Greetings, fellow dialists,Thanks to all who have contributed to the little problem of the early Roman 'dial'.
Nicholas Severino wrote: I do not know Roman sundials like this. Vertical clocks reported by Gibbs and those I found at Pompeii and Rome, are very different in style.
Patrick Powers thought that one dial, (Gibbs 5022G), bore a resemblance but it may not be Roman.
Sasch Stephens wondered why I thought it was a dial at all rather than a decoration. Well, it might be as hard to make a decoration of this chunk of stone as make a dial of it. I had considered this in an earlier message though and left it open.
Mario Arnaldi believes with justice that the Romans on Hadrian's Wall had dials (and what appears to be part of a water clock has been found at Vindolanda). He suggests portable dials, however the chunk of stone currently considered is hardly portable, being roughly 30cm by 30cm by 15cm thick. And the Romans occupied Hadrian's Wall for hundreds of years as a permanent settlement.
I think Brent's suggestion that it might be a small millstone is unlikely since a millstone would need a clear run from centre to outer edge while this stone has a perimeter ridge. Moreover, millstones tend not to have grooves radiating like spokes but rather slanting away from the radii.
Jerome Bonnin of Lille University, currently studying Roman dials and water clocks, has sent me a picture (Gibbs 5012) of what he thinks may not be a sundial but almost certainly is. It is a thin stone incised with seasonal hour lines finely cut, unlike the wide grooves of the Chesters dial.
Despite the various difficulties I am yet beginning to think this may be a dial. To act as a dial the stone would have to be positioned as in the attachment (34kb). When viewed like this, on a more detailed photo it seems there is no sign of an hour line on the extreme right of the stone (erosion?) and not even a suggestion of a gnomon hole (although much has been lost here). But still I would say from what appear to be hour lines that the odds are slightly in favour of this being a dial. The Romans did make flat dials and this may be one. If it is a dial then it is most probably the oldest English dial. Let us hope that more information can be found. Thanks again to all.
Frank 55N 1W
<<inline: chesters 2.jpg>>
--------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial
