A South Sudanese who fought and died before July 2011 is a martyr; the one
who is fighting in present internal wars, dies a tribesman: Bishop Yugu
Sep. 01 Politics <http://www.southsudannation.com/category/politics/>,
Uncategorized <http://www.southsudannation.com/category/uncategorized/> 11
comments
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comments>

By Professor Deng Awur Wenyin, SEPT/01/2016, SSN;

It was Sunday August 21st, 2016. The 11 o’clock English service was on in
Juba All Saints’ Cathedral. The preacher was Jackson Moses Pitia, Dean of
the Cathedral. The main readings were Psalms 46: 1-11, Jeremiah 1: 4-10,
Hebrews 12: 18-29 and Luke 13:10-17. The theme of Pitia’s sermon was: “God
is our refuge and strength”. The topical example he gave is the exodus of
South Sudanese to other countries as refugees, because of the civil strife
which started on December 15th, 2013. He said we inside the country and
refugees, our prayers strengthen us.

All the churches in their different denominations and the mosques, have
been preaching for peace, forgiveness and reconciliation. Some of the
preachers even weep in their preaching and prayers. Indeed, our religious
institutions are working for peace.

The most senior priest in the service was Assistant Bishop Frazer Yugu. As
it is the rule in the Church, the duty was on Bishop Yugu to make the
benediction. Normally this authority who closes the service and dismisses
the congregation, would make some comments and commendations on the sermon,
or at least say something in the form of an announcement.

Bishop Yugu commended Dean Pitia for the splendid sermon by asking the
congregation the usual questions: What is this current war for? Who is
fighting who? And why? He made a brief analysis of the wars which were
fought by South Sudanese from 1955 to 2011 and then declared: any South
Sudanese who fought and died in any of those wars, is a martyr.

Then, by way of distinction, he furthermore declared: any South Sudanese
who is fighting and killed in an internal war after 2011, dies a tribesman.

When I tried to work out the rationale of that statement, it means to me
that the qualification for martyrdom is for a South Sudanese who fought and
got killed in a war against foreign invasion. For some of our younger
generation who might not have been exposed to our history of resistance and
struggle, foreign invasions in our land go back as far as 1821. The start
was the Turco – Egyptian invasion led by Mohammed Ali Pasha. At that time
the Sudan was a loose territory without strict borders.

That period (1821 – 1881) lasted for 60 years. It was the then southern
Sudanese who suffered most because slave trade was applied on them. Then
came the Mahdist revolution or the Mahdiya (1881 -1899). Instead of the
revolution being a salvation for all the Sudanese, the Mahdists expanded
the slave trade in the whole of southern Sudan. The Mahdists reigned for 18
years.

Then came the Anglo – Egyptian reconquest of the Sudan (1899 – 1956) in
which the official name of the country became the Anglo – Egyptian Sudan.
That period was 57 years. Then came the period which the northern Sudanese
called independence (1956 – 2011). That period was 55 years.

It was supposed to be genuine independence for all of us but alas, the old
treatment of southerners and outlook of the Turco – Egyptian, Mahdists and
Anglo – Egyptian Sudan periods, did not change. In fact the South Sudanese
had forecasted and therefore the new struggle started in August 1955, just
some four months to independence.

So from 1821 – 2011 there was good cause to continue fighting. With that
historical background of having resisted all sorts of foreign invasions and
mistreatment for 190 years, why are our people killing themselves these
days?

It is unfortunate that historical tribal competitions, ambitions and
rivalries have been brought to town to be used for attaining political
power. Attainment of political power has its own history in the European
civilization.

Great Britain, Germany, France, Belgium and Portugal scrambled for Africa
and established the European model of rule. On independence that model was
inherited, thus in Africa today we have elections, legislatures, cabinets
and judiciaries. The United Nations (UN), which was a result of the
European wars which they call World Wars One and Two, has accepted as the
standard the European model of acquiring power.

Tribes like the Jieeng (Dinka), Nuer, Chollo (Shilluk), Mundari, Murle,
Otuho (Latuka), Boya, Didinga and Toposa, just to mention a few, should not
import their cultural conflicts to the town. For example the Jieeng and
Nuer have a long history of fighting among themselves in the toch (open
plains and swamps) where their cattle graze.

Also cattle rustling is a factor. There they do not fight over any power
but mainly for acquisition and control of pastures and watering places. Let
the reader be informed that the Jieeng (Jaang in Nuer) and the Nuer are
first cousins.

