The 71st Birthday Anniversary: The Towering Legacy of Dr. John Garang Posted: June 23, 2016 by *PaanLuel Wël* in Columnists <https://paanluelwel.com/category/columnists/>, Featured Articles <https://paanluelwel.com/category/featured-articles/>, History <https://paanluelwel.com/category/history/>, PaanLuel Wël <https://paanluelwel.com/category/paanluel-wel-2/>, People <https://paanluelwel.com/category/people/> 0 <https://paanluelwel.com/2016/06/23/the-71st-birthday-anniversary-the-towering-legacy-of-dr-john-garang/#respond>
Rate This *“A man came and found an animal killed and he demanded to be given ‘**ɣ**äm’ (thigh) but someone among the people said, look at this guy, how could he be so greedy that he asked for ‘**ɣ**äm’ (thigh) instead of ‘l**ɔ̈ɔ̈**m’ (rib) and so he was given ‘l**ɔ̈ɔ̈**m’ (rib). Meaning if we want Southern Sudan, we must start by asking for the whole Sudan and then surely we will be given South, but if we started with asking for the South, we would gain nothing as the Anyanya One case attest. The people of South Sudan should know that no man marries an ugly woman and no woman marries an ugly man. The unity of the Sudan has not been made attractive. I and those who joined me in the bush and fought for more than twenty years have brought to you CPA in a golden plate. Our mission is accomplished. It is now your turn, especially those who did not have a chance to experience bush life. When [the] time comes to vote at referendum, it is your golden choice to determine your fate. Would you like to vote to be second-class citizens in your own country? It is absolutely your choice,“* *Dr. John Garang’s famous “Rumbek Exhortation” delivered on May 15, 2005 at Rumbek Freedom Square, upon his arrival in Rumbek for the commemoration of the 22nd anniversary of May 16th in Rumbek, Southern Sudan.* *By PaanLuel Wël, Juba, South Sudan* [image: Tribute to Dr. John Garang] The Genius of Dr. John Garang: Tributes to the Late SPLM/A’s Leader Dr. John Garang de Mabioor (Volume 3) Paperback – July 11, 2015 by PaanLuel Wël (Editor) *June 23, 2016 (SSB) —* Garang Mabioor Atem Aruai—popularly known as Dr. John Garang—was born on 23rd June 1945 into a peasant Dinka family in Buk village of the Awulian community, Kongor District in Jonglei State, Upper Nile Region of the historical Sudan. Garang was the sixth of ten children—six boys and four girls—born to Mabioor Atem Aruai from the Awulian clan (Patem, pan-ayen) and Ghak Malwal Kuol from the Kongor clan (Padol, pareng), both of Twic Dinka from the Greater Bor Dinka Community. Young Garang left his home district of Kongor at the age of ten after the death of his father to attend school in Bahr el Ghazal. He went to Tonj Primary School (1954), followed by Bussere Intermediate School (1958), and then Rumbek Secondary School (1962) when the Anyanya One war broke out. Just after joining Rumbek Secondary School, teenage Garang was expelled for participating in a Southern-wide student-led strike—one that was fomented by the legendary Southern freedom fighter, Marko Rume. Garang’s early studies in Bahr el Ghazal formed and enshrined his life-long relationship with the Dinkas of that region, on whom he later relied and with whom he fought the long war of liberation. Stephen Madut Baak, Kerubino Kuanyin Bol, and above all Garang’s longtime comrade, deputy and eventual successor, Salva Kiir Mayardit, all hailed from the Bahr el Ghazal region. Teenage Garang joined Anyanya One on 31 December 1962 at the age of 17. >From there, he proceeded to live in Bombo Refugee Camp in Uganda between 1962 and 1963, and then in Kibera—in Nairobi, Kenya—where he worked in a restaurant to earn transport fares for his next journey to Tanzania. It was in Tanzania that he resumed and completed his interrupted high school education, studying at Magamba Secondary School in the southeastern Tanzanian town of Lushoto. After his graduation, he returned to Kenya and taught math as an untrained teacher at an Asian-owned Gatunganga Secondary School in Karatina, Central Province, near Mount Kenya. It was while he was teaching in Kenya that he secured the Thomas Watson Fellowship to Grinnell College in Iowa, US, where he graduated in 1970 with a bachelor’s degree in economics. He returned to the Sudan immediately after graduation and rejoined the Anyanya One movement in 1971. After a training stint in Israel, General Joseph Lagu commissioned him as a captain. Just eight months after his arrival, the Anyanya One leadership signed the Addis Ababa Agreement that Garang bitterly opposed, leading to the penning of his famous 1972 letter. He was