Concerning Bill Gottesman's proposal of a method to measure the solar
diameter:

Well, it's basically a very good idea, but there are a number of traps
to watch for.  First, the slits need to be parallel.  They also need
to be aligned closely to North-South (or rather, perpendicular to the
sun's motion at the time the measurement is made).  Finally, what you
are measuring is the time it takes the sun to change its longitude by
one solar diameter, so there is a correction for the declination of
the sun and another for the motion of the Earth around the sun.  If
all you are interested in is the ratio of the solar diameter at the
two solstices, then the first correction cancels out, but not the
second one.

Also, it may be harder to determine a point in time accurately than a
point in space.  I would favor two parallel "pin-slits" casting images
on a plane normal to the suns rays.  The angular diameter (in the
direction perpendicular to the slits, which should be oriented close
to North-South and used near noon to eliminate any residual effects of
atmospheric refraction) is inversely proportional to the distance
between the slits and the plane when the images just touch.  That is,
the measurement consists of moving the plane until the images on it
just touch and then measuring the distance from there to the slits.

--Art Carlson

Reply via email to