”*  Hussein further declared that* “it was ‘most
important’ to get people to return to their villages”* *[In fact, thousands
of which had already been destroyed—ER].* Each state—the Darfur region has
three—had its own plan of return” (UN Integrated Regional Information
Networks, *July 12, 2004*). *[An arrest warrant for Hussein has been issued
by the International Criminal Court, charging him with massive crimes
against humanity in Darfur—ER]*

In *2010 *Khartoum announced a *“New Strategy for Darfur,”* little more
than a means of compelling further withdrawal by humanitarian
organizations, since humanitarian needs were declared to be no longer
compelling—a vicious example of regime mendacity (see "Accommodating
Genocide: International Response to Khartoum's 'New Strategy for
Darfur,'*" Dissent
Magazine *(on-line), October 8, 2010
<http://sudanreeves.org/2010/10/08/accommodating-genocide-international-response-to-khartoums-new-strategy-for-darfur-dissent-magazine-on-line-ocober-8-2010/>).
Disgracefully,
this cynical initiative enjoyed the enthusiastic support of the
incompetent *U.S.
special envoy for Sudan, Scott Gration*, the *equally incompetent* *AU
negotiator in failed peace talks for Darfur, former South African president
Thabo Mbeki*, and *Ibrahim Gambari of Nigeria*
<http://sudanreeves.org/2011/09/19/the-uns-man-in-darfur-the-expedient-mendacity-of-ibrahim-gambari/>
*, **head of the AU/UN “hybrid” Mission in Darfur (UNAMID)**.*

Such perverse support was not entirely unexpected, given Gration’s earlier
shocking pronouncements concerning the issue of returns by displaced
persons. Indeed, so shocking were Gration’s words in summer 2009 that he
was confronted by a “*humanitarian inter-agency management group*,” which
released harshly critical minutes of their meeting, all of which worked to
reveal Gration’s profound ignorance of the crisis he was speaking about in
such glib terms (see *Washington Post,* August 5, 2009
<http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/08/05/AR2009080503808.html>).
The same response to Gration’s assessments came from Darfuris themselves
(see “U.S. Special Envoy on Returns of Displaced Persons in Darfur,” September
2009 <http://wp.me/p45rOG-B3>); additionally, Darfuris in exile also spoke
harshly of Gration’s ignorance of the plight of IDPs (*Sudan Tribune*,
September 13, 2009 <http://www.sudantribune.com/spip.php?article32447>).

[image: imgres]
<http://sudanreeves.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/imgres1.jpg>

*Scott Gration, the disastrous former special envoy for Sudan, appointed by
President Obama despite a total lack of qualifications on Gration's part;
during his tenure he was immensely destructive of the chances for peace in
Darfur*

Presently, the expulsions Interior Minister Hussein was implicitly
demanding in 2004 would force *more than 2.5 million people* into a vast
arena of violence and extremely insecure conditions. The most recent report
from the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA)
indicates that there were, *as of December 2014, 2.5 million people
displaced in Darfur—and that 233,000 people were newly displaced in
2015* (Issue
52, December 21 – December 27, 2015
<http://reliefweb.int/sites/reliefweb.int/files/resources/OCHA_Sudan_Weekly_Humanitarian_Bulletin_Issue_52_%2821_-_27_December_2015%29.pdf>).
There is also a large population of displaced persons that does not appear
in UN figures because they are inaccessible; many of these displaced are in
remote areas of the Jebel Marra region, or remain simply uncounted in the
chaos that continues to define Darfur. It is very likely that the
populations in and around camps *well exceeds 2.5 million*—and this does
not take into account the nearly *400,000* Darfuri refugees in eastern Chad.
<http://www.unhcr.org/pages/49e45c226.html>

Nor does the UN figure take into account the more than *500,000* Darfuris
who have died from violence or the consequences of violence
<http://sudanreeves.org/2010/08/07/quantifying-genocide-darfur-mortality-update-august-6-2010/>,
now extending over 13 years. (The UN has offered no mortality estimate or
update on its figure of *300,000* Darfuris dead from violence and its
consequences since *April 2008*, nearly *eight years ago*.) This death toll
represents a significant percentage of Darfur’s pre-conflict population.
*The Experience of Darfuris “returning” to their lands and villages*

The experiences of displaced persons attempting to return to their
lands—even when nominally under the protection of the UN—have not been
encouraging, despite some minor successes. Many incidents of the following
sort have been reported, and word travels quickly in Darfur when the
subject is the security of those returning:

