Hi Scott,

PFSense Version Beta2 Full Install
2WAN + Lan

Myself being a MultiWan and Load Balancing User I thought that you may
appreciate some feed back.

I first did the CVS update on the 19th or 20th March when you announced the
changes. 

PFSense box already configured, as a working load balance. I created the
Static Routes and checked to use the Interface as a GW. (I remembered seeing
this available in the Snapshot Releng 03-10-2006, it didn’t work for me
then). I had to reinstall to be able to continue business for the following
day.

I retried the newer CVS update 03-20-2006 and re-setup the Static routes for
the Interfaces and DNS addresses per Interface. But it made no difference to
being able to Fail-Over DNS. I associated this to be a conflict with my
working DualWAN (Round Robin). Reinstalled for next work day.

23Mar06. 3.30AM
I reinstalled PFSense and did an update via cvs_sync.sh releng_1. This
produced a couple of errors at the end of the update, failed to open debug
in path /usr/local/lib/php/extensions/no-debug-non-zts-20020429/.... I went
looking for the file manually via the CVSTrack but found that the reason why
it could not open the file is that it had not been updated. I presumed that
this was known and I continued ignoring the error MSG.

SETUP Load Balance + Failover
I first setup the Interfaces to allocate IP Addresses.
I then setup the Load Balance
I setup the Static Routes allocating the Wan and Opt interfaces as Gateways
I then configured the NATs for all interfaces
Then the Firewall Rules for All Interfaces

Results:

There was a Failover of sorts, the remaining interface would not resolve the
URL immediately but with coaxing a couple of times it would eventually find
the page.

Modifying NATs and Rules made no positive differences to the viewing of any
page.

I then left the PFSense configured with the DualWan Load Balance + FailOver
ready for work at 5.15AM.

When Staff began work at 7.15AM the PFSense box was not passing traffic in
any direction and could not ping any outside IP or host from the console. A
restart was performed and tried again. Again the traffic only flowed for a
short time period before stalling.

To continue operations for the day, a complete reinstall was done
reconfigured by using a restore of the working config, but this did not pass
traffic (seems to be a problem in Beta2 for some reason as I have tried this
a number of times with the same results, it unsuccessfully restores).
Another reinstall was done and manually configured DualWan Load Balanced,
NATTED and Ruled in 20 minutes.

If it is any help, when I next do a DualWan Load Balance + Failover I can
send you a copy of the config in File.txt. I don’t think that it would tell
you anything that you would not already be aware of though. But it may
confirm in my mind that I have not forgotten or overlooked something.

In case this has been an oversight, the Subnet in the Rules pages are Max of
31 not 32 as in all other events of the subnet. So a Static Internet IP is
unable to be selected to create rules for. If it is intentional, then you
must have a reason for it. 

Anyway, thanks for a great Firewall.

BTW, Endian announced their release yesterday and the Features are not half
as good as PFSense. I looked at theirs before I discovered PFSense. Now that
I'm here, I wont use anything else.  www.efw.it 

Kindest Regards,
 
Craig Roy
Horizon IT Consultants
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 

-- 
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Anti-Virus.
Version: 7.1.384 / Virus Database: 268.2.6/288 - Release Date: 22/03/2006
 


---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to