The existing resource generation process from RFC 3920 seems to work just fine. If clients want to generate randomized resources, they can do so, or they can ask the server to do so. There's no reason for servers to be "smart" about this by overriding client-generated resources. I've been uncomfortable with this section of rfc3920bis for a while now, and the philosophy of "if it ain't broke don't fix it" seems to apply here. Therefore I plan to very soon revert this section of rfc3920bis to something as close as possible to Section 7 of RFC 3920.
Extra side benefit: we can kill off this interminable thread with the subject line "RCF3920bis07: Resource generation"!!! Peter -- Peter Saint-Andre https://stpeter.im/
