+1 The tlds and dtds are an exension of the code in the JAR, and should travel with it.
Ideally, I think there should be a copy of the license in the JAR, and then another in jakarta-struts-lib.zip alongside the other files. -Ted. Martin Cooper wrote: > > Yes, I've (mostly) followed the discussion on 'general'. For Struts, I'd > like to suggest that we consider something which I believe follows the > spirit of that discussion, although it does not follow it literally. > > The Struts 1.0.1 binary distribution currently looks like this: > > jakarta-struts/ > INSTALL > LICENSE > README > lib/ > (struts.jar, tlds, dtds) > webapps/ > (documentation, example and test web apps) > > My interpretation of the spirit of the discussion on 'general' is that it > would be a good idea to make available a minimal binary download, in > addition to the standard binary download. > > In my opinion, for Struts, it would be a *bad* idea to make available the > 'struts.jar' file as the minimal download, independently of the > corresponding tld and dtd files. This would likely lead to many "bug" > reports which are simply the result of mismatched files. > > Therefore my suggestion is that the 'minimal' download be > 'jakarta-struts-lib.zip', which would include only the contents of the > 'jakarta-struts/lib' directory. Regarding the ASF license, we could either > include a copy under 'jakarta-struts/lib' directly, or include a copy in > 'struts.jar', or both. > > Comments? > > -- > Martin Cooper -- To unsubscribe, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]> For additional commands, e-mail: <mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
