*UN says response to violence in its South Sudan camp marred by confusion/
The Guardian 22.06.16*
Simona Foltyn in Aweil, South Sudan

UN presents findings of investigation into attack on Malakal base to the
security council, as an MSF report strongly condemns peacekeepers’ response

Confusion about the rules of engagement marred the ability of the UN’s
peacekeeping mission in South Sudan (Unmiss) to protect civilians at its
compound earlier this year, it has emerged.

In a note to correspondents, the UN said on Tuesday evening that it had
completed its investigation into an attack on its protection of civilians
site (PoC) in Malakal on 17-18 February, which claimed the lives of at
least 30 displaced people and injured a further 123.

The findings are to be presented to the security council on Wednesday, but
it is unclear whether they will be made public.

Related: Gun battle in UN camp deepens South Sudan's humanitarian crisis

Violence erupted along ethnic lines in the Malakal PoC, then home to around
40,000 people, mostly from the Dinka, Nuer and Shilluk tribes. The incident
culminated in dozens of armed government soldiers from the Dinka tribe
reportedly entering the camp, yet it took UN peacekeepers more than 12
hours to intervene, according to sources interviewed by the Guardian in
March.

The UN’s announcement comes as the medical charity Médecins Sans Frontières
(MSF) released the findings of its own investigation, strongly condemning
Unmiss for its response to the incident.

“By not ensuring that adequate preventive measures were taken, failing to
act to stop the violence in a timely manner and actively blocking the IDPs
[internally displaced people] from reaching safety during a large part of
the emergency, Unmiss effectively failed to protect the civilians it is
mandated by the UN security council to protect,” said the MSF report.

Unmiss first opened its gates to people fleeing when conflict erupted in
South Sudan in December 2013. After almost two years of often ethnically
motivated fighting, a peace deal was signed in August 2015, but many PoC
residents have not been confident that it is safe to return home amid
regular ceasefire violations and mounting food insecurity across the
country. By January, six Unmiss bases around the country were sheltering
more than 200,000 IDPs.

The incident has raised broader questions about the feasibility of the
PoCs, an unprecedented concept in peacekeeping operations. Over the years,
the sites have come to resemble semi-permanent settlements, complete with
markets, clinics and rising criminality.

While UN officials say the PoCs have helped save many thousands of lives,
members of the humanitarian community fear they have turned into pockets of
insecurity and easy targets for armed groups, who may have become
emboldened by the UN’s reluctance to use force.

“The attack on Malakal PoC again raises concerns about armed actors’
respect for the camps’ sanctity and about Unmiss’s ability to provide
robust protection,” said Matt Wells, senior advisor on peacekeeping at
Center for Civilians in Conflict, an organisation that conducted its own
investigation into the incident.

Related: 'Very, very severely malnourished': South Sudan's children on the
brink | Nadene Ghouri

Protection of civilians has been a continuous source of tension between the
UN and NGOs. In Tuesday’s announcement, the UN claimed there were
“unrealistic expectations” as to the level of protection it could provide.

“How much can we be expected to protect 200,000 people in a country that is
at war?” asked one UN official in South Sudan, who didn’t want to be named.
There was a fear, the official said, that use of force against the
government’s own soldiers could quickly escalate.

UN security officials and humanitarian agencies in Malakal claimed that the
1,200 soldiers based there – from India, Rwanda and Ethiopia – could have
done more. Members of the Indian battalion refused to deploy troops or
heavy armour to the area of fighting, while Rwandan peacekeepers insisted
on written approval before acting. Once the Rwandans deployed, the
attackers were repelled within a matter of minutes. The Ethiopians, one
security official claimed, slept through the entire incident.

“The Rwandans were good when led, the Ethiopians were completely absent and
the Indians were a disgrace,” the official in Malakal summarised.

Humanitarians have pressed for accountability of peacekeeping troops. “The
UN needs to release far more about these investigations’ findings, to
provide greater transparency about who was responsible for the violence and
why the peacekeepers’ response was slow and ineffective,” said Wells.
“There needs to be accountability for any peacekeeping unit that failed to
perform.”

The UN now wants to “review the concept of protection of civilians sites”
as part of the recommendations put forward by the investigation, which
could pave the way for the disbandment of the PoCs. Since the beginning of
the year, population in the sites declined by 21%, and is currently at just
under 160,000.

Earlier this year, Unmiss angered some NGOs by announcing resettlements
from the Bor PoC site. “While humanitarians are eager to support solutions
for displaced persons, these processes are extremely complex and need to be
managed in a delicate, transparent fashion. Supporting returns without
first agreeing on a common strategy or conducting a risk assessment is
irresponsible,” said an aid worker who didn’t want to be named.

Unmiss has maintained that it will only facilitate returns that are safe
and voluntary.

-- 
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at 
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14oqRiop6SV7YZdGNRx3Dgq5WQrZaPSg15X%3DMt4QAg20eTQ%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to