Hi Fabian, Sorry for taking so long to get back to this.
I filed the following bug in the Apache Jira for this issue: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/STANBOL-588 Cheers, Peter On 27 March 2012 15:41, Fabian Christ <[email protected]> wrote: > Hi Peter, > > thanks for figuring this out. You are absolutely right IMO. Commons > should not have any dependencies and we should fix that. Could you > open a JIRA issue for that? We have to do some SVN cleanup anyway in > Stanbol and this should be one part of that. > > Best, > - Fabian > > Am 27. März 2012 03:18 schrieb Peter Ansell <[email protected]>: >> Hi all, >> >> I am trying to compile the ontologymanager submodule of the stanbol >> source from trunk and there are some issues with circular dependencies >> between modules. Trying to compile ontologymanager shows that there >> are commons modules that are missing, which is to be expected. >> However, trying to compile commons, without compiling any other >> modules or using the complete reactor, shows that commons is not >> self-contained. It relies on enhancer-servicesapi among others. >> >> [ERROR] Failed to execute goal on project >> org.apache.stanbol.commons.web.base: Could not resolve dependencies >> for project >> org.apache.stanbol:org.apache.stanbol.commons.web.base:bundle:0.9.0-incubating-SNAPSHOT: >> Could not find artifact >> org.apache.stanbol:org.apache.stanbol.enhancer.servicesapi:jar:0.9.0-incubating-SNAPSHOT >> in apache.snapshots (http://repository.apache.org/snapshots) -> [Help >> 1] >> >> However, trying to compile enhancer requires commons to be compiled >> previously to have access to commons-indexedgraph, which didn't seem >> to have been compiled before commons-webbase which failed. >> >> [ERROR] Failed to execute goal on project >> org.apache.stanbol.enhancer.servicesapi: Could not resolve >> dependencies for project >> org.apache.stanbol:org.apache.stanbol.enhancer.servicesapi:bundle:0.9.0-incubating-SNAPSHOT: >> Failure to find >> org.apache.stanbol:org.apache.stanbol.commons.indexedgraph:jar:0.9.0-incubating-SNAPSHOT >> in http://repository.apache.org/snapshots was cached in the local >> repository, resolution will not be reattempted until the update >> interval of apache.snapshots has elapsed or updates are forced -> >> [Help 1] >> >> Is it possible to rearrange the packages throughout stanbol so that >> commons does not have any dependencies on any non-commons modules so >> that commons can be compiled from scratch? >> >> The module order in the parent pom makes it naively look like commons >> could be self-sufficient: >> >> <modules> >> <module>parent</module> >> <module>commons</module> >> <module>data</module> >> <module>frameworkfragment</module> >> >> <module>enhancer/parent</module> >> <module>enhancer/generic/servicesapi</module> >> <module>enhancer/generic/chainmanager</module> >> <module>enhancer/generic/enginemanager</module> >> <module>enhancer/jobmanager</module> >> <module>enhancer/chain/allactive</module> >> <module>enhancer/chain/graph</module> >> <module>enhancer/chain/weighted</module> >> <module>enhancer/chain/list</module> >> <module>enhancer/jersey</module> >> <module>enhancer/ldpath</module> >> <module>enhancer/benchmark</module> >> <module>enhancer/defaults</module> >> <module>enhancer/bundlelist</module> >> >> <module>cmsadapter</module> >> <module>contenthub</module> >> <module>entityhub</module> >> <module>factstore</module> >> >> <module>ontologymanager</module> >> <module>rules</module> >> <module>reasoners</module> >> </modules> >> >> However, the reactor build order that is automatically generated by >> maven shows that this isn't the only case where commons has >> dependencies on other packages, as the commons reactor doesn't appear >> in the list until after the enhancer parent pom, data parent pom, >> entityhub parent pom, and contenthub parent pom which seems to >> indicate that modules in each of those meta-modules are dependencies >> of the commons meta-module. >> >> [INFO] Reactor Build Order: >> [INFO] >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Parent POM >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol JSON-LD API >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Jobs API >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Indexed Clerezza inMemory graph implementation >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Parent POM >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Services API >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Web Base >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Jobs Web >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Jobs Reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data File Provider >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data parent POM >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: OpenNLP Models for English >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons: Open NLP and Models >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Web Home Page >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub parent POM >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Services API >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Contenthub parent POM >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Contenthub API Bundle >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Web SPARQL >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Jar Executor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Jar Http Testing Library >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Testing Utilities >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Offline Utilities >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data File Provider for Bundles >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Bundle Provider >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Solr Core >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Solr Web >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Solr Managed >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Solr Installer >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Solr Defauts >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol OWL libraries >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Clerezza LDPath Repository >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Http Query Headers >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Default Configuration >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: DBpedia.org >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: OpenNLP NER Models for English >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: Default ontology registries >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: Default Data Bundle List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: Remote DBpedia.org with local cache >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: OpenNLP Models for Danish >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: OpenNLP Models for German >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: OpenNLP Models for Dutch >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: OpenNLP Models for Portuguese >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: OpenNLP Models for Swedish >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: OpenNLP NER Models for Spanish >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: OpenNLP NER Models for Dutch >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data: Bundle List for OpenNLP >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Data reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Default Framework Fragment Bundle >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Chain Manager >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Engine Manager >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Weighted Job Manager >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Event Jobmanager >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer JobManager Reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Chain: DefaultChain >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Chain: GraphChain >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Chain: Weighted >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Chain: List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Jersey JAX-RS API and front-end >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer ldpath >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Benchmark >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer default configuration >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Bundle List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol CMS Adapter parent POM >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol CMS adapter API bundle >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol CMS Adapter Core Bundle >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol CMS Adapter JCR Bundle >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol CMS Adapter CMIS Bundle >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol CMS Adapter Web Bundle >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol CMS Adapter Bundle List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol CMS Adapter Reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Contenthub Solr Store >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Contenthub Clerezza Store Implementation >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Contenthub InMemory Store Implementation >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Contenthub Store Reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Search Solr Searcher >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub - Test Framework >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Core >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Model implementation based on RDF >> (using Clerezza) >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Search Related Keyword Searcher >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Featured Search >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Search Reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Content Hub JAX-RS API >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Contenthub Bundle List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Yard implementation hased on Solr >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub LDPath implementation >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Contenthub Clerezza LDPath Backend Implementation >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Contenthub Reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Query implementation hased on SPARQL >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Linked Data Protocol Implementation >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Yard implementation hased on Clerezza >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub HTTP Endpoint >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Indexingparent POM >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Indexing Core >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub IndexingSource for RDF using Jena TDB >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub IndexingSource for vCard >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Indexing SolrYard destination >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Indexing - generic configuration for >> RDF indexing >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Indexing for geonames.org >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Indexing for DBpedia.org >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Indexing for dblp >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Indexing reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub default configuration >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub Bundle List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Entityhub reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol FactStore >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol FactStore Bundle List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol FactStore Reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Ontology Network Manager >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Ontology Registry Manager >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol OntoNet Web Home >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Ontology Manager Bundle List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Ontology Manager reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Rules Services API >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Rules Manager >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Rules Refactorer >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Rules Web Home >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Rules Bundle List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Rules reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Reasoners Services API >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Reasoners Service Manager >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Reasoners OWL API >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Reasoners Jena >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Reasoners Test Framework >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Reasoners Web >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Reasoners Bundle List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Reasoners Reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Web Content Editable Enhancer UI >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Enhancement Engine : Semantic NER >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Enhancement Engine : Language Identifier >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Enhancement Engine : Topic Classification >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Enhancement Engine : Metaxa Metadata >> and Text Extractor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Enhancement Engine : Apache Tika >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Enhancement Engine : geonames.org GIS service >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Enhancement Engine : for Entityhub >> ReferencedSites >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Enhancement Engine and utilities for >> extracting keywords form parsed text. >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Enhancement Engine : Refactoring service >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Enhancement Engine : OpenCalais >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Enhancement Engine : Zemanta Tagging >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Enhancer Engines Reactor >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol OSGi Framework Bundle List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Commons Bundle List >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Launcher - Stable >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Launcher - Stateless >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Launcher - Full >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Launcher - Full WAR >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Integration Tests >> [INFO] Apache Stanbol Reactor >> >> Of course, this will not stop a normal reactor as maven reorganises >> all of the modules to fit even if the pom.xml module order is not >> consistent with reality. It would be nice to be able to do quick >> compiles of stanbol without having to pick and choose manually the >> bits that are required by each package. In my case I would like to >> experiment with the raw ontologymanager part independent of all of the >> value added (slow to compile) parts like the enhancer, rules, and >> entityhub. >> >> Cheers, >> >> Peter > > > > -- > Fabian > http://twitter.com/fctwitt