Some individuals would distort that fact but to no success. Observe their
languages, names and initiation system, respectively. For example, the
forehead marks of my Agaar section of the Jieeng are the same ones on the
Nuer foreheads.

Even these tribes know when and where to fight. In December 2013 when the
fighting broke out in Juba, the fighting which was, because of Riek and
Kiir, taken to be a Jieeng–Nuer war, some individuals from my hometown,
Rumbek, tried to mobilise the Agaar youth for war against the Nuer.

But the youth and elders wanted to know where the Nuers were attacking
from. When the answer was Juba, they said no, they can’t be mobilized for
that war because their Nuers attack from Bentiu, not Juba. The essence was
that the fighting in Juba was a government affair, not their customary war.

Regrettably, the Lou Nuer do not see the logic of the Agaar: they have
allowed themselves to be manipulated by Dr Riek Machar, wading all the way
from Leer in Bentiu area on the West Nile, to raise the white army (jech
mabor) to fight the Jaang. It seems to me the Bentiu youth tend to think
like the Agaar. This is because Dr Riek could not raise a White army in
Bentiu area.

I would like to underline a point which I think is important. Though the
Jieeng and Nuer were the majority in the SPLA liberation war, the war which
culminated in the independence, nevertheless South Sudan is not a country
for two tribes alone so as to compete over it. The country belongs to all
the tribes.

Since we have inherited the European mode of governance from the Sudan, we
want a political leader to come to power through the will of the people.

In 1978 the people of the then Southern Region of the Sudan, through their
Regional Assembly, elected Gen. Joseph Lagu president of the High Executive
Council (HEC). Majority of the Jieeng members of the Assembly voted against
their tribesman, Moulana Abel Alier and instead voted for Gen. Lagu.

Lagu’s Ma’adi tribe is a minute one on the Ugandan border but
notwithstanding, he was elected because of his role in the Anya-Nya
Liberation Movement. Gen. Lagu did not organize a fight to be president but
presented himself humbly to the people’s representatives.

In conclusion, a question to you, the reader, and to myself as well, is
Bishop Yugu right or wrong when he makes a distinction between a person who
died in a liberation war, and a person who dies after the liberation wars,
in these trivial wars, as a tribesman?

For my part, before I choose, I would like to ascertain the precise meaning
of martyr. A dictionary meaning of the word is that a martyr is a “person
who … dies for a cause or belief.”

What is the cause or reason to fight to die after the liberation? Riek? Or
who? What is the belief to fight to die for? Folktales about Ngun-Deng?

Therefore, I entirely agree with my bishop that those who died during the
liberation wars, are martyrs but those who are dying in these uncalled for
internal wars, are dying as tribesmen. William Deng Nhial, Aggrey Jadein,
Ezboni Mondiri, Dominic Muorwel Malou, Fr Saterlino Lohure and many others
died in the struggle while poor. Their riches is July 9th 2011.

Of course Bishop Yugu didn’t make that judgment out of the blue. He is a
well-informed bishop about topical issues. He and some of us are aware
that, many individuals, civil societies and even the government, have been
describing this Riek’s war as a senseless war.

Then he logically concludes that someone who fights and dies in these
senseless Riek’s war can’t be a martyr. Such a person would be like an
animal killed not according to Jewish or Islamic rituals. The meat of such
an animal can’t be eaten by a Jew because it is unclean and a Muslim can’t
eat it as well because it is fatis or not pure, because it is not halal. In
Islam halal is something allowed and haram is something prohibited. Any
unclean meat or thing in Judaism and Islam is negis or nasty.

In our Christian faith taking someone’s life is a sin.

The Nation Mirror daily of August 30th, 2016 had the following title for
its editorial: “Can we stop killing ourselves?” My answer: Yes we can. But
how and when?
<< Older
<http://www.southsudannation.com/the-tragedy-that-is-south-sudan-and-warring-elite/>
Newer >>
<http://www.southsudannation.com/the-new-us-policy-and-the-implementation-of-south-sudans-peace-agreement/>
11 Comments

   1. J Gore
   September 2, 2016 at 1:15 am
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comment-1301677>

   Professor Deng Aweer,
   I expected you to be better than your tribesmen who have not gone to
   school but am wrong to think education can change a jaang like yourself. I
   think you should be stripped of the title of professorship and allowed to
   join jce or go to herd cattle in your village if this is how you can
   analyse a simple sermon by a clergy.

