Redirected to dev since this is off-topic for the bug now.
[email protected] wrote:
http://bugs.squid-cache.org/show_bug.cgi?id=2651
--- Comment #17 from Alex Rousskov <[email protected]> ---
(In reply to comment #16)
Alex, please close on commit and mark with the version to be ported back to.
I think we should not close until the fix is ported and committed to the
current release branch (or you decide not to port). Otherwise, it may be too
easy to overlook the need for porting. Also, most users do not care much about
the trunk state. For them, the bug is not fixed until the current release has a
fix.
As long as the bug is quoted in the commit message the changeset
maintenance pages used for porting make it trivial to find and check. I
check every bug fixed before porting to see how relevant it is and to
add the "applied to X" comments.
I look for both the Version of how far back its actually needed and
how close to a feature it is, so how hard I should work on getting it to
port. The Target Milestone gets changed by me after porting to the
version where portage stopped. So its not formal, but Target is usually
for me the version where it's currently fixed if closed, or the version
which needs to be prioritized for a fix to be made working against if open.
As for the closing itself, there are a lot of bugs which get fixed in
incremental parts and it's very hard to follow whether the bug is fully
fixed or partial without being one of the fixers. I've been burned
before with closing other peoples bugs myself after they committed one
of a series of patches. The closing of the bug is my main indicator now
that the fix has actually been finished in the opinion of the dev who
fixed it and is fully in trunk, so to start the porting process.
If the bug is still open it becomes a matter of chance whether I have
time to read the full bug report and understand it before porting. Often
I do, but that is no guarantee.
Where the patch applied to trunk does not easily apply to the lower
versions for users wanting to patch. Then by all means feel free to help
out both the users and myself by attaching a port patch before closing
with a trunk fix.
Amos
--
Please be using
Current Stable Squid 2.7.STABLE9 or 3.1.5
