On 10/11/07, Romain Vincens <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Hi, Hi! > In case of full-anonymous or semi-anonymous rooms, I can't find a > clear explanation whether the presences are broadcasted or not: > > When entering a full-anonymous room: should presence be broadcasted > to all occupants BUT without the full JID in the item element? or the > presence is just not broadcasted, except maybe for the arriving > occupant himself?
Yes, of course the presence is always broadcasted to every members, and the full JID is not present in the packet, otherwise how could an occupant of the chat know who are in the room ? > When entering a semi-anonymous room: should presence be broadcasted > to all occupants BUT without the full JID, except for moderators? or > the presence is not broadcasted to participant but for moderators and > maybe the arriving occupant? The presence is broadcasted to everyone and only the admins get the full jid > > When reading the XEP I think the presence is always broadcasted to > all occupants, the type of room determines whether there's a jid > attribute in the item element or not. Am I wrong? If not I think it > should be a bit more clearly mentioned. Section 7.1.3 "The service MUST also send presence from the new occupant's room JID to the full JIDs of all the occupants (including the new occupant)", it seems clear enough for me. -- Grégoire Menuel Jabber : [EMAIL PROTECTED] Clé GPG : 1024D/D3BF3B20