   The Bishop did not say in his sermon that it was Dr Riek’s war but you
   are trying to put words onto his mouth which is wrong and unacceptable, and
   you should retract it. Time for fooling South Sudanese is long gone and
   every one, even children in primary school, knows who is responsible for
   the on-going senseless war and the killing of innocent civilians in South
   Sudan.

   So stop lying and make some effort to educate your tribesmen to have
   some humanity in themselves and to stop killing innocent South Sudanese.
   Reply
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/?replytocom=1301677#respond>
   2. abai okwahu
   September 2, 2016 at 7:51 am
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comment-1301690>

   whatever happened to the christian maxim that ‘do not be a judge unto
   others’? perhaps bishop yugu is a devil in a preacher’s garb. folks who
   died challenging the dictatorship in juba will be remembered as patriots,
   let yugu keep his opinion to himself and his flock in juba.
   he (yugu) is afraid to speak the truth like his brethren in the Cathoiic
   church and other denominations who have spoken up and condemned the
   tyrannical regime in juba.
   Reply
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/?replytocom=1301690#respond>
   3. GatNor
   September 3, 2016 at 3:55 am
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comment-1301727>

   In case the professor wants to write a book on the meaning of the word
   “martyr” he can help himself to the followings below ..free of charge

   martyr:
   1). a person who willingly suffers death rather than renounce his or her
   religion.
   2). a person who is put to death or endures great suffering on behalf of
   any belief, principle, or cause: is a martyr to the cause of social justice.

   noun – a person who is killed because of their religious or other
   beliefs.
   “saints, martyrs, and witnesses to the faith”

   verb – kill (someone) because of their beliefs.
   “she was martyred for her faith”

   Perhaps, the professor’s article is a martyr of a fundamentally
   misconceived philosophical meaning of the word itself.
   Reply
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/?replytocom=1301727#respond>
   4. Abel Magok <http://SouthSudanNation.com>
   September 3, 2016 at 5:24 am
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comment-1301734>

   Professor,

   This is one of the few best article I have read on this website,
   neutral, balanced, informative and indeed carrying highly intellectual
   stand-point on this issue of war. People gone wild on this website, look at
   J Gore, he pickups one word in the whole article, Dr. Riek’s war, he
   misunderstood it and become fiery. What people know most on this website is
   tribalism talks and expression of maximum hatred and insults to certain
   group indiscriminately without distinguished the ordinary from those
   leading government and has been encouraged by highly educated people most
   of them are living in the U.K.
   Read an article written by El hag Paul, titled Time for Dr. Riek to
   strategize Aug.11, 2016 and see commentary of the EDITOR of this website,
   he attacked Yien Mathews, saying your negativity has been problematic to
   those who support the Nuer in general in their leadership in the new war of
   liberating the people from JCE.—- and more.
   Reply
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/?replytocom=1301734#respond>
   - info@southsudannation
      September 3, 2016 at 12:38 pm
      
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comment-1301742>

      Abel Magok,
      The irony of the message of the learned professor’s article is
      abundantly clear. Picking up the wisdom of Bishop Yugu, he is mostly
      telling the jieng and especially those serving the interests of
pres. Kiir
      and the JCE that their deaths are shameful and futile because these
      tribesmen are only laying down their lives for the interest of
      parochialism. Of course, to be fair to you, the professor’s message also
      goes out to Riek Machar’s Nuer militias.
      Apparently, the professor is coming around the centrality of the
      message of this website that you so unfairly hates, and that’s
South Sudan
      is the nation for all South Sudanese.
      Editor
      Reply
      
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/?replytocom=1301742#respond>
      5. Eastern
   September 3, 2016 at 3:52 pm
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comment-1301746>

   My friend, the professor Awur Deng didn’t do himself justice in his
   article by referring to the current conflict in South Sudan as “Riek’s war”
   before falling short in drawing the corollary between previous wars of
   “liberation struggle” waged by southern Sudanese starting way back in 1821
   and culminating with the independence of South Sudan on July 9, 2011. The
   professor is playing dirty politics by insinuating that it’s Dr Machar
   wagging a war against Kiir.

   Professor Awur Deng has not been objective on this article. His article
   is cheap politics at best. Professor Deng Awur is perhaps trying hard to
   win back his deanship at the college of law at the university of Juba of
   which Kiir stripped him sometime back. The bushes of South Sudan are now
   teeming with a large number of agrieved citizens baying for Kiir’s blood;
   it’s no longer SPLA-IO or Dr Machar alone fighting Kiir’s dictatorial and
   tribal regime.

