I happen to own a small version of this exact item.  I must concur with Sara 
that it is not what it purports to be.  I picked up the small (about 5" high) 
version a few years ago as a curiosity - lamenting all the time that the gnomon 
design and placement make the whole thing useless.  This is almost definitely a 
modern attempt (made in several different sizes!) to put one over on emptores 
who ignore the caveat!

Fred Sawyer

  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Sara Schechner 
  To: Josef Pastor 
  Cc: Sundial List 
  Sent: Friday, October 12, 2007 11:08 AM
  Subject: bone terrestrial globe with sundial


  Hello fellow dialists,

  I am very dubious about the ivory  (or bone) globe with the inset sundial on 
a number of grounds--cartographically, horologically, and stylistically.

  First cartographically, I do not see this globe as dating from around 1600.  
The first thematic map showing trade winds was by Edmond Halley in 1686, and an 
early example of trades winds marked by scattered arrows was that of William 
Dampier published in 1699.  I also do not feel that it is in keeping with other 
cartography in terms of style and information of the 17th century   It seems a 
mishmash of information and languages.  But I don't buy the idea that many 
hands made this item, adding to it at different times.  I think a single person 
did it by borrowing from different sources.  The weight of the engraving is the 
same throughout.

  Second, horologically, I need not tell this group that the gnomon is 
misaligned and misplaced.  There is no evidence of it ever being correctly 
placed, and the metal slot for it suggests that it was intentionally put where 
it is now.  No competent  sundial maker or user of this accessory (alleged to 
have been added to the earlier globe in the late 18th century) would have set 
it up this way.  Moreover, the style of decoration and lettering of the 
horizontal dial is different from that used for the globe.  And are we supposed 
to think that the early globe was sawed in half at this later date?  The marks 
on the globe do not suggest this rough treatment.  

  The stand appears to be a marriage of later parts.  

  All in all, it makes me queasy.  

  I have seen small ivory globes, ivory globe sundials, small compass sundials 
inside turned ivory spheres the separate into two hemispheres, and even a 
compass sundial inside a small ivory celestial globe from the early 17th 
century.  This last item is in the British Museum.  None look anything like 
this.    

  Caveat emptor.

  Sara
  Lat 42.4N  Long  -71.1W



  On 10/10/2007 7:31 PM, Josef Pastor wrote: 
    Dear Diallists,



    Exclusive Sundial Offer at EBAY. Does anybody have background knowledge 
concerning this sundial?



    
http://cgi.ebay.com/Antique-Globe-engraved-in-Bone-with-Sundial-inside_W0QQitemZ250174150059QQihZ015QQcategoryZ63593QQcmdZViewItem
 



    Kugelsonnenuhr in Genthin (Germany): Altenplathower Sonnenuhr (1810) soll 
von Schweizer Fachmann restauriert werden:



    
http://www.volksstimme.de/vsm/nachrichten/lokales/genthin/?sid=0e2db9ab8943a7c818ad1c0fe9114797&em_cnt=472182
 

           Best regards

        Josef Pastor 



----------------------------------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------
https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial

  

-- 
Sara Schechner, Ph.D.
David P. Wheatland Curator
Collection of Historical Scientific Instruments
Department of the History of Science
Harvard University, Science Center 251c
1 Oxford Street, Cambridge, MA 02138
Tel: 617-496-9542    
Fax: 617-496-5932

------------------------------------------------------------------------------


  ---------------------------------------------------
  https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial

---------------------------------------------------
https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial

Reply via email to