On 25/09/2010 05:01, Roger Bailey wrote:
Hi Jim,

For me, Pluto is a planet. This is based on what led to its discovery, not
the rewriting of science and history by the the new generation that knows
everything  and values nothing.

For a while I was on the advisory board for the Lowell Observatory. My
mountaineering friend, William  Lowell (Bill) Putnam is the trustee of the
Lowell estate, a huge funder of their astronomical research and probably the
most interesting character I have met. While on the board I had the
opportunity to meet the Gene and Carolyn Shoemaker,  John Spencer and Mark
Buie, among others great astronomers. The Shoemakers are best  known for
discovering with the Canadian comet hunter David Levy, Shoemaker-Levi 9, the
comet that hit Jupiter. Gene's ashes are on the moon, a fitting tribute by
NASA for the pioneer in planetary geology. Marc Buie is the foremost Pluto
expert and John Spencer wrote  the book on the Great Comet Crash. I was a
few years too late to meet the early Lowell astronomers, Clyde Tombaugh who
discovered Pluto or Vesto Melvin Slipher who discovered the distance to
galaxies before Hubble. Slipher studied the Andromeda Galaxy that show a
blue rather than red shift as it is a member of our local group and is not
receding but coming towards us. The Nobels gave no credit to the pioneering
stellar spectrographer who discovered blue shift when awarding the prizes.

The effete intellectual astronomical elite continues to denigrate the
accomplishments of an privately funded observatory that continues to be at
the forefront of astronomical science.  I continue to believe in the nine
discovered planets, as in "Man Very Early Made Jars Stand Up Nearly
Perpendicular". Of course, Pluto is a Kuiper Belt object captured by the
sun. There are many like it now being found and some are bigger. This takes
nothing away from the history of Percival Lowell, an rich astronomy
dilettante and Clyde Tombaugh, a simple farm boy who discovered astronomy,
telescopes and the PLANET PLUTO.

Regards,
Roger Bailey

The IAU definition of a planet as an object orbiting the Sun that has cleared its neighbourhood seems to me to be seriously flawed, as it excludes :-

extra-solar planets (which don't orbit the Sun)
Earth (because there are near Earth objects)
Jupiter (because there are Trojan asteroids)
Neptune (because there are trans-Neptunian objects)

--
--
Richard Mallett
Eaton Bray, Dunstable
South Beds. UK


---------------------------------------------------
https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial

Reply via email to