Hello Simon,

Thanks for this information that adds credence to the hypothesis. I am 
posting your note to the sundial mailing list as it will be of interest to 
this rather eclectic group.

Regards, Roger Bailey

----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Simon Cassidy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
To: "Roger Bailey" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Cc: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Sent: Saturday, September 29, 2007 7:46 PM
Subject: Re: God's Longitude and the Lost Colony of Virginia


>
> Roger Bailey wrote:
> .. ..........................[Thomas not James] Harriot, described as the 
> best
>> mathematician Oxford has produced, was employed by Raleigh as a 
>> navigator,
>> astronomer and cartographer. His observations of a solar eclipse on 19 
>> April
>> 1585 on the voyage to Virginia have been used to determine the latitude 
>> and
>> longitude of the ship. Many think that he was on the 1584 voyage as well 
>> and
>> had hoped to observe a lunar eclipse in Virginia in November but the
>> historical records show a earlier return in September to avoid the winter
>> north atlantic storms. See
>> http://www-groups.dcs.st-and.ac.uk/~history/Biographies/Harriot.html The 
>> map
>> John White pained was based on Harriot's accurate surveys in 1585/86. Is
>> there documentary evidence that they accurately measured the longitude? 
>> No,
>> but navigation was a state secret at that time, a strategic asset not to 
>> be
>> shared with your enemies. Drake's voyage is an example of this secrecy. 
>> If
>> they had a longitude fix, the data remains a secret. They certainly had 
>> the
>> capability.
>
> The November 1584 lunar eclipse is an interesting case. The calendric 
> hypothesis,
> for Raleigh's American colonisation attempts, strongly predicts 
> (retrodicts?) that
> there would have been Englishmen left behind over the winter of 1584/85 to 
> time
> this eclipse's phases for longitude determination, especially because this 
> was the
> only lunar eclipse visible in both Virginia and Europe over the years of 
> Raleigh's
> efforts. The fact that the official English accounts (collected by 
> Hakluyt) make no
> mention of such a wintering-over seems to be a strong falsification of the 
> hypothesis
> (other cases of wintering over by small parties of Raleigh's men are 
> recorded, as
> well as the subsequent attempts to locate them).
>
> I took this as a challenge and predicted (in a talk I gave in Berkeley 
> California)
> that evidence in other sources would be found to contradict Hakluyt on 
> this point.
> Several years later I found just such evidence in Spanish archival 
> material which
> described the interrogation of castaway sailors from the 1585 Roanake 
> voyage who
> were told by Simon Fernandez (Raleigh's chief pilot) that they were 
> expecting to
> meet up with two men left in Virginia on his previous voyage.
>
> This eclipse is well-documented in contemporary Spanish material and 
> advance
> instructions were sent out, to Spanish possessions in the Americas, with 
> requests
> and instructions for obtaining local timings of its phases for 
> cartographic
> purposes. In the light of this Spanish awareness, Hakluyt must have 
> suppressed
> the account of any English observers of this eclipse in Virginia.
>
> Dee's Years,
> Simon Cassidy
> 
---------------------------------------------------
https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial

Reply via email to