absorbed into the Sudanese army after the peace accord, but demonstrated numerous acts of disobedience and rebelliousness. In a move calculated to preclude him from dragging Southerners “into trouble prematurely,” Joseph Lagu and Abel Alier recommended John Garang for a military training course in the US, from which he graduated with a master’s degree in military science, third in a class of 200 students. He pursued his studies further, earning a doctorate degree in economics from Iowa State University in 1981. Upon returning to the Sudan in 1982, he was promptly promoted to the rank of colonel, posted to the Army General Headquarters in Khartoum, and appointed as a deputy director for military research. At the same time, Garang’s American friend and schoolmate, Dr. Brian de Silva, requested him to join their faculty of agriculture at Khartoum University as an adjunct professor of agricultural economics. He accepted. It was during his time at the Army General Headquarters in Khartoum that Garang commenced reorganizing the Underground Movement for a planned revolutionary war to be launched on 18 August 1983. August 18 was chosen in homage to the Torit Mutiny that erupted on 18 August 1955. However, political and security events were getting out of control in the South, particularly in Bor, where ex-Anyanya soldiers were resisting mass transfer to the North. Thus, the Underground Movement changed tactics and launched the premeditated revolution on 16 May 1983 instead of the scheduled August 18. The SPLM/A war of liberation, which commenced on May 16, went on relentlessly for the next two decades with Garang at the helm, until the signing of the Comprehensive Peace Agreement (CPA) on 9 January 2005. Although Garang passed away in a tragic plane crash just three weeks after he was sworn in as First Vice President of the Sudan—plunging Southerners into an unprecedented state of uncertainty—a successful referendum was later conducted and Southern Sudan was declared an independent state on 9 July 2011 under the leadership of his longtime deputy and successor, Comrade Salva Kiir Mayaardit. *The Legacy of Dr. John Garang* The historical significance of Garang from the time he authored his famous letter in January 1972 to the time he died in July 2005 is that he had, more than any other South Sudanese leader (and Sudanese leader for that matter) within that brief span of time, shaken the entire edifice of power in Khartoum. True to his declaration, Sudan has not been the same since and will never be again. Garang was the political conscience of, and moral advocate for, the marginalized people of the Sudan. A Dinka from the long suppressed region of Southern Sudan, he gazed on the iron curtain of marginalization and envisaged that the vision of the New Sudan could tear it down. From the pain and exhaustion of his fight to free the marginalized people of the Sudan from a century-old bondage of political marginalization, social deprivation and economic exploitation, he wrung the most eloquent statements of his vision of what the Sudan could become. He helped Southerners overcome Khartoum’s divide and rule conspiracy, and the debilitating ignorance of clothing themselves in the insignia of a Southerner that had denied them vital allies during the Anyanya One War. He railed against the repressive policies of despotic successive regimes in Khartoum, as much as he had spoken out against self-serving opportunistic Southern comrades who were ready to betray and sacrifice the people’s aspirations on the altar of a selfish quest for ephemeral monetary and political benefits. By his sheer commitment to, and sacrifice for, his beloved people of Southern Sudan, Garang made the People’s Movement better and their liberationary struggle stronger, leading it stalwartly until the CPA era. For this, he was the man of the people, by the people and for the people because they loved him and he loved them. They honored him with songs and dances, and by slaughtering bulls. The people rejoiced with him over the triumphs of the SPLM/A, shouldered the losses together, cheered him on during his long but humorous speeches, and celebrated with him the signing of the CPA. By these gestures, he was invigorated and empowered, for those for whom he struggled up to the end were solidly behind him. In him they saw the embodiment of their resolve and their quest for freedom; in his utterances was revealed the sum total of their long bitter suffering and their strong determination to triumph at all cost. He became a Moses of and to the suffering people of Southern Sudan and the marginalized