There seems to be much discussion and some advice (some good and some bad)
about pneumatics. Here are my experiences but first my background.
I have been carving various different kind of stones for 37 years (I am 43
years old). I started with hand tools on limestone and then marble.

Eventually I purchased a Cuturi air hammer ( I believe that I brought the
first air hammer into Ireland 30 years ago) to carve granite. I traveled
around Europe and Asia and America for 10-12 years so I feel I was exposed
to many different kinds of stone working from Portland stone in England to
jade in Thailand. I now live in Central Vermont near Barre, VT where I now
carve mostly granite, some marble and a little limestone.

I feel the the answer to whether one should use pneumatics or not is:...It
depends on what you are doing.

Stonemasons and stonecutters don't have much of a need for air tools; hand
tools do most of the trimming these days. It wasn't always this way. But
there isn't much dressing of stone by hand anymore; the big stone saws and
hydraulic splitters do most of this work now.

While Walter Arnold does some gorgeous work on limestone with an air hammer,
I've known some carvers in Ireland who do work with hand tools and do a very
good job and just about as quickly. Besides speed is not always the desired
method of producing a good job. Sometimes one should slow down. So, it
depends on what you are doing.

Air hammers were invented by Trow and Holden Co. in Barre, VT for carving
granite over 100 years ago. Since then Cuturi came up with the same design
in what may be called "curious" circumstances. I use 3 different T and H air
hammers for the work I do which is mostly granite figurative work. But then
again, I have known some abstract granite sculptors who do not use any
pneumatics (they do use electric tools).

It is probably true that if one is going to make a living CARVING (not
cutting) stone, then some use of power tools are necessary.
I haven't found it necessary to change the pressure on the compressor when I
am using a Trow and Holden air hammer, the butterfly valve is enough. But I
use a 1/2" shortstroke hammer for detail work which doesn't hit very hard
anyway. And though hanging up you air hose is good idea, it doesn't work for
carving granite. We have to use suction to remove the toxic dust and this
hangs on a arm above my head.

To Jock Hildebrand, who is looking for some basic granite carving tools; I
feel that a 1" Dallet air hammer with a 1/2" ninepoint and a 1/2" fourpoint
would be a start. And probably a angle grinder with a 5" diamond blade would
also be beneficial. And A BIG DRILL; as big as you can afford (3/4" drill
bit minimum).

Lastly, this mailing list seems to be useful for beginners to get ideas from
people who have been doing this stone carving for a while. Here is some of
my advice for what it's worth.

If you want to determine what is good advice and what is not, look for
people who relate only their experience (such as Walter Arnold and the
fellow from BC, Canada) and do not belittle anyone else's experience. People
such as these have been doing this a long time and are secure in their
abilities. Also the longer one does this work, the more one realizes how
much one has to learn. And besides I have learned many techniques from so
called "novices" who might do things a little different than myself.
Watch out for people who tell you how much they know and how much you don't
know. People such as these are probably beginners who have a little
knowledge. The aphorism applies: "A little knowledge is dangerous".

Thanks be to God that they are as many different ways of working stone as
there are different stones and there are different people who can produce
it. If you can create a thing of beauty and you can make living at it so you
can create another piece tomorrow then you must be doing something right.

Seamus O'Mahoney







....................................................................
Learning Stone is hosted free by Spunge.org (http://www.spunge.org).
For list info + help, including subscribe/unsubscribe options,
email message "intro stone" to [EMAIL PROTECTED]


Reply via email to