Reposted after notification of failure to deliver.
Dear AD I presume you have heard about a fad (craze? activity?) in Europe of walking through damaged forests and adding powdered rock with several claims made about how that assisted the forest to regain health. Do you think this is rooted in the silica availability? Or is the claim spurious? It is reported from the UK as well but I have not read details. If the crop/forest in question would benefit from added, freshly broken rock, does it not make sense that adding rice hull biochar (which is more than 1/2 silica) would have equal effect? The electrical properties mentioned by Tom certainly grabbed by attention. Charged clay particles (which just means they are smaller than 2 microns) in an electrically conductive environment with lots of finely structured silica (basically a sponge) might release the needed minerals more efficiently than otherwise might be the case. Combined with Ron's report that there are a wide variety of chars with very different properties if will not surprise me to find that your poor results trying biochar amendment and the success in other places can all be fit into a single paradigm. You need the right kind to char to get any benefit where you are. Thanks Crispin +++++++ Dear Crispin, the so called insoluble minerals in the soil actually do dissolve in water, albeit in extremely small quantities. They cannot be detected in tests using only chemistry based on their detection in a test tube by using specific reagents. All minerals absorbed by plants growing in nature come from this soil solution. Powdering rocks helps the process of dissolving the minerals in water, and that is why addition of rock powder to a field often gives higher yield than a field to which such dust is not added. Even silica has to be dissolved in water, before plants can take it up. Silica and silicates constitute almost 30% of the earth's crust, and therefore it is the most abundently available mineral in the soil. Therefore I don't think that adding more silica to the field would give you higher yield.
_______________________________________________ Stoves mailing list to Send a Message to the list, use the email address [email protected] to UNSUBSCRIBE or Change your List Settings use the web page http://lists.bioenergylists.org/mailman/listinfo/stoves_lists.bioenergylists.org for more Biomass Cooking Stoves, News and Information see our web site: http://www.bioenergylists.org/
