*Which are the most corrupt cities in the world?/ The Guardian 21.06.16*
Jack Shenker

Cities around the world – from Mogadishu to London – are under the
spotlight for corruption, with heightened focus following the Panama Papers
leak. But what does urban corruption look like – and how is it measured?

As a teenager, Michael Cassius McDonald worked the railroad cars. It was
the 1850s, Chicago was rapidly growing into a major national transport hub,
and for young runaways and street urchins the city’s bustling train
carriages offered numerous opportunities for illicit enrichment. McDonald
was a “candy butcher”, offering sweets and trinkets to tired passengers. It
was only when they got home that most of his customers realised the box
they’d bought was near-empty, or its contents fake.

With the money he saved, McDonald managed to establish himself in the
Chicago underworld and eventually rose to become the most powerful gambling
tycoon in town. Alongside wealth and influence came political control: at
the height of his reign in the 1870s and 1880s, “King Mike” determined the
destinies of virtually every elected representative in Chicago, from local
ward committeemen to mayors, senators and governors. “He never held
office,” noted writer Richard Henry Little, “but ruled the city with an
iron hand.”

More than a century later, Chicago’s reputation for urban corruption –
first established by McDonald, then bolstered by a succession of criminals
over subsequent decades, from Al Capone to Rod Blagojevich – remains
intact. Over the last 40 years there have been more than 1,500 public
corruption convictions in Chicago’s judicial district, more than any other
city in the US, and a report published last year by the University of
Illinois concluded that the Windy City is still the “Capital of Corruption”
in America.

But outside of the US, Chicago faces stiff competition. In Colombia, an
estimated 1,380 local mayors have been charged with corruption over an
eight-year period. In Ukraine, one-in-10 of all news reports address
corruption issues in urban development. In Spain, the Gürtel scandal –
involving the alleged bribery of leading politicians by businessmen seeking
construction contracts in Madrid and Valencia – continues to engulf
establishment circles, leading 95% of citizens to believe that corruption
is institutionalised, although no one has yet been found guilty. In Rio de
Janeiro city prosecutors and council members say they are scrutinising
Olympic contracts for possible corruption as the investigation continues
into the multibillion-dollar kickback scheme at Petrobras.

So where does Chicago’s malfeasance rank when set against its global
counterparts, and to what extent are court rulings really a useful measure
of a city’s corruption? The answer, of course, depends on how we choose to
define urban corruption. There is no simple or universal way of doing this,
because the question of what our cities look like when they are corrupted
is really just another way of asking a much harder question: what do we
want them to look like when they are clean?

Cities pre-date nation-states by millennia, and the process of urbanisation
– particularly when it occurs quickly, and in places where natural and
civic resources are limited – has always created opportunities for those
willing and able to bend the rules. “A high-density and expanding
population puts pressure on space, on water, on public services like health
and education, and that causes shortages,” explains Dieter Zinnbauer,
research manager at Transparency International – an international
organisation which aims to combat corruption and is based in Berlin.
“Whenever you have shortages, you have big corruption risks; one has to ask
oneself ‘who are the gatekeepers of these resources, and how are they being
allotted?’ Of course this can exist in the countryside too, but it plays
out in the urban theatre in a more concentrated and drastic way.”

Those risks are increasing. Over the next 30 or so years, the number of
people living in cities is set to grow by an extra 2.5 billion and the vast
majority of that urbanisation will take place in parts of the world where
the prevalence of dishonest practices – corruption of local politics,
policing, resource allocation and delivery of services to citizens –
already appears to be high. Transparency International’s Corruption
Perceptions Index, which ranks nations according to expert perceptions of
public-sector corruption, assigns each country a score between 100 (very
clean) and 0 (very corrupt). India, China and Nigeria all currently score
below 40, indicating a high level of public corruption; between them, these
three states alone are set to absorb almost a billion new city-dwellers by
2050. Over the next decade, in terms of new residential and commercial
space, India will build the equivalent of an entire Chicago every single
year.

