The XEP could also specify that if a client sets the value of the 'node' attribute to "$" then it MUST NOT include an 'ext' attribute.
Not sure about this, it really depends on how ext is actually used in the wild, as Joe said. I'd be tempted to leave this somewhat open, at least for now. It could be that we could grow a set of extensions of commonly co-implemented features, bearing no actual relation to client plugins, and cut down traffic that way. But such things require quite a bit of research.

Ext is used in the wild. My initial reaction is that it is still needed, but on further thought, I can't see why.

If you remove ext, you create MORE separate things to cache, and thus recreate more network traffic. Because now, client Foo with plugin Bar installed will have an entirely different hash than client Foo without Bar installed. With ext, client Foo has the same capabilities hash in both cases, but one has an additional ext hash for plugin Bar's capabilities.

--
Rachel Blackman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Trillian Messenger - http://www.trillianastra.com/


Reply via email to