regions of the Sudan. He continued until his last days to strive for a befitting homeland for his people: “a restructured democratic, New Sudan where social justice, freedom and human dignity for all flourish.” Upon his untimely and mysterious death, they poured out their hearts, revealing to the world the great man that he was—his indispensability to their cause and his centrality to their aspirations and struggles for freedom and justice. His life informs South Sudanese about their subjugation, their struggle for liberation, and their ultimate realization of freedom and liberty. His vision sustained the South Sudanese during the dark years of the early 1990s when the movement fragmented into two warring factions, and still gives South Sudanese hope for a better possibility, a brighter tomorrow, in the new Republic of South Sudan. Garang believed that the state policy of Arab-Islamism was a direct assault on Sudan-ness, what he called Sudanism. Sudanism is the idea that the Sudanese people should first and foremost be Sudanese before becoming Christians or Muslims, Africans or Arabs, Southerners or Northerners, and so on. Garang believed that the endeavor of seeking an outside identity to subsume Sudanism conflicted with the sacred values of democracy, justice, freedom, and long lasting peace in the Sudan. The contrived Arab-Islamist identity, strange and foreign as it was and thus largely unacceptable to most Sudanese, had to be imposed and sustained by force, and it was a force that engendered equal opposition from the disadvantaged majority Sudanese who responded in kind to the injustice meted upon them by the ruling clique in Khartoum. It was to right this injustice that Garang dedicated his entire life from the time he burst on the South Sudanese political scene with his 1972 letter to his boss, Joseph Lagu, throughout the war of liberation, and until he died in July 2005 after the signing of the CPA. Garang understood that the Sudan’s richness and diversity in cultures, languages, religion, and politics was more of an asset than a liability, yet it had been victimized and dilapidated by the chauvinistic policy of Arab-Islamism. The solution, in his view, was for Southerners to seek refuge in numbers—the combined forces of the marginalized people of the Sudan. It is difficult to appreciate Garang’s achievement if we do not understand that his dilemma was that he saw both the need for and the danger of seeking refuge in numbers—the New Sudan Vision. On the one hand, he had the conviction that the only effective way to restructure the center of power in Khartoum was through the New Sudan Vision. If only the combined energies of the marginalized people were spent fighting the central government, then these groups could collectively finish off the dragon and then, freely and without coercion, could decide to remain together in one voluntary union by consensus rather than by force. Alternatively, if they so wished and preferred, they could decide to break up the union freely and peacefully, each going her own way to form independent amicable sister nation-states. Although this was evidently a plausible vision, the stark reality was that Southerners had, over the years, cultivated and internalized a culture of secessionism. So strong and entrenched was the pursuit of Southern independence that any alternative view, the New Sudan Vision, for example, was taken as an act of betrayal of the dissenting tradition. Indeed, Garang’s vision proved to be too threatening to both sides. Ardent Southern separatists saw it as at best a dangerous distraction, at worst an outright betrayal of their long pursued dream of independence. On the other hand, Northerners saw it as an existential threat to their discriminatory ideology of Arab-Islamism. Ironically, Garang ended up alarming and offending everyone, the victims and the oppressors alike. War broke out among Southerners—partly over the objective for the war and partly over leadership—and it was not until Garang defeated Southern separatists that he began his war of liberation against Khartoum. The effectiveness and viability of the New Sudan Vision explains the irony of the Anyanya One movement that started out as a secessionist movement, only to end up signing a unionist agreement in contrast to the SPLM/A that commenced as a unionist movement but ended up signing an accord that brought the independence of South Sudan. Truly, as the old saying among the SPLM/A cadres attests, they knew what they were fighting for—kë thärku angicku. Thus, in retrospect, it was only opinions regarding tactics that