Dear Frans,

You are right!  Absolutely right!

> > The expression now turns into a function of time:
> > 
> > a . (coslat/cos(dec(t)) . sqrt(coslat^2 - sin(dec(t))^2)
> > 
> > THIS is the expression to integrate over a whole year and
> > whose average should be found.  THAT result is where the
> > markers should be placed.

Integrating this is does need numerical methods and you could
certainly say that the mathematics now becomes cumbersome!

> I therefore would like to make a plea for the original
> Lambert circles.

Yes, I agree.  I didn't mention Lambert circle but they are
very elegant AND the focal points are invariant AND, as you
say,...

> They are "the real thing", no integration or approximation
> needed.

I agree again but there is one very small problem...

> One just needs a compass, or a pin and a piece of rope for
> a human-sized dial!

I might carry a rope and several pins when climbing mountains
[not very often in the Netherlands, or even in Cambridge :-) ]
so it might be an idea to install such a sundial on some Alpine
plateau.  Unfortunately, I don't very often carry a rope with
me when walking round towns!

I think it would be better just to indicate a selection of
Lambert circles on the dial itself.  They needn't be complete
and six would probably be enough.

[You could draw the major axis of the ellipse as a seventh
(infinite radius) circle if you wish to but anyone who doesn't
know that the time of sunrise at an equinox is 6 o'clock
probably won't be very interested in the Lambert circles!]

Perhaps you should go out with spray paint one night and
mark in some Lambert circles on an analemmatic sundial
near you!!!

Best wishes

Frank King
Cambridge, U.K.

---------------------------------------------------
https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial

Reply via email to