I'm inclined to agree; I think a good first step would be documenting how we do OTR currently in XMPP. My understanding from Emil Ivov was that there were a couple of edge cases that need consideration.
On Thu, Jan 9, 2014 at 4:55 AM, Peter Saint-Andre <[email protected]>wrote: > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- > Hash: SHA1 > > On 01/08/2014 12:56 AM, Fedor Brunner wrote: > > Hi, is there a XMPP client/library implementing [draft-miller] ? > > Not that I know of. Matt Miller implemented it in some private code of > his, but nothing public as far as I know. > > > When comparing [draft-miller] with XTLS, I think XTLS is simpler > > and could be implemented using existing TLS libraries. TLS doesn't > > support encryption of offline messages, but for offline messages > > OpenPGP XEP-0027 could be used. > > That seems kind of complicated (needing two different encryption methods). > > Fedor, what problem are you trying to solve? Why wouldn't a well-known > technology like OTR work for you? > > To me, the only things that OTR doesn't currently solve are: > > 1. Multiple devices > 2. Encryption of complete stanzas > > IMHO we might be able to solve those through working with the OTR team > instead of designing something new... > > Peter > > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- > Version: GnuPG v1.4.12 (GNU/Linux) > Comment: GPGTools - http://gpgtools.org > Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/ > > iQIcBAEBAgAGBQJSzivTAAoJEOoGpJErxa2pGZsP/25M06vOXSpKUyabbFjNGqgb > 7iM97E6k3Ax8l7hrofbe3pzFyHy0XuxIuhqGS6Q3UdiUORDjqogLsVkvdLnSlXnG > yHuz3Adv9WGnpQzfEBjsptPz9S/3frZRKEwB0G1JG3Glu6VRbX+/Frz9Bwjr0l2c > nP0zLDLFhaQCdHTIxw6ShWOJG9URjipBzW0v1vCu0psbkOsrC+17avaUe4Dn4J3I > Wb4oFC0FG0H4et+BcvnmHzrUh6Omid1fN6cGnH0kzwlrGJsLpn5JNXev2tG6TH7N > 6LFttcZJ2hT3rooCnS1dSmBHyvBhbfG/IZ7kH5pj5sQhl4nkmR73ASRCT/ntZ479 > Sm8rpZvTySGbBLekuwL7Ph23AyNiJVNOJyNKt8IldM1Vkv/YxeBzh2F74EkmVPmj > QA2kh+8ndiF4F7/Og00sLTAcjJCHCFCyAdfCRacMmsGNjuQPh5DwVV19ZKA/E6Vo > 3NOcFbD/7sYhtSv4BmLacn5NPxob+rmAwi7QK9NUPnMUv3m/rPm+W16NXA0He+VV > sR874Tp4QBgvZVZKwtTL1WTjegwDNZRyw2eGa119iASNmoaJkzGeR+mebOd4wJIM > N+ZwwmUB2ITp3PUlHwEb/mH3EjXFj0ALi2pTZfoO8xHRt1DzGETTUDDUp+mfc0PI > 2CylIwsJr9Ka2V2VlZxu > =MFxz > -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- >