differentiated Garang from his pioneering predecessors of Southern nationalism, for all had held the same overriding aim—freedom and liberty to their beleaguered region. Garang secured that wider support precisely because he promised the world of freedom and liberty for all Sudanese people, with new government based on mutual consensus rather than by force or coercion, of which all marginalized people dreamt. His vision implied a complete and extensive restructuring of the center of power, just distribution of national resources and equal and fair political representation in the central government. But the very possibility of the success of his vision, the near realization of the tenets of the New Sudan Vision, might have been behind the sudden and mysterious death of Garang in a helicopter crash in 2005. His vision, however, still excites South Sudanese socioeconomic and political imaginations—the tantalizing prospects of political freedom, economic prosperity, and social progress. It still beckons them to manifest the New Sudan Vision in the new Republic of South Sudan—to provide a democratic and pluralistic society where freedom and liberty are guaranteed to all regardless of race, gender, political affiliation, tribe, religion or region. And it imbues them with the conviction that the two Sudans could prosper and shine as a beacon of hope for the rest of the African continent. Garang’s vision was not only that the freedom of the marginalized regions would herald the true freedom and peace for the whole Sudan (Southerners’ freedom will make Northerners’ freedom possible) but also that the vision of the New Sudan could be a template to solving continental issues, wherever marginalization and exploitation of the peripheral regions by a central government is experienced. There is this pervading phrase nowadays in all corners of South Sudan, whenever there is an overwhelming national quandary: “if only John Garang was alive.” Yet, critics of Garang have been quick to interpose that Garang would never have voted for an independent South Sudan. Implied therein is the supposition that Garang was a power hungry man who wanted to rule the whole Sudan at the expense of the aspirations of South Sudanese people. Yet, back in 1992 during his conversation with Steven Wondu in Nairobi, Kenya, Garang told Wondu that he knew about the aspirations of the South Sudanese as much as the Nasir group: “I know as much as they do that the South feels strongly about its quest for independence. There are valid reasons for their wish but the strength of passion is not the same as the practicality of the proposition at this time. We must base our approach on the objective realities facing us.” Garang also knew that if given a chance to vote in a free and fair referendum, South Sudanese would “vote almost 100% for independence.” And knowing this, he told Riek Machar (after Riek had signed the Khartoum peace agreement) that if Khartoum was serious about letting the South go, he (Riek) should let Khartoum withdraw their forces from Juba, Wau, and Malakal and conduct the referendum. Garang’s unambiguous prediction of the January 2011 South Sudan’s referendum outcomes, coupled with his “Rumbek Exhortation” in which he had urged the South Sudanese not to be second class citizens in their own country, hardly leave any room for doubt regarding his intent and political stance had he been alive to vote during the referendum on South Sudan independence. *Dr. John Garang and his Critics* It was Winston Churchill, one of the greatest British statesmen, who once said that if you have no enemies, then you have never stood for anything. Garang stood for the most innovative vision ever proclaimed in an independent Sudan. As such, he attracted fierce opposition from all sides: Southern separatists accused him of being an ardent unionist, while Northern fundamentalists accused him of being a secret separatist. Garang’s first critics were the leaders of the Anyanya Two movement—Akuot Atem Mayen, Samuel Ghai Tut, and William Abdallah Chuol; his second opposition came from the reactionary group led by Kerubino Kuanyin Bol; the third hailed from the Nasir group, when the People’s Movement was on the verge of capturing Juba; and the last was from his closest comrade, Salva Kiir Mayardit. While he was largely hated and feared in equal measure by the Arab North, there were supporters there, too: Mansour Khalid and Yasser Arman, among others, who flocked to the SPLM/A. The masses from the marginalized regions did not contest the alleged authoritarianism of Dr. John Garang and neither did Garang