Richard: To clarify terminology, what I was trying to describe with the term "essentially performance-engineer" is the methodology for the basis of the design, not to literally promote performance-based design which is a different exercise altogether and having to do with alternative means and methods of compliance with codes and standards. What I proposed in committee and what I am saying still is that the design should be matched to the performance of the equipment carried by the responding fire department.
There are still straight stream nozzles in use by fire departments and there are likely some that use 2" or 2-1/2" inside of buildings. But the VAST majority of fire departments use 1-1/2" or 1-3/4" hose packs, and many pull them from gated wyes as Rich and I both described. (Over the course of the last 3+ year cycle we had 4 days of task groups and took a lot of comments and correspondence from fire service - this is not just my opinion.) How do we guarantee that they keep using the same gear? We can't. So wouldn't it be prudent to promote designs that are conservative enough to work reasonably well across-the-board? It can't be said that 100 PSI is adequate for most or many or maybe even half of the departments out there who are rigged for response to mid-rise and high-rise fires. Would you agree that 75 PSI at the riser base will serve most sprinkler systems? Why don't we just require 75 PSI, go back to pipe schedules and leave it at that? What I proposed was pretty straightforward and did not include flow modification; it was to require that the discharge pressure be adequate to deliver the required pressure at the nozzle tip(s), based on the actual equipment used. A recommendation to designers and fire service has been in the standard for at least 3 or 4 cycles (A.7.8 in 2003 and 2007), that the required nozzle pressure and actual set-up should be considered. I agree with your statement that many cities - small, medium and large - may not know how their equipment performs or what pressures are needed. So we should look the other way? Are you saying that's just a fact of life and it's okay to send firefighters into a building with gear that may not perform at it's optimum level? There is no excuse for ignorance and oversight if the information is, in fact, readily available to us. It is incumbent upon fire brigades to train their personnel in the equipment and tactics they have adopted, and the administration of those departments has a responsibility to maintain continuity within reason. That's one of the benefits of having a wide range of nozzles available - some FD's carry different rated nozzles on their trucks to assure as much as possible that they'll get the best match for the fire and building in which they're working. And we as an industry can accommodate whatever they want. But unlike sprinklers (or just about any other building system), the end-user of a standpipe system is the fire department. They should have some ownership of the design and I stand by my statement that the design development sequence should begin with contacting the responding FD. Steve Leyton Protection Design & Consulting The foregoing is the opinion of the writer alone, and does not necessarily represent the intent of the NFPA 14 Technical Committee, nor constitute a formal or informal interpretation of the standard. -----Original Message----- From: Richard Malek [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, December 06, 2006 6:22 PM To: [email protected] Subject: RE: pump capacity/standpipe Steve, It is good to see you are thinking outside the box some, but I'm somewhat glad your performance-based approach to standpipe design was voted down. The comments that Chris makes regarding FD's have quite a bit of truth to them. You can design for what the SDFD or what any FD wants today, however, as Chris points out, that can change with a new fire chief or fire service changes in strategy/tactics or just pure fads. That building and standpipe however is going to be there for many decades. Over those many decades, how many different performance-based designs are there going to be in just one city? And those are on top of the 100 psi and 65 psi designs and even earlier crtieria. Did your performance-based proposal also allow modifying the flow per outlet as well? Unless an FD is using 2 1/2" or maybe 2", they are not going to flow 250 gpm at a reasonable outlet pressure. If they are going to use 1 1/2 or 1 3/4" hose, the max gpm is probably only in the 175 gpm range. If we are going to force owners to pay for the extra pressure, why make them pay for gpm the FD will not use? There are a number of options out there to make good use of the current 100 psi outlet pressure. Every dept still has the option of 2 1/2" and many use it. For those that don't want to lug the bigger hose, a 2" line is well-sized for standpipe use. 2" line with a smooth-bore could deliver in the 225 gpm range and isn't much more difficult to handle than an 1 3/4". You portray somewhat the best case scenario with FDs that know how they want the standpipe to perform, Unfortunately, many small and mid-size cities, and probably even some bigger ones, aren't in that position and there is a lot to be said for standardization and where over time there is knowledge building on the fire service side and where neighboring (or not so neighboring in the internet world) can learn from each other how to properly utilize a "standard" design standpipe. I think this is an area where industry can assist FDs in understanding the design and how to match equipment to it vs. throwing key design criteria over the fence to the FD and asking "tell us what you want." Interesting discussion. Rich Richard Malek [EMAIL PROTECTED] _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum
