Why South Africa should undo Mandela’s economic deals
Posted on January 12, 2016 by Patrick Bond
ANC leaders were not constrained in the 1990s by a desire for economic
stability but entered into a pact with Afrikaner nationalists and big
business. This pact now needs to be broken.
Nelson Mandela addressing the International Labour Conference, Geneva,
in 1990. Credit: ILO.
Nelson Mandela addressing the International Labour Conference, Geneva,
in 1990. Credit: ILO.
Is South Africa finally maturing to the point that the economic − not
just political − compromises of the 1990s democratic transition can be
reconsidered? When engaging student activists, for example, University
of the Free State rector Jonathan Jansen frets that “If [former
President Nelson] Mandela gets any mention at all, it is as a
sell-out, the man who led South Africa into a soft transition that
left white privilege undisturbed and black poverty undiminished”.
There has been tough questioning of Mandela’s deals by a diverse range
of critics. They include: the leader of the opposition Economic
Freedom Fighters Julius Malema; Black Consciousness ideologue Andile
Mngxitama; Soweto community activist Trevor Ngwane (way back in 2003);
and Stellenbosch political economist Sampie Terreblanche.
Insiders like Winnie Madikizela-Mandela and ruling ANC stalwart and
former minister Ronnie Kasrils have equally been critical of the
compromises Mandela made. In 2013, Kasrils explained how Mandela
signed a self-sabotaging “Faustian Pact” with global capital.
In mid-1994, I saw those devils up close when I participated in
government policy debates as editor of the Reconstruction and
Development Programme White Paper, and again as drafter of the aborted
1996 National Growth and Development Strategy (Gear). In answer to the
question “Was Mandela pushed or did he jump?”, my view is that there’s
a bit of ‘structure’ – externally-imposed necessity – and individual
‘agency’ in answering ‘both’.
The crippling economic compromises
In his 2005 book and a more recent article, former Presidency official
and now academic Alan Hirsch justifies neoliberal compromises on
grounds the new government was “constrained by concerns for economic
stability”.
Yet weren’t government’s deals the main cause of subsequent economic
instability, including the half-dozen currency crashes between 1996
and 2009 when Trevor Manuel was finance minister?
The neoliberal compromises demonstrably failed the South African
society, economy and natural environment, no matter what one thinks of
the ethics and politics of these Faustian Pacts. Here are the dozen
biggest devils that hobbled Mandela’s economic legacy:
The repayment of the US$25 billion apartheid-era foreign debt.
This denied Mandela money to pay for basic needs of apartheid’s
victims.
Giving the South African Reserve Bank formal independence. This
resulted in the insulation of the central bank’s officials from
democratic accountability. It led to high interest rates and the
deregulation of exchange controls.
Borrowing $850 million from the International Monetary Fund in
December 1993, with tough conditions persisting for years. These
included rapid scrapping of import surcharges that had protected local
industries, state spending cuts, lower public sector salaries and a
decrease in wages across the board.
Reappointing apartheid’s finance minister Derek Keys and Reserve
Bank governor Chris Stals, who retained neoliberal policies.
Joining the World Trade Organisation on adverse terms, as a
“transitional”, not developing economy. This led to the destruction of
many clothing, textiles, appliances and other labour-intensive firms.
Lowering primary corporate taxes from 48% to 29% and maintaining
countless white people’s and corporate privileges.
Privatising parts of the state, such as Telkom, the state-owned
telecommunications company.
Relaxing exchange controls. This led to sustained outflows to rich
people’s overseas accounts and a persistent current account deficit
even during periods of trade surplus, and raising interest rates to
unprecedented levels.
Adopting the neoliberal macroeconomic policy Gear. This policy not
only failed on its own terms, it also caused developmental austerity.
Giving property rights dominance in the constitution, thereby
limiting its usefulness for redress.
Approving the “demutualisation” of the two mega-insurers Old
Mutual and Sanlam. It was the privatisation of historic mutual wealth
for current share owners.
Permitting most of South Africa’s ten biggest companies to move
their headquarters and primary listings abroad in the late 1990s. The
results are permanent balance of payments deficits and corporate
disloyalty to society.
I believe that this list shows that the ANC leaders were not
“constrained” in the 1990s by a desire for economic stability but
entered into a pact with Afrikaner nationalists and big business. The
constraint was mainly a concern to comply with world economic
orthodoxy at a time their prior Moscow sponsors had given up the
ghost.
Structural considerations
Consider also the structural dynamic then and still in play:
capitalism’s “financialisation”. As manufacturing and mining declined,
the share of finance in Gross Domestic Product (GDP) soared from 6% in
1994 to 13% by 2010.
Financial liberalisation gave South Africa the appearance of a healthy
GDP growth of 5%/year just prior to the 2008 world crisis. Yet given
the 1990s deals, this growth was largely froth.
It was whipped up by spending on the 2010 World Cup, by
bribery-induced white elephant infrastructure, and by the 2002-08
commodity price blip.
In addition, the early 2000s witnessed a consumer debt boom. But by
2008 soaring interest rates made repayment obligations difficult for
70% of borrowers. South Africa’s medium-term interest rates are the
fourth highest among the world’s 57 main economies, lagging only
behind Brazil, Turkey and Pakistan.
Financial froth also included what The Economist measured as the
fastest-rising speculative real estate bubble on earth from 1997 to
2008.
The froth included insane valuations of the country’s stock market. By
late 2015, the market value of the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE)
was 320% higher than GDP, the Buffet Indicator. This was the highest
recorded level of any major country’s modern stock exchange, with only
Singapore (304%) and Switzerland (281%) close.
Add in and stir South Africa’s world-leading inequality, a poverty
rate of 63%, and an unemployment spike from 16% in 1994 to 26% by 1998
with a plateau since.
What needs to be done
Given the resulting damage, isn’t it time, finally, to honestly
confront the dozen devils, and discuss how to reverse the damage, by
undoing the deals?
The ANC is notorious for talking left and walking right. Forced
corporate repatriation is one issue. Others include lowering interest
rates and, to stop capital flight, re-imposing tougher exchange
controls (as the Chinese did last week to slow outflows).
Then a genuine industrial policy could substitute for imports,
rebalance the economy and prioritise labour-intensive ecological
sustainability. Lower interest rates would also increase policy space
to raise state social spending and reorient infrastructure to meet
unmet basic needs.
But to adopt such obvious reforms would require radical economic
transformation led by an honest government, not just rhetoric from a
duplicitous, exhausted nationalist regime. And most important, it
would require a powerful democratic movement from below.
Patrick Bond is a Professor of Political Economy at the University of
the Witwatersrand.
This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the
original article.The Conversation
If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or
subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your
feed reader.
This entry was posted in African Politics Now. Bookmark the permalink.
2 thoughts on “Why South Africa should undo Mandela’s economic deals”
Adrian says:
January 13, 2016 at 12:03 am
That ‘deal’ is the ONLY thing that has kept the Lights on in SA this long.
Tau says:
January 13, 2016 at 5:51 am
So yet again everything is to blame on white folk and the
apartheid regime. No responsibility or accountability given to the
current government, who has ruled for 22 years now. Mr. Bond, with a
mentality of denial, South Africa will NEVER move forward. A person
with the intelligence of a professor, of all people, should know
better than the blame shift you have just performed in this article.
--
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
---
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14orrDsnzgFm48yjDN1mofw%3DkFzF%2ByHtH%2BobVeS5w_VnKDQ%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.