   It’s sad that a learned fellow would fail to discern such simple
   philosophical messages.

   Thank you J Gore for your rebuttal.
   Reply
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/?replytocom=1301746#respond>
   6. White Rat. <http://Gmail.com>
   September 4, 2016 at 8:25 am
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comment-1301767>

   Tribal professor. Your are disgrace to your tribes mate How dare could
   you term the war Riek’s War!. Tribes mates are killing our pp at will and
   ruling with impunity. Hell on you.
   Reply
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/?replytocom=1301767#respond>
   7. Southdan
   September 4, 2016 at 10:18 pm
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comment-1301789>

   Hi professor, you are really professor for jeeng elders council not for
   south Sudan. Why do I believe you not for south Sudanese but for dinka.
   because now a day non intellectual Dinkas are better you intellectuals.
   Professor Awur, please thinks carefully before you act. To me, buying
   people loyality buying words is an ignorant. First of all the word maryter
   (ma-ry-ter )that you bought from Honorable Mr. Bishop, means one who died
   for his country in Arabic. ( الشهيد ) of course, if those white army, or
   rebels in general from upper Nile, Bahr Gahzel and equatoria has died since
   2013-2016 I think they could qualified as maryer despite Bishop’s opinion.
   I know many people would blamed and disagree with you but to me any one
   like you has a sickness that could be diagnosed as Riek Machar sickness I
   said this because I heard all Dinkas intellectuals uttering nonsense over
   internet against Dr. Reik Machar. Therefore are mentally sick with Risk
   Machar the only man wanted to bring about reforms. Dear Editor please
   forgive my language consider a whistle blowing.
   Reply
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/?replytocom=1301789#respond>
   - info@southsudannation
      September 4, 2016 at 11:27 pm
      
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comment-1301790>

      Southdan,
      There is absolutely nothing wrong with your criticism or language.
      Editor
      Reply
      
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/?replytocom=1301790#respond>
      8.
   
http://shoebat.com/2016/07/27/muslim-imam-becomes-a-christian-all-his-relatives-and-even-his-own-wife-and-children-disown-him-destroy-his-home-and-business-and-try-to-murder-him-he-says-he-would-do-it-again-for-jesus/
   <http://Google>
   September 5, 2016 at 7:43 am
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comment-1301805>

   It is the war mongers who will associates themselves with Riack Machar.
   Those who know

   the man are now following the peace lover Taban Gai. So for you who are
   enlightened ignore these people. There is no point of killing your own
   people.
   Who are the people killing innocent civillians on roads. Has those
   civillians done anything wrong.
   Reply
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/?replytocom=1301805#respond>
   9. Southdan
   September 5, 2016 at 12:55 pm
   
<http://www.southsudannation.com/a-south-sudanese-who-fought-and-died-before-july-2011-is-a-martyr-the-one-who-is-fighting-in-present-internal-wars-dies-a-tribesman-bishop-yugu/#comment-1301809>

   Thanks Mr. Editor, shame to those who’re buying words and people loyalty
   by a superficial propaganda. We have realized those who do so have a
   disease called (Riek syndrome). To me it was just a personal opinion for
   Reverend Mr. Bishop to say those who had died during 1955-2005 are only
   martyrs and those died from 2013-2016 are not, this also a cheap
   prescription and nobody should agree unless a person with sick mind like
   professor Deng Awuor how had Reik syndrome. We have learned in Arabic
   curriculum that a martyr is one who died or a soldier who died for sake of
   his country. If those rebels who had fought President Kiir government and I
   will not called it (regime ) have been acknowledged as Spla-io forces
   therefore would acknowledge marytrs no matter who say nonsense.

-- 
To post to this group, send email to [email protected]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
[email protected]
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/d/forum/southsudankob
View this message at 
https://groups.google.com/d/msg/southsudankob/topic-id/message-id
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout
--- 
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"South Sudan Info - The Kob" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
to [email protected].
To post to this group, send email to [email protected].
Visit this group at https://groups.google.com/group/SouthSudanKob.
To view this discussion on the web visit 
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/SouthSudanKob/CAJb14opZ0vin5qJfT%2BNL1KddsJG1-NsHH7%2BoBEiTP1-iZ45KsA%40mail.gmail.com.
For more options, visit https://groups.google.com/d/optout.

Reply via email to