I wrote the note below quickly, based on recollections of correspondence in 2007 and 2005. Since then I check through my files to see if my recollections were correct. In general they were and I have not changed my opinion. My recollection of of a note quoting Occam's razor was partially correct. This was included in a personal note to Daniel Roth and was not posted by me at that time on the SML. Here is a direct quotation from my 2007 note to Daniel. The problem were were discussing was the rejection of Rawls postings to the SML. The size filter rejecting even small pictures was the problem. this is a common experience we have learned to live with.
"The design of memorial site for the victims on Flight 93 destroyed on 9/11 by Islamic terrorists is now seen by many, including Alec Rawls, to contain inappropriate Islamic symbols: Red crescent oriented to Mecca, minaret as a gnomon indication Moslem prayer time etc. It does not matter at this time if this symbolism is real and intended or it is an over interpreted accidental oversight. Perception is reality. Something that looks like a duck and quacks like a duck, will be seen and judged as such. In my opinion the memorial design must be changed because of the perceived symbolism that is an insult to the victims. Rawls posting focuses on sundial aspects of the 9/11 memorial, the interpretation of the "Tower of Voices" as the minaret and gnomon for a sundial showing a Moslem prayer time. Rawls has provided well documented logic leading to this interpretation. I have checked his figures on the position of prayer line and agree that there is some coincidence, but nowhere near as good a fit as the author suggests by adding complexities. In my opinion, Occam's Razor should be applied and his thesis rejected as an over interpretation." My opinions have not changed. Regards, Roger Bailey From: Roger Bailey Sent: Thursday, October 14, 2010 9:04 PM To: Richard Mallett ; John Carmichael Cc: 'Sundial Mailing List' Subject: Re: Is This True? No, It is not true. This is old news. I engaged in an interesting exchange of information with Alex Rawls and analyzed the tower as a gnomon for Islamic prayers, The whole data does not support the thesis. The Asr prayer line curves the other way. You have to invoke several complexities to achieve any kind of fit. I am satisfied that this is conspiracy theory, based on coincidence and a selective review of the data to support the premise. Add complexities when the facts deviate from the premise as in any classical conspiracy theory. I think this was discussed on the SML previously. I think I quoted Occam's Razor that the simplest explanation is likely correct. "When competing hypotheses are equal in other respects, the principle recommends selection of the hypothesis that introduces the fewest assumptions and postulates the fewest entities while still sufficiently answering the question." That said, the architect showed arrogant insensitivity in choosing a red crescent as the dominant theme for his circle of red maple trees. Yes, the opening in the crescent does sort of point to Mecca. He says these are accidents of the geography of the crash site. Yes, the choice of a tower as the other highlight for the memorial is unfortunate as towers are used by Moslems as minarets for their call to prayer but also by Christians as bell towers. "For Whom the Bell Tolls" is a classic memorial. I give my heartfelt thanks to the rugby team members that said "Let's roll", fought back and brought down the plane before its intended Washington target. It is unfortunate that the memorial site is diminished by this controversy, The architect was insensitive not considering the symbolism of the red crescent and a tower and the opponents are highly sensitive, over-interpreting the evidence. Remember that almost a majority of Americans believe the moon landings were fake, that Kennedy was killed by the Russians or a right wing cabal, that the twin towers were destroyed by Mossad and the CIA and Elvis lives. I remain a skeptical non-believer of these and other widely held beliefs. Regards Roger Bailey From: Richard Mallett Sent: Thursday, October 14, 2010 12:42 PM To: John Carmichael Cc: 'Sundial Mailing List' Subject: Re: Is This True? On 14/10/2010 17:17, John Carmichael wrote: Yesterday, I received an email from a fellow dialist containing the following link to an article written by some group called The Canada Free Press. He wanted to know if I could confirm its veracity. I've heard nothing about it. Have you? In the article it says this, among other things, about the Flight 93 Memorial presently being built in Shanksville Pennsylvania at the crash site: "Another feature of paramount significance is a colossal 93-foot minaret-like tower that Rawls argues indicates time for prayer by functioning as an Islamic sundial." Do any of you know if anything in this article is true? See: http://canadafreepress.com/index.php/article/28649 --------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial This has been going round the Internet for months (years ?) - see a balanced account at :- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flight_93_National_Memorial -- -- Richard Mallett Eaton Bray, Dunstable South Beds. UK -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial
--------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial
