-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA512 Some comments, I don’t have a strong opinion one way or the other.
On Dienstag, 7. Februar 2017 17:25:40 CET Georg Lukas wrote: > - it would be great to have a stable link/identifier to spread to > developers and reference in documentation Being able to link to a specific version (release year) would still be necessary, so the XEP-with-fixed-number-approach seems fitting. > Cons: > > - developers couldn't just stamp "implements XEP-0375" on their release > to indicate a given level of compliance, they would rather need > to write "Implements Compliance Suite 2017" IMO, That’s a feature. "Nobody" knows what XEP-0375 is. "Implements Compliance Suite 2017" is much clearer. > - having this as a non-XEP might increase the maintenance burden or > reduce the "credibility" of the document This doesn’t seem to apply if it is kept as a XEP which is continuously updated. This XEP could use version numbers based on dates, so that it is easy to reference the specific version of the Compliance Suite which was implemented. Either in the form of year.patchlevel or year.month.patchlevel, if we want to futere-proof it against a more frequent release cycle in the future. regards, jwi -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- iQIzBAEBCgAdFiEEG/EPV+Xzd5wEoQQIwGIDJZdiWIoFAliaKTAACgkQwGIDJZdi WIrsgw//Va2zRtHG4I0uFdBNddGDs4GzwlM49AGrYGmnyZ6tIYWzBeY2b+IZf/Tx v0L2iJHTtwUWzGWWhUxvXzvGb0xZL8vOUp8AVNyGVFAzfDRmQdpgCuehj+X5AfyJ 25XzluVpyE7ynSjwR/xs0EH7Cf8P1Jr8MqL8zuQ7Nhe2W8dcC2N8DShEhO1WvCA+ oBAyOukQi0Qc3wYycd8J4Lq03+Edw6NmNhFYTjy82WJoykDgtzhur0wdTuBfbIdJ utXyPQjdMVSaxt+o0EOv5n/Qa4vanIfIXyTr1jd98feVr6LjwNJRrvi1T6ZeY+yR WLzTsXcPk6WYwfoR47mv5ovwYursUGcKZC6btXEUHb+gIXv74MqMlgRm/WARRUoj GGNJL20KuZeCGpw54CIGzObvXxiwHamlc104/H6y6EIFE2C9ASfr1SvQQatridAv /v/Vt/UIV1jy7iHu5QJKJ8u0L3r5SUQcXWerxloXf2R0lXLuRCeQM0v/gQnG6M4Z WsQ4QHu3+FiQUT9SdOev2yn+Y8wf2TvGcLUkRpPnUqqjWxmgqK3XXqV3k8gIWvRV vdSvgCoroNRoK0eEcuP6i3UoB3AT+uxWgGK44jtYKhwSxbCnxcxJ/tGvFXyWJo1e uoqBoZDUDiZcq1fzbpIT5zHJ787SXLwD0z5K/RkNdUIk/K9sRHQ= =WjeN -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- _______________________________________________ Standards mailing list Info: https://mail.jabber.org/mailman/listinfo/standards Unsubscribe: [email protected] _______________________________________________
