On 03.06.2018 11:48, Florian Schmaus wrote: > On 03.06.2018 01:33, Steve Kille wrote: >> >> Sam's message made me realize that none of the variant 1/2/3/4 stuff is >> needed for MIX-CORE. There are some things that might be needed in >> MIX-ANON, but let's worry about these in the MIX-ANON spec and keep them out >> of MIX-CORE. >> >> In MIX-CORE, messages/presence go to a channel or are distributed by a >> channel. There is no participant to participant (PM style) communications. >> >> I suggest. >> >> 1. Messages come from the channel (channel@domain). This is what is >> happening as the channel is distributing messages. Inside each message you >> have a mandatory sender information: (Nick and Bare JID). There would be >> an elegance to putting this information into the JID, but I do not think it >> is practical and it does not gain you anything. >> >> 2. Presence come from the channel (channel@domain). This reflects that >> the channel is distributing presence. Inside each presence stanza you have >> a mandatory sender information: (Nick and Full JID). >> >> >> That is it. Very simple. No variant JID addressing. There are some >> issues for MIX-ANON, but lets worry about these in MIX-ANON, and not make >> the core more complex than it needs to be. > > That very much looks like that I would currently favour, besides that I > don't see a reason why we shouldn't also use the stable participant > identifier as the resourcepart of the originating address.
Uh, and I slightly favour presence also from channel@mix.service/stable-participant-id/unique-client-id as otherwise you will get presence from different devices from the same address. But presence from users with multiple devices is not trivial anyway, not only in the context of MIX, so no matter what we do, someone has to handle it. I still prefer keeping the invariant that presence comes from a unique address per user session, because I think it has the potential to make things easier. - Florian
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
_______________________________________________ Standards mailing list Info: https://mail.jabber.org/mailman/listinfo/standards Unsubscribe: standards-unsubscr...@xmpp.org _______________________________________________