And yet despite the soaring relevance of cities to our lives, to date
global anti-corruption efforts have largely been targeted at countries as a
whole, rather than at the urban settlements within them. The recent Panama
Papers exposé drove debates over corruption to the top of the news agenda,
and also revealed the extent to which tax havens have a direct impact on
cities; more than 31,000 companies based in tax havens own property in the
UK, largely concentrated in London, and nearly one in 10 of them are linked
to Mossack Fonseca, the law firm at the centre of the leaks. “The Panama
Papers have once more driven home the point that shell companies associated
with offshore secrecy providers play an outsized role in the real estate
markets of some world cities,” argues Zinnbauer.

But a major anti-corruption summit held by David Cameron in the aftermath
of the leaks largely ignored the urban dimension. “Internationally, there’s
a big focus on macro initiatives and people just hope this will filter down
to the city level, but it doesn’t happen like that,” says Anga Timilsina,
programme manager at the UNDP’s Global Anti-Corruption Initiative. “It’s an
area that needs much more attention.” Part of the problem is that
identifying which cities are most exposed to corruption is a daunting task;
although there has been some piecemeal regional research, at the moment
there is no standalone corruption index for urban areas that spans the
globe.

“Every methodology you could possibly use to measure urban corruption has
its limitations, and is likely to reveal a certain type of corruption that
is pertinent to some corrupt cities but largely unimportant in others,”
adds Timilsina. “How do you compare apples and pears?”

Based on the fragmented data that is available though, a few cities do
stand out. If we assume a direct correlation between national and
city-level corruption, and restrict ourselves to Transparency
International’s metric of asking experts to assess the degree of corruption
among public institutions and employees, then it is largely cities in
war-torn states – where normal governance mechanisms have been suspended
and delivery of education, healthcare and other municipal services highly
disrupted – that fare worst: Mogadishu in Somalia, Kabul in Afghanistan,
and Juba in South Sudan. In Libya and Iraq, which both sit in the bottom 10
of the Corruption Perceptions Index, military conflict is entwined with an
abundance of oil reserves, which generates extra incentives for corrupt
practices in cities like Tripoli and Baghdad.

But there are other ways of thinking about urban corruption, one of which
is how robust legal protections for citizens are, and how common it is for
them to have to bribe officials on a day-to-day basis to get things done.
Here, it is cities in Africa and Asia which tend to stand out. The LSE’s
New Urban Governance Project, a two-year research programme which attempts
to chart different aspects of city management across the world, lists two
Nigerian cities – Lagos and Port Harcourt – as places where the risk of
corruption is a “highly relevant” governance challenge. According to Global
Integrity, a Washington DC-based non-profit organisation which tracks
international corruption trends and has produced an “African Integrity”
map, capital cities like Asmara (Eritrea), Nouakchott (Mauritania) and
Conakry (Guinea) score particularly poorly on indicators like the rule of
law, accountability and civil service integrity.

Indian website ipaidabribe.com, which allows citizens to upload details of
street-level extortion, suggests that Bangalore, Delhi and Hyderabad rank
worst for corruption; Dhaka, capital of neighbouring Bangladesh, is listed
by a number of surveys as one of the places where informal payments for
public utilities or business licences are demanded most frequently.

Another measure of corruption in cities is the extent to which organised
crime or more generalised violence is widespread. Latin American cities
dominate the statistics in this area. Caracas recently overtook San Pedro
Sula in Honduras to top a list of the world’s most dangerous cities ; the
Venezuelan capital also makes an appearance on the LSE’s list of cities
where corruption risks are highest, and Venezuela itself – also a major
oil-producing country – is listed near the bottom 10 of Transparency
International’s Corruption Perceptions Index. Corrupted security agencies
often help fuel urban violence; in Caracas, police officers have been
accused of involvement in eight out of 10 kidnappings.