dismiss the charges against him as smear campaigns concocted by his critics, serving at the mercy of Khartoum. When some internal and external voices began to claim that the SPLM/A did not “care to protect the very people whom it was purporting to liberate” Garang responded by accepting that “indeed mistakes had been made in the Movement during the discharge of duties, [but] he believed that the basket containing the mistakes was lighter than the one containing the positive contributions that had been made in the furtherance of the nationalist cause. He then went on and apologized for mistakes done and proceeded to say this: ‘I take full responsibility for all the mistakes committed during all these years of our national liberation, but the people take credit for all that has been good and positive’.” One could even suppose that some of Garang’s shortcomings resulted from his firm belief that “a liberation movement and army could not take decisions by consensus. The buck stopped with him.” Most Southern Sudanese were ready to tolerate these flaws, with the rationalization that “he may have been authoritarian, but he had to be, [because] the survival of the liberation struggle was dependent on not leaving anything to chance.” For sure “some have even argued in retrospect that without Garang’s autocratic leadership the South would have lost the Second Civil War and no peace agreement would have been negotiated.” In fact, the conviction that the movement was too young and fragile to “take risk” was one that was not unique to Garang; other intellectuals within the movement such as Dr. Lam Akol had enthusiastically championed it. For example, in December 1989—in Nairobi, Kenya—Lam, then the SPLM/A’s top negotiator, once bluntly told Khartoum’s delegation, “Yes, we have imprisoned some and killed others and we will kill many more because we are a liberation movement who would not take risks.” Lam had accused Khartoum of human rights violations and they in turn questioned Lam about SPLM/A’s political detainees. Out of this somber understanding, the South Sudanese came to regard Garang as the symbol of their opposition to and protest against the North in spite of his apparent failings. Out of this sincere appreciation came the conviction to give him the benefit of doubt, to follow and believe in him, as reflected in the way most people from the South and the marginalized regions came to view his limitations and mistakes as a small, tolerable price to pay for the greater goal of liberation. *Conclusion* It is my hope that as we celebrate the 71st anniversary of the birth of Dr. John Garang, we may reflect upon the revolutionary struggle for which generations of our people died, and in the process pause to assess our collective conscience in light of our present courses of action in the Republic of South Sudan. The generations of South Sudanese nationalists and leaders that came before and shaped Garang were prompted to revolutionary action by a sense of dignity and self-respect. Garang, emerging from this tradition of dissent, was driven by the accumulated indignities of years gone by and more so by the boundless aspirations of generations yet unborn. With the history of oppression as his driving force and the pursuit of liberty for his people as his destiny, Garang became the spirit of our time, the embodiment of our opposition to Khartoum, and the aspiration for our envisaged future. Garang, the hero of our glorious history, is dead but his name will remain eternally in our minds and hearts and in the pages of his speeches and writings. We the people of the Sudans will never forget him and his comrades. Garang “gave his Southern Sudanese people the dignity they had been denied through a combination of charisma and military prowess on the battlefield.” While we the living celebrate his legacy—as the symbol and embodiment of our collective sufferings, sacrifices, and above all, resilience—we must always remember the debt we owe to Garang and his martyred comrades. Today in the Republic of South Sudan, the wailing of the neglected orphans and the destitution of the forgotten widows is telling of the complacency with which we have plunged the destiny of this great nation into the abyss. That a nation as ours—for which so many rivers of blood have been shed, so many millions of souls offered, so many resources expended, and the futures of so many young men and women of South Sudan forfeited—should be so neglected is the very thought that would make Garang quiver with shame in his grave. And yet, when we consider Comrade Salva Kiir Mayaardit’s loyalty, determination, and sacrifice to the cause of the oppressed people of South Sudan, there was no more befitting, deserving successor to Garang than him. Sadly, the Promised Land is still as elusive and far off today under the “government of the liberators” as it was during the war. One could even argue that it was better during the war of liberation because there was hope for a brighter tomorrow “*bï paanda ben bei miak.”