Dear Geoff,

Many thanks for your kind words...

> Congratulations on implementing a novel dialling
> concept in such a beautiful dial.

As you may infer from the citations in my covering
message: you and  Gianni Ferrari  were the two people
who made me think extra carefully about what I was
doing!

I realised that this might be a controversial dial
because its design compromises strict gnomonic rules.
My account is careful not to hide anything!

> ... your omission of the sunrise/sunset hours
> should be regarded as of no practical disadvantage
> since the timings of these phenomena are evident
> to the observer without the need for a dial.

That was my thinking.  To ordinary mortals, sunrise
and sunset are durations rather than instants so I have
two wavy lines dressed up as sun rays to suggest this
lack of precision :-)

> ... you might have transposed the standard deviation
> values for R1 and R2 in the last sentence of the
> penultimate paragraph on page 30.

Ooops.  You are right.  I have put that right now and,
unless you have a cache which won't let go of the old
version, you should find that

  http://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/users/fhk1/Newnham/write-up.pdf

has that mistake corrected.

Incidentally, I considered calling the two points R1
and R2 the King point and the Thurston point (the
latter being the better!!) but decided to stick with
simple identifiers.

It is huge fun just staring at this dial.  The shadow
of the gnomon is sweeping round from one hour-line to
the next noticeably more quickly now than it was just
a few weeks ago.

Very best wishes

Frank

---------------------------------------------------
https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial

Reply via email to