https://logs.xmpp.org/council/2021-03-10?p=h#2021-03-10-46a8e412b5f68829
1) Roll Call Present: Daniel, Zash, Dave, Jonas, Georg 2) Agenda Bashing None. 3) Editor's Update * New ProtoXEP: Content Rating Labels Sam would like for XEP-0280 (Message Carbons) to be considered for advancement again soon - Jonas suggests poking the authors to ask the Editor, as with MAM. 4a) PR #1044 (xep-0294: add mapping for a=extmap-allow-mixed) - https://github.com/xsf/xeps/pull/1044 Daniel asks whether there are best practices for adding new elements in the same namespace, as there was a similar case for rtcmux recently - Jonas thinks the general consensus is "don't"; Dave says that if it's an optional element then it's technically breaking XML namespacing rules, but thinks it should be fine pragmatically. Zash ponders whether this ought to have been discussed on the list first - Dave was going to raise this too; Jonas had conveniently forgotten that rule, and this PR wasn't even originally on the agenda. Daniel thinks the PR is probably fine and doesn't see it breaking anything in practice, though the proper solution should be to put this in a new namespace - Dave thinks that's more pedantic than proper (namespace bumps are to prevent interoperation failures, which this presumably shouldn't cause - it should be safe to omit this element, and to ignore it.) Zash thinks the general principle of ignoring unknown elements should make this fine without a namespace bump. Zash is irked by the (less visible) discussion on GitHub, rather than on the list. Jonas thinks raising it on-list would be good, especially as it relates to Jingle. Dave is also irked and would prefer it were run past people on-list first. Daniel: +1 Zash: +1 (PR comments are reassuring, and Trust In Fippo®) Dave: [on-list] Jonas: [on-list] Georg: [on-list] 4b) Proposed XMPP Extension: Content Rating Labels - https://xmpp.org/extensions/inbox/content-ratings.html Daniel: +1 Jonas: +1 (author) Georg: [on-list] Zash: +1 (noticed some issues, but sure the author will fix them in Experimental) Dave: +1 (seems worth working on) Zash is particularly impressed by the extensive plain-text compatibility conversion algorithm (§4.1) - Dave thought it seemed overly simplistic and even misses some key cases. 5) Pending Votes None. 6) Date of Next 2021-03-17 1600 UTC Georg will be in a video conference, which may require several seconds of his attention. [Note: North America participates in its bi-annual clock-fiddling on the 14th, so the meeting time will appear to be one hour later for those affected, until Europeans play the same game on the 28th.] 7) AOB None. 8) Close Thanks Jonas, Tedd, all.
_______________________________________________ Standards mailing list Info: https://mail.jabber.org/mailman/listinfo/standards Unsubscribe: [email protected] _______________________________________________