* But nowadays, many feel no hope for tomorrow because tomorrow is mangled up in the wreckage of today’s national idiocy. What shall we tell the pioneering fathers and the martyrs of our liberationary struggle when we finally join them tomorrow? To triumph in a protracted war against a vicious enemy like the fascist Arab-Islamists of Khartoum, only to succumb in peacetime to the fleeting pleasures of “now” is a damning legacy, which patriotic citizens of any nation would avoid like a plague. That somehow the “government of the liberators” is happily wedded to that plague is the appalling tragedy, and shame, of our time. Garang was the right man at the right time, as Steve Wondu succinctly observed: “I felt that Southern Sudan was blessed to have him at its hour of most need and that those Southerners who sought to bring him down were making a grievous mistake.” But in the cruelest irony of fate, Garang who had “single-handedly kept the hopes of the black Africans in the Sudan” and the man who “fought for the freedom and justice of Southern Sudan for over 20 years” was suddenly killed in a mysterious helicopter crash on his way back from Uganda. Today, there is no bigger honor that South Sudanese people can accord Garang than to ensure that the vision of the liberationary struggle that he led and for which he paid the ultimate price is actualized in the new Republic of South Sudan. Anything less will be the ultimate betrayal, not just of Garang, but also of all the pioneering fathers and all the martyrs—men and women without whose blood and flesh this country would have never been freed. The greatest legacy of Garang over and above his comrades—the pioneering fathers of Southern Sudanese liberationary struggle—will always be (as Francis Mading Deng decorously recognizes) the extent to which he “shifted the Southern outlook from that of a minority, struggling for recognition and a degree of autonomy in a marginalized corner of the country, to one of self-assertiveness, pride, and dignity in the struggle for a democratic Sudan.” Although Dr. John Garang de Mabioor, “the most visionary and incisive revolutionary thinker of Africa and undying martyr of South Sudan,” died physically on 30 July 2005, “his vision will continue to inspire many peace loving people around the globe.” Return in Peace (R.I.P) Dr. John Garang. *This is an excerpt from PaanLuel Wël’s book, “Who Killed Dr. John Garang (July 2015),” marking the 10th anniversary of the death of Dr. John Garang. For reference, all quotations are cited in the book.* *PaanLuel Wël, the managing editor of PaanLuel Wel: South Sudanese Bloggers (SSB), graduated with a double major in Economics and Philosophy from The George Washington University, Washington D.C, USA. He is the author of Who Killed Dr. John Garang <http://www.amazon.com/Who-Killed-Dr-John-Garang/dp/1515034666/ref=tmm_pap_swatch_0?_encoding=UTF8&qid=1438205148&sr=1-1>, the editor of the essential speeches and writings of the late SPLM/A leader, Dr. John Garang, published as The Genius of Dr. John Garang, vol. 1-3 <http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=dp_byline_sr_book_1?ie=UTF8&text=PaanLuel+W%C3%ABl&search-alias=books&field-author=PaanLuel+W%C3%ABl&sort=relevancerank>, as well as a co-editor (with Simon Yel Yel) of President Sakva Kiir’s speeches before and after independence: Salva Kiir Mayaardit: The Joshua of South Sudan <http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=dp_byline_sr_book_1?ie=UTF8&text=Salva+Kiir+Mayardit&search-alias=books&field-author=Salva+Kiir+Mayardit&sort=relevancerank>. **You can reach him through his email: [email protected] <http://gmail.com> or Facebook page* -- To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob View this message at https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout --- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "South Sudan Info - The Kob" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To post to this group, send email to [email protected]. Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14opv7dHLAsS8tJBuLRwZnCGgWaXriLVo1mddDTb1CPHX4A%40mail.gmail.com. For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.