*[Seven] families who came back to the Guldo region [West Darfur] in the
framework of the Sudanese Government’s voluntary repatriation initiative
were found in an extremely worrying state.* Witnesses told Radio Dabanga
that they were part of *25 families who left Kalma Camp (South Darfur)* as
a *part of the Voluntary Return program. *However, the journey was too
dangerous, and 18 families were forced to travel back to their original
camp in South Darfur. *Furthermore, they reported to Radio Dabanga that the
remaining families did not receive any support from the province of West
Darfur, even though it organized the deportation*. They now call for
*international
action to save these families, who are currently in a critical state.* (Radio
Dabanga | July 26, 2011)

More recently, Radio Dabanga reported (May 1, 2013):

*Hundreds of displaced families who were returning to their areas of origin
in South Darfur in connection with seasonal farming were forced to flee
after large Misseriya [an Arab tribal group] crowds began arriving from
different parts of the region*. One of the farmers told Radio Dabanga on
Wednesday that they are “concerned” with the presence of these groups
settling in Shattai, "especially because there are so many of them and they
are armed." *The farmers fear for "disastrous consequences if the Misseriya
settle in their lands of origin.”*

The claims to African farmland by Arab militiamen and thuggish opportunists
present the greatest obstacle to peace in Darfur, and we have already seen
all too fully what happens when men and women, girls and boys decide to
leave the confines of camps, feeling that their only choice is to farm or
starve. Many making these daring efforts to farm their lands, tend their
cattle—or simply to gather wood, straw and clean water—are violently
assaulted, killed, raped, or abducted. (See *“‘Changing the Demography’:
Violent Expropriation and Destruction of Farmlands in Darfur, November 2014
– November 2015," *December 3, 2015
<http://sudanreeves.org/2015/12/13/changing-the-demography-violent-expropriation-and-destruction-of-farmlands-in-darfur-november-2014-november-2015/>,
which includes a data spreadsheet with more than 500 entries for this
one-year period, all mapped onto three regional maps of Darfur.)

[image: The annihilation of Darfur High Resolution]
<http://sudanreeves.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/The-annihilation-of-Darfur-High-Resolution.jpg>

If we add to this present destructive dynamic the wholesale displacement of
camp populations—literally forced out of the tenuous security of the camps,
which also serve as focal points for the distribution of relief aid—a
massive catastrophe will surely ensue. There may be efforts by the
displaced to re-congregate in order to continue receiving international
humanitarian relief. But Khartoum will most certainly not give access to
INGOs in Darfur to work with these re-congregating populations of displaced
persons.

Khartoum will be insistent on this point because it is key to the regime’s
larger goal: remove the rationale for any continuing international presence
in Darfur, including not only INGOs but also UNAMID
<http://sudanreeves.org/2015/06/03/abandoning-the-victims-of-genocide-in-darfur-the-huffington-post-3-june-2015/>.
If the camps are shut, no matter what the forcibly expelled populations do,
Khartoum will deny them as fully as possible humanitarian access. They are
willing to accept considerable international criticism in order to complete
what has long been a primary goal in the regime’s genocidal
counter-insurgency war in Darfur.
*KHARTOUM’S TOOLS FOR CAMP EXPULSIONS**•  Attenuation of humanitarian
capacity*

Efforts to shut down the camps and compel “returns” have long extended to
the deliberate diminishing of humanitarian capacity, both domestic and
international. As Radio Dabanga recently reported in an all too
representative dispatch:

*The residents of the Otash camp for the displaced near Nyala, capital of
South Darfur, have renewed their complaints about the shortage of drinking
water. *One of the Otash camp sheikhs told Radio Dabanga that the *drinking
water crisis started nearly one month ago after both the governmental Water
and Sanitation Department (WES) and the organisation which used to provide
fuel for the operation of the pump engines stopped their work at the camp
“without providing a reason.”* The sheikh appealed to the local and state
authorities to speed up the provision of clean drinking water to the
displaced. He pointed out that the camp residents lack the means to fetch
water from the commercial wells. “They are now forced to buy a jerry can of
water for SDG2 ($0.33).” (January 3, 2016 | Otash camp, South Darfur)

[image: 5582816bf1e12]
<http://sudanreeves.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/5582816bf1e12.jpeg>

*Lines for water in many camps can be extremely long and time-consuming;
Khartoum is deliberately exacerbating the problem in some camps*

Such efforts to make camp life increasingly unbearable have long been in
evidence and are too numerous to catalog, but are now clearly escalating
and are marked by greater coordination and targeting of critical
resources....


[full text and Appendices at | http://wp.me/p45rOG-1Qo/]

-- 

Eric Reeves
Smith College

Northampton, MA  01063

[email protected]

www.sudanreeves.org

Twitter@SudanReeves


All woodturning purchases benefit the work of Oxfam in Sudan and South Sudan

https://www.etsy.com/shop/EricReevesWoodturner

-- 
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at 
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14oroxw6JenTMvXyRgWtXhNnrFUnUTRrpyPra39Y-p_oJrw%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to