Hi David, I don't know anything about the Hunt problems but when I clicked the link that you provided to his site, I see the first glaring error that is made in many of these dials...I believe. Shouldn't there be just a single line that you straddle. His picture shows a person very much standing to one side and implying that you would stand on the other side during the opposite half of the year. Fritz
-----Original Message----- From: David Andersson Sent: Wednesday, August 17, 2016 3:30 PM To: Sundial Mailing List Subject: Re: Re: Double analemma dials
In message <[email protected]> "fabio.savian" <[email protected]> wrote:
I know an analemmatic sundial may have sophisticated versions to show mean time, Fred your article is exhaustive, but I think it isn't the better kind of sundial to give this info and to get a precison time (position on the heels or on the middle of the feet, how vertical is the hand rising above the head, estimation of the direction of the shadow, graduations of the minutes, etc). Conversely it is a very powerful instrument to involve people with gnomonics. Anyway I think a simple analemma on the meridian line, without explain its huge limits, is not an option, it is an error. thank you, ciao, Fabio Fabio Savian
As far as Analemmatic sundials are concerned, surely the person who can be thanked for making these interactive features so popular all over the world must be Douglas Hunt of "Modern Sunclocks" in the UK who is responsible for these being installed in thousands of school playgrounds - plus famous Stately Homes and even the "Space Shuttle Memorial" (at Racine, Wisconsin), and his 'Human Sundials' are even mentioned within school-books due to the many educational benefits. I do not think that he subscribes to this Mailing List (having been 'chased away' many years ago, by people who were jealous of his own international success) - but I seem to remember some discussions on this List around 2 years ago, when Frank King (Chairman of "British Sundial Society") said that it was an excellent design due to self- adjusting to/from Daylight-Saving and coping with shadow lengths at different times of year in a better way than 'traditional' layouts. His website (www.sunclocks.com), even has a link to Brian Albinson. Doug's design does NOT use any Analemma, which is as this should be because (in my personal opinion) it would only 'confuse' the people who simply want to see their shadow indicating clock time (agreeing with their wrist-watch) - plus is maybe why "Sunclocks" have become so popular within public areas, compared with the more conventional sundials which could be costly as well as subject to theft/vandals. At the risk of having 'brickbats' thrown at me, I must explain that I have no "axe to grind" here - but I do think that Doug Hunt could be acknowledged for the services he has given to advancing both the popularity and understanding of sundials (of all types), especially with school-children who will become our 'Diallists of the future". Sincerely, Dave Andersson. -- --------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial --------------------------------------------------- https://lists.uni-koeln.de/mailman/listinfo/sundial