And yet all these figures ignore what is arguably the most important
element of corruption in cities: where illicit money flows, and how it is
hidden. From embezzlement in Ashgabat to bribery in Bogotá, virtually all
forms of corruption can ultimately be traced back to the hijacking of urban
public policy-making and civic institutions by vested interests, and the
financial bounty reaped by elites has to end up somewhere. That somewhere,
overwhelmingly, is the City of London.

Britain’s private bankers, largely headquartered in the UK capital’s square
mile – an institution which is itself shielded from most forms of
democratic accountability through an archaic web of legal exemptions and
historical conventions (the City is one of the only urban settlements on
earth where businesses help elect the area’s political representatives, and
control votes which vastly outnumber those of local residents) – manage
$1.65 trillion of client assets between them, covering wealth from all over
the planet. That money is protected from meaningful oversight through
extraordinarily generous laws on tax, trusts, secrecy and domicile status,
and a consistently lax enforcement regime. Nicholas Shaxson, author of the
book Treasure Islands, which explores tax havens, argues that “financial
services companies have flocked to London because it lets them do what they
cannot do at home”.

This has led Transparency International itself to label the City of London
the world’s “number-one home for the fruits of corruption”; anti-mafia
journalist Robert Saviano believes the practices of the City have
transformed the UK into the most corrupt nation on earth. It is impossible
to analyse urban corruption in any form without placing London and its
financial industry at the heart of the problem. Via its deregulatory
impulses and unparalleled influence on the global economic system, London’s
financial core has exported the conditions necessary for wide-scale
corruption to countless other cities around the planet, while at the same
time offering a safe haven for corrupt money that makes the job of tackling
urban corruption in all those other cities far more difficult.

As cities continue to expand and proliferate, demand for urban land, and
thus its value, is set to increase sharply. Dieter Zinnbauer, of
Transparency International, believes that we may be moving towards an urban
land “resource curse” – a phrase normally associated with countries laden
with so much mineral wealth that rulers have little need to establish a tax
base and thus prove themselves accountable to citizens, but which Zinnbauer
fears could soon apply to cities too and be responsible for driving further
corruption in the years to come.

In Egypt, for example, the improper sale of desert land on Cairo’s fringes
by government officials has not only lined the pockets of regime cronies
but diverted scant public resources – drinking water, energy pipelines and
transport infrastructure – to areas of the city where few people live. “The
problem isn’t only that rapidly rising land prices allow specific groups to
land windfall profits in the short-term,” Zinnbauer notes, “but also that
in the longer run this locks in certain development patterns which
potentially deprive large parts of the community of economic opportunities,
so it hardwires injustices into the future of the city.”

It’s not all bad news. In many cities, concerted fightbacks against
corruption have met with some success: the transformation of Colombia’s
second city of Medellín from murder hotspot to apparent civic beacon made
headlines around the world, and in Romania the tireless efforts of
anti-corruption head Laura Codruta Kövesi has claimed huge scalps,
including the mayor of Bucharest, Sorin Oprescu, who was arrested and stood
down last year. Among the global anti-corruption community, innovative
forms of urban planning and design which aim to ensure cities are more
responsive to the needs of citizens and make corrupt practices much harder
are becoming more prominent. In New York, activists have used large-scale
public murals and advertising billboards on the metro to inform residents
of their rights in cases of housing eviction or police intimidation, and
recently published research in India suggests that workers who display a
visible symbol indicating their hostility to corruption are less likely to
be asked by colleagues or bosses to engage in malpractice.

But such measures will never be enough in isolation. To really root out
corruption in our cities, we will need to fight for a different kind of
global economic infrastructure, one that does not allow vast quantities of
illicit wealth to be siphoned off from public treasuries and vulnerable
citizens, only to disappear into the shadows. And for that, those of us who
live in London need to turn our attention closer to home.

Guardian Cities is a member of the Habitat III Journalism Project.

-- 
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at 
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14oqkgFXx%2BOUr3FUavBKWnozJnvJr883rTQ4mQiPdEHCHZQ%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to