MORE REVIEWS
For links to all the reviews, go to
http://www.theflagship.net/films/stx/rev/index.html
Each quote accompanied by my appraisal of the review, either positive
(+), negative (-), or neutral (��). So far, the stats, as I
determine
them to be, are as follows:
Positive: 34
Negative: 25
Neutral: 11
Some of the neutral could go either way, depending on your
interpretation--I just wanted to have the leeway. New quotes:
+ (Almost) every bit as great as II and VI.
--David Cornelius, Amazing Colossal Website
- The latest and supposedly last trek for the next generation
appear[s] half empty instead of half full.
--James Hill, BET
- Everyone is still off-track after the ideologically unsound,
sparsely entertaining "Insurrection."
--Wesley Morris, Boston Globe
+ The action that fills the rest of the movie is flat out
killer.
--Cranky Critic
- Ranks as one of the weaker "Trek" movies.
--Mark Harden, Denver Post
- Pap of the first water invested in undergraduate doubling
subtexts and ridiculous stabs at existentialism.
--Walter Chaw, Film Freak Central
�� More than competent, but it doesn't really go anywhere new
or exciting.
--Louis B. Hobson, Jam! Showbiz
- The best "Star Trek" episodes are those that dabbled in big
ideas. . . . The movies, on the other hand, are practically
idea-free.
--Robert W. Butler, Kansas City Star
+ A rip-roaring space opera.
--Bob Bloom, Lafayette Journal and Courier
�� Oddly unengaging.
--Jeffrey M. Anderson, San Francisco Examiner
- Relieved to a degree only by some striking visual effects and
by Patrick Stewart's outstanding presence.
--Mick LaSalle, San Francisco Chronicle
- It's a phaser set to stun.
--Stephen Hunter, Washinton Post
benoit
> Tres fort pour denicher tout ces commentaires !
>
> b> Positif : 31
> b> Negatif : 20
> b> Neutre : 9
>
> b> http://www.theflagship.net/films/stx/rev/index.html
>
> b> benoit
peso j' y suis pour rien , juste abonner a la ML , c' est le webmestre qui
c'est amuse
MORE REVIEWS
For links to all the reviews, go to
http://www.theflagship.net/films/stx/rev/index.html
Hi, guys. The pleasant people over at Yahoo! have decided to mess
around with their Web Console services, so I'm unable to upload any
pages until this afternoon, when I regain access to my FTP program.
However, I've been keeping an eye on the reviews, and have included
quotes from fifty-four of them, with more to come. Each is
accompanied by my appraisal of the review, either positive (+),
negative (-), or neutral (��). So far, the stats, as I determine them
to be, are as follows:
StarTrek-fr, la mailing list francophone - inscription, d�sinscription,
informations dans notre rubrique mailing-list :
http://www.unification-online.org/unifv3/articles/1/11
StarTrek-fr, la mailing list francophone - inscription, d�sinscription,
informations dans notre rubrique mailing-list :
http://www.unification-online.org/unifv3/articles/1/11
