Hi Steve and others,

I tried to make light talk about the little Frankenstein Sundial by The
Nobel Collection in my first email (remember the hubbub over the DST human
analemmatic?) but inside I was really pissed off for three reasons:

1.  They cheated my friend, the person who gave it to me and who spent a lot
of money.
2.  I am in direct competition with this company, their product, and their
glamorous false advertising. But I am playing by the rules and they are not.
3.  They don't have an address that I can write to or a number to call.

It was also upsetting that this is just another flawed sundial that we can
add to a growing list of flawed sundials that are flooding our small sundial
market. I couldn't agree more with Steve's concern about this and I also
wonder about existing legislation. I think reputable sundial sellers and the
buying public need a way to protect themselves from this sort thing.

But perhaps there is a better way that wouldn't involve lawsuits.  I know
that before people buy anything, they like to read reviews of what's
currently for sale in the industry. ( That's how I picked out my digital
camera). The internet is LOADED with reviews for just about everything.
Wouldn't it be nice to have a website of Sundial Reviews?  It wouldn't have
to be associated with NASS or BSS. The reviews could be written by a group
of dialists and/or by customers.

I know my idea for a Sundial Makers Association didn't float, but a website
of Sundial Reviews would be a lot less ambitious and very effective.

Just a Thought

John

p.s. If anybody wants to see a close-up photo of the Nobel Frankenstein
Sundial and a scan of their signed "Certificate of Authenticity" that I dug
out of the trash, tell me and I'll sent you an attachment.

I'm mad!

John L. Carmichael Jr.
Sundial Sculptures
925 E. Foothills Dr.
Tucson Arizona 85718
USA

Tel: 520-696-1709
Email: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Website: <http://www.sundialsculptures.com>
----- Original Message -----
From: "Steve Lelievre" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: <[email protected]>
Sent: Sunday, December 29, 2002 1:04 PM
Subject: Re: corrupt instruments


> Sara wrote (snipped)...
>
> > One reader took me to task for my use of the word "corrupt" and perhaps
> > others were equally puzzled.
>
> Well, I for one had no problem seeing it as corrupt (modern). But if we
> don't like corrupt, how about fraudulent?
>
> The site says the dial is "...an  authentic replica  ...exacting in
> detail...calibrated to count the hours by the sun's rays..."
>
> Doesn't the US have any consumer protection legislation to say that
products
> must be fit for the advertised purpose?
>
> Steve
>
> (original, snipped...)
> >  >What bugs me about this kind of rubbish is that for all the effort
that
> >  > went into making the castings, the company could just as easily have
> made
> >  > them right as wrong....Is this just do to ignorance, laziness, or
> > corruptness?
> >
> -
>


-

Reply via email to