I spent many hours debugging SSSD in different scenarios last week and I
admit it wasn't always easy -- and I have the source code knowledge I
can use. I imagine it's considerably harder for users and admins..

So this is a brainstorm request on how can we make debugging with SSSD
easier. Maybe there are some low-hanging fruits that can be fixed
easily. Off the top of my head:

- it should be easier to see start and end of a request in the back end.
  Instead of:
    [be_get_account_info] (0x0200): Got request for [0x1001][1][name=admin]
    [acctinfo_callback] (0x0100): Request processed. Returned 0,0,Success 
  We could make the debug messages more explicit:
    [be_get_account_info] (0x0200): Received request for 
    [acctinfo_callback] (0x0200): Finished request for 
[object=user][key=name][value=admin]. Returned 0,0,Success

  Then we could document the messages in our troubleshooting document.
  Please note I'm not proposing to turn debug messages into any kind of
  API and keep them the same forever, but decorate the usual flow with
  messages that make sense without source level knowledge.

- same for authentication

- same for responder cache requests. We seem to have gotten better with
  the new cache_req code there, so this is mostly about using the new
  code in all responders. But also the commands we receive from sockets
  should be printed in human-readable form.

- Running sssd in environment where all actions complete successfully
  should emit no debug messages. Default log level should be moved to
  SSSDBG_OP_FAILURE or CRIT_FAILURE. (This basically amounts to checking
  all OP, FATAL and CRIT failure messages..)

  The reason is that sometimes sssd fails, but because logging is
  totally silent, we don't know what happened at all. Currently we have
  a couple of small bugs where we might print a loud DEBUG message just
  because we search for an entry which is not there etc.

- anything that causes SSSD to fail to start should also emit a syslog
  message. Admins don't really know about sssd debug logs.

- our man pages are not structured well, especially the LDAP man page is
  too big and contains too many options.

One reason I'm bringing this up now is that we'll have a new SSSD developer
starting soon and these might be nice tasks to start with AND they're
also needed.
sssd-devel mailing list

Reply